6 ms·
Teacher certification a painful farce
- Locke1689 17y agoI have a BS in Foreign Service from Georgetown What? If you can get a Bachelor of Science in something not even tangentially related to science then what is the degree for?
- euroclydon 17y agoEver hear of Political Science? My wife majored in it, and she used to always talks about her statistics course; doesn't know a lick of stats though.
- eru 17y ago"The misnaming of fields of study is so common as to lead to what might be general systems laws. For example, Frank Harary once suggested the law that any field that had the word "science" in its name was guaranteed thereby not to be a science. He would cite as examples Military Science, Library Science, Political Science, Homemaking Science, Social Science, and Computer Science. Discuss the generality of this law, and possible reasons for its predictive power." (Gerald Weinberg, "An Introduction to General Systems Thinking") [Actually it's from the fortune program.]
- Locke1689 17y agoEh, I at least understand getting a BS in computer science degree if it's in the engineering school. As an engineer I'm required to take a very math and science heavy course load and all the various engineering core curricula. In addition, I can see computer science as being categorized as science for historical reasons, but if it's not science it is at least applied mathematics. Given that applied math is an engineering degree, I see no reason why computer science shouldn't be. In contrast, not only does political science have nothing to do with science, but the course requirements aren't even science related. Maybe, if you're lucky, you'll take one basics statistics course. However, I have yet to see a polisci course that requires differential equations.
- eru 17y agoYes. I just posted the fortune cookie because it's funny. In German we talk about natural sciences (Naturwissenschaften) and mind sciences (Geisteswissenschaften). I guess it's just in English that sciencies implies natural sciences. Interestingly, while using math is in practice the hallmark of a proper science, in theory the experiment as final arbiter separates the sciences from the rest. So math, with no experiments to rely on, is not considered a proper science.
- Locke1689 17y agoYou're not gonna believe this but I was going to say the same thing. I speak German and was going to mention Naturwissenschaften/Geisteswissenschaften but I figured no one else on HN spoke German so it wouldn't be that helpful :) BTW I wasn't using math as an example of why computer science is a science, but rather why it can be justified that computer science gets placed in the school of engineering and one earns a B.S.
- Perceval 17y agoAs a graduate of the Georgetown School of Foreign Service, I feel it's my duty to point out that the major difference between the core requirements of the SFS and the College of Arts & Sciences is that you have no math or science core requirement in the SFS. I think you end up having econ take the place of math & science in the SFS's core requirements, but the basic econ courses (micro, macro, int'l trade, int'l finance) do not require anything more than knowledge of algebra. So yes, it is quite possible to get a political science degree and not know a single thing about math or science beyond your high school education.
- DannoHung 17y agoSome sort of historical precedent, it seems. The school that gives that degree out within Georgetown was established with the express purpose of training diplomats post-WW1. Like, sort of a MBA but for politics and diplomacy?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- apowell 17y agoMy wife, a civil engineer from Georgia Tech, was told she did not have enough college math credits to become a teacher in California. If she wanted to teach here, she would need to take another college math class, such as basic algebra.
- skolor 17y agoTo throw my anecdote in there: Several years ago my family moved to Florida to be closer to my grandparents. My mother found out that the only teaching position she was "qualified" to do was as a substitute teacher. She had previously taught several different levels of Science in a different state, had a BS in Biology, a Masters in Chemistry and a Law Degree (Teaching was actually the 5th profession she tried). In order to teach science in Florida, she would be required to take roughly a year and a half worth of college courses, and get a different certification.
- lief79 17y agoThis is probably closely connected to why Florida is in the bottom 25% of states in terms of school quality. The red tape scares away some of the best teachers. Of course, I'm not sure any of those rankings compensate for social-economic factors that will skew these factors. What I have heard is that the Florida districts really set back the migrant students who ended up in my Mother in Laws classroom in NJ for part of every year. That might be due to them ending up in some of Florida's worst school districts of course.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoA friend of mine from grad school had a similar experience. Her daughter's school was short a math teacher and couldn't offer AP calc (which the daughter wanted to take). She offered to teach a class below calculus to free up a teacher for calc. For free, if necessary. She was told she wasn't qualified. Her degrees: Ph.D. in Math, USA College. B.S. Math, Not USA college. No masters. Her undergrad degree was apparently not sufficient. (I'm obscuring some details to protect the guilty.)
- uhybouy 17y ago
- jdminhbg 17y agoFrom my anecdotal experience, maddening red tape like this is much more of a problem for attracting quality teachers than pay is. There are lots of people who are smart and driven but don't care much about money; just look at the ranks of the non-profit world. But you have to be a special kind of crazy to want to put up with these Kafkaesque rules.
- cwan 17y agoI suspect this may a primary driver of net based education. Certainly it probably won't replace elementary and primary schools, but if accreditation can be achieved online, then you don't have to fuss with the "middleman" - which in this case often means dealing with arcane rules that protect the tenure of educators versus promoting quality education. I think I remember a Fred Wilson or Paul Kedrosky post a ways back on how home schooling was a particularly attractive market for education delivered over the net as a starting point.
