2 ms·
ok, I think we are quite different but let me address just two things. For (4), are you suggesting that a company first pays for the bandwidth, and then pays a
by kristopolous 12y ago
ok, I think we are quite different but let me address just two things.
For (4), are you suggesting that a company first pays for the bandwidth, and then pays again, for essentially the privilege to use the bandwidth paid for? (Given the Verizon/Level3 debacle, it was clearly shown that the networks are at about 40% capacity - so the narrative of scarcity or oversubscription is false - can't be used, sorry.)
And for (6), I'm suggesting that conglomerate companies have industries they are good at, and those they aren't. I wouldn't expect to buy an automobile manufactured by starbucks - and furthermore if starbucks went out to manufacture automobiles, everything from the board of directors down would be poorly suited for the task - they are in the food services business - it's fundamentally different.
So the idea here is that perhaps some of these modern cable service providers should be entertainment companies and not distributing in-house hardware or laying out the internet infrastructure - they may be terribly structured for that job.
- exelius 12y agoNo, I'm suggesting that a company like Netflix pays to deliver traffic directly to a company like Comcast. Netflix only pays once (they're paying Comcast instead of paying Level3/Cogent, at least for delivering to Comcast customers). I think our big difference of opinion comes in the understanding of the industry. Content and distribution have always been intimately linked. In fact, that's the whole disagreement: Netflix is performing content distribution but is not paying for the full cost of that distribution. Inexplicably, a lot of people feel those costs should be pushed to the consumer (i.e. "I already pay once for Internet! Netflix shouldn't have to pay because I already do!") rather than to the company making the profit off the specific act of a user watching a video (who will inevitably push those costs to the consumer, but only to THEIR consumers). Netflix's business model is nearly identical to HBO's. The only difference is that HBO bills through the cable companies and Netflix does not. But the cable companies take a cut of HBO's earnings for distribution. Netflix wasn't paying that until recently.
- TheCraiggers 12y ago>Netflix's business model is nearly identical to HBO's. The only difference is that HBO bills through the cable companies and Netflix does not. But the cable companies take a cut of HBO's earnings for distribution. Netflix wasn't paying that until recently. You're probably right about that. However, I don't agree with the FCC being lobbied in order to protect an aged revenue model and further increasing lock-in. That shouldn't be the FCC's purpose. The whole thing smacks of the laws some states are enacting trying to prevent Tesla from selling cars online, etc.
- kristopolous 12y agoI think the ISP should be a common-carrier and unbiased vehicle for the open exchange of information that makes the Internet so intellectually critical. It sounds like you prefer them to be a privately held entity with zero civic obligations. I really wish that there was a metaphorical wall between entities that facilitate the civic function of a press and these more or less chicanery-based private corps. I'm terribly worried about the fact that the fate of modern discourse, society planning, press, arts, and culture essentially lies in the hands of the people whose primary goal is to bring commercially sponsored leisure distractions to the living room - their interests are too narrow and their vision of the task is too thin - as if we asked the Orville Redenbacher corporation to single-handidly draw up agricultural subsidization, land use, and disbursement policy (I bet their suggestions would favor more popcorn and leave 80% of the problem unsolved.)