4 ms·
That's not how 1Password works. All passwords for 1Password are stored locally in an AES encrypted file. They never see, touch, or have any control over your pa
by Accelerata 12y ago
That's not how 1Password works. All passwords for 1Password are stored locally in an AES encrypted file. They never see, touch, or have any control over your passwords on their end. Even if they suddenly shut down tomorrow, all your passwords would still be accessible unless you chose to delete the application and have zero backups to restore from.
They even have an export function to dump the passwords (unencrypted) into a plain text or CSV file, so you can easily migrate the data to a new manager if needed.
- Dobbs 12y agoYou are 100% correct. To add to this all syncing on 1Password is done using 3rd party vendors. You can use dropbox, iCloud, Google Drive, etc to do the actual syncing of the encrypted files.
- mikepurvis 12y agoI use Dropbox, but my password for Dropbox itself is stored inside 1Password. The escape hatch is that the 1Password sync folder is shared publicly, and the URL is copied to a slip of paper in my wallet.
- newman314 12y agoWhy would you ever expose the sync folder publicly? Just keep a copy on a local computer with Dropbox if need be.
- mikepurvis 12y agoBecause I only have one computer and no mobile devices— therefore I only have one copy of the password database, and I need the password database to access Dropbox. The sync folder is encrypted—is there some risk I'm not seeing?
- newman314 12y agoPersonally, I don't believe in leaving something like a password database exposed. That's akin to leaving a safe in the street. While someone might not be able to get in right away, why make it easier? For you, I would just keep a copy elsewhere (friends computer etc.) or just get an additional device (mobile or otherwise).
- newman314 12y agoNo true. I sync using BT Sync and it works fine. It's just not interpreted with 1Password like Dropbox is.
- hrrsn 12y ago> dropbox, iCloud, Google Drive, etc Point being the sync is platform agnostic. The etcetera covers BT Sync.
- meowface 12y agoI still don't see the benefits of 1Password from a cost perspective, regardless of a trust perspective. I can spend $40-80 and buy a bunch of 1Password license packages, or I can use KeePass and place the database in my Dropbox folder. Yes, 1Password has a more aesthetic interface, but otherwise it basically does the exact same thing.
- cpach 12y agoIMO, the big question is: Who do you trust more when it comes to cryptography and security engineering? The 1Password developers or the KeePass developers?
- eridius 12y agoNot only that but the format of the file is fully documented, so even if they were to shut down tomorrow and the application itself self-destruct, someone can still write a new app to decrypt the password "keychain" without much difficulty.