- timwiseman 17y agoThis again is anecodotal, but my wife is in the process of working on her master's thesis in history. She went for the master's for personal development reasons, but now that she is close to getting it she started looking at what she wanted to do to pay off the student loans and thought of teaching. Once she finishes she will meet the requirements to apply as a full instructor at the multiple community colleges within commuting distance, and as and adjunct professor/instructor at both the local 4 year college and the university she is about to graduate from. To teach at the public high schools though, she will need to go back and complete classes in education the equivalent of another full-time year in college.
- lief79 17y agoPractically speaking, at a minimum, she should be required to demonstrate an ability to student teach for a half year before being hired. There are definitely some tricks to running a good classroom, but I have no idea if the education courses are in anyway connected to what is needed for the real experience. At a minimum, I would hope they would provide some guidance in how to compensate for different learning styles, how to properly handle difficult students, etc.
- thras 17y agoTeacher certification is vitally important: it props up teacher wages. Oh, did anyone think it had another purpose? Education is a funny field. When you test the IQ of people by university subject, you generally find that the hard sciences have the highest IQs (physics and math at the top) followed by the social sciences followed by the artsy stuff. Education is at the very bottom. However, in every field but education, you find that people with PhDs are smarter than the people with Master's who tend to be smarter than people with just BS or BA degrees. Education is the only field where this is reversed. The people with PhDs are the dumbest of the lot. I heard a funny story once about someone who cheated on his teacher certification exam. He had failed twice and was about to lose his job. So he paid a homeless person to take the test for him. They only caught the cheater because the homeless guy scored better than anyone else in the district and officials got curious about the improvement.
- eru 17y agoSources?
- req2 17y agoRobin Hanson has some citations in this post: http://www.overcomingbias.com/2009/05/econ-neglects-licensing.html http://www.overcomingbias.com/2009/05/econ-neglects-licensin...
- nazgulnarsil 17y agorant warning I may get voted down simply for using loaded phrases, but stepping around them would be laborious. the largest labor unions in the US (Teachers, AMA, etc) operate off a marxist labor theory. this is completely fucking ridiculous considering the average education level of these organization's members. how long is it going to take basic econ to sink into the general knowledge base of humanity? the world seems completely mired in mid 19th century economic thought. If we can't at least get to the level of understanding marginal utility it is going to kill us. More modern economic theories are paid lip service to in the form of being implemented whenever doing so is politically expedient. This is the polar opposite of the spirit of econ. An economist by definition looks past the consequences that are of immediate concern to the public/political body. OTOH: massive tech improvements causing changes to society will probably hit before we WWIII ourselves with our economic ignorance so all the angst may be for nothing. that is if economic ignorance doesn't (continue to) severely hamper technological improvements to the point that we fall short of saving ourselves from ourselves.
- trafficlight 17y agoIronically, my wife has a problem of too much education. She graduated in 2006 with a bachelor's in both Elementary Education and English as a Second Language. She tried to get a job for a year somewhere in the state (Montana). No one would hire her because she didn't have enough practical education. So she went back and got her Master's in English as a Second Language. Also while doing so she taught at the school to build up her "contracted" work experience. Now she doesn't even get interviews for elementary teaching positions because she has too much education and too much experience. Most of the school districts have a policy to hire only those fresh out of school because they can pay them less. My wife is a very talented teacher and just wants to be able to teach. She doesn't care about the money and would be happy to take the lowest pay grade available. Union rules require that they pay her at her experience/education level. I have no hope for the public system.
- lief79 17y agoThen she should be applying at the private schools, who still have the option of paying her less.
- marze 17y agoNo surprises here, anything that reduces supply increases price (of a teacher) is lobbied for by the powerful teachers unions.
- wsprague 17y agoI think the teaching certification cluster is due to a few cultural dynamics: 1. There is an overall trend to more bureaucratization, and bureaucracies often evaluate their officers based on formal certification, especially when there is no structure to measure output. So I support wide spread standardized testing .... 2. The public educational system is designed to enculturate the entire population, including a big proportion of folks that are needed to provide working class labor and reproduction of more working class laborers. So if 80% of the country get a crappy education due to a certification system that rewards mediocrity and punishes excellence, then the system has succeeded. 3. Good education hurts. Not be Nietszchean (sp?) or anything, but most people are taught that fun and ease are the highest ideals in life -- how can you really teach if you, your administrators, the kids, and the parents all believe that you should maximize personal pleasure rather than maximize personal accomplishment? I apologize for the rant, but the unbelievably bad education in the US is probably the issue that most infuriates me.
- mattmcknight 17y agoMakes me think about how programmer certification would work in the context of licensing. Working as a government contractor, we already see a fair amount of certification requirements. At least those are tests though, just taking courses doesn't guarantee much of anything.
- teeja 17y agoLike most standardized testing ... like the largely invisible 'accreditation' establishment ... like most education ... certification has been politicized. That's because education has been twisted into a vehicle of social-engineering. I'll quote Zinn the Wise here: "... honest, and therefore unmanageable."