2 ms·
This is just silly. The problem with columnists/pundits who argue for investing in xyz "because we're falling behind" particularly where it relates to immature
by cwan 17y ago
This is just silly. The problem with columnists/pundits who argue for investing in xyz "because we're falling behind" particularly where it relates to immature technologies is that governments have a notoriously bad track record at playing/picking favorites that ultimately win out.
Taking this column specifically, what if it turns out that natural gas is far cheaper and far more abundant than solar - at least in the mid and near term? (after you factor in recent shale gas discoveries, it is). Why not instead develop technologies through companies that enable solar like Applied Materials and in the meantime buy subsidized panels from other countries if that's your cup of tea?
I should note that many of us here are also aware and even aim to replace longstanding competitors who are larger, often better capitalized and are certainly more entrenched with technologies that are cheaper, without the legacy overhead costs and are more agile. Why shouldn't this happen in solar/energy?
In solar in particular, look at thin film solar firms like Nanosolar - http://www.treehugger.com/files/2009/09/nanosolar-solar-power-efficiency-germany-factory-mass-production.php http://www.treehugger.com/files/2009/09/nanosolar-solar-powe... - yes, one of their robotic plant may be in Germany, but it is a US developed technology that may end up being far cheaper than traditional solar panels. If anything, American firms have shown when the incentive exists, they can play catch up and they can do it quickly and generally better as US dominance across an array of industries shows (disclosure: I'm a Canadian).
This, incidentally is what can happen when the subsidies go away: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB125193815050081615.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB125193815050081615.html