19 ms·
Uber ordered to halt transportation services in Germany
Google translated article: http://www.google.com/translate?hl=en&ie=UTF8&sl=auto&tl=en&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.spiegel.de%2Fwirtschaft%2Funternehmen%2Fuber-gericht-stoppt-taxidienst-in-ganz-deutschland-a-989332.html
- sschueller 12y agoGoogle Translate: http://www.google.com/translate?hl=en&ie=UTF8&sl=auto&tl=en&u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.spiegel.de%2Fwirtschaft%2Funternehmen%2Fuber-gericht-stoppt-taxidienst-in-ganz-deutschland-a-989332.html http://www.google.com/translate?hl=en&ie=UTF8&sl=auto&tl=en&...
- duncan_bayne 12y agoTo quote Rand: "There is no way to legislate competition; there are no standards by which one could define who should compete with whom, how many competitors should exist in any given field, what should be their relative strength or their so-called “relevant markets,” what prices they should charge, what methods of competition are “fair” or “unfair.” None of these can be answered, because these precisely are the questions that can be answered only by the mechanism of a free market."
- sschueller 12y agoA truly free market is not ethical. A certain amount of regulation is required to protect people from each other.
- nhstanley 12y agoYup. In a truly free market, murder is totally fine. Kill your competition, literally! There's a reason we don't live in Randian fantasy worlds.
- jasonisalive 12y agoNo, that's not true. Free != permissive of nonconsensual interactions. For a free market to work, there must be common respect for individual autonomy. People must enter into contracts of their own free will.
- pgeorgi 12y ago> People must enter into contracts of their own free will. That requires a degree of abundance (so people can refuse to enter contracts) that makes competition obsolete. As is, people are required to enter into contracts else they perish.
- aikah 12y ago> For a free market to work, there must be common respect for individual autonomy. That's why that utopia cannot work. Because individuals will always use the shortest and quickest way to get what they want at the expense of others. Anarchism and Communism have/had the same problem as for their simplistic understanding of human nature which can only lead to wrong the conclusions,and the wrong ideas,even though the thought that led to these conclusion might be genuine. If a precondition states that ,in order for a system to work, people should "naturaly" respect this or that rule, well your system is broken at first place. Mankind is about order and chaos,and balance between them.People cant regulate themself.Sometimes they accept order because it suits their interests and see the benefits,but during most of human history chaos "ruled".And there is no guarantee most of the order that led the "western civilization" will last. > People must enter into contracts of their own free will. Define free will. If someone cant understand all the consequences of his actions before taking a decision, that's not free will. And noone can get the entire picture, or that person would be god himself. And who will enforce contractual obligations ? These 2 preconditions in order for your system to work are metaphysical at best,I would consider them a lie,because they cannot be fufilled.
- claudius 12y agoThankfully, this is not intended to legislate competition but the safety of passengers and other users of the tax-financed public roads. Your point being?
- holri 12y agoThe court says they are violating laws. What has this to do with a free market? Is a free market one without laws? Is anarchy free market?
- aianus 12y agoOther than maintaining liability insurance like any other driver, I don't see the need for any of these added protections. IMO consumers do not want to pay the cost of these protections and they should be able to make their own well-informed choices instead of being forced to buy them by the state. The cynic in me thinks this is less about consumer protection and more about well-funded taxi lobbies which benefit from the regulatory capture.
- holri 12y agoWell, than the Germans have to vote for a more liberal government. But they did the opposite, the liberals just lost their parliament seats.
- aianus 12y agoJust because the government is elected democratically doesn't mean individual laws are just or reflect the will of the constituents. There's no incentive for the government to side with the consumers on this issue since politicians profit through taxi medallions, political contributions from taxi companies, etc and it's not a big enough issue for anyone to change their votes.
- Xylakant 12y agoI doubt that there's a lot of political contributions from taxi companies. The market is very different from the US - in Berlin the 7000 Taxis are mostly owned by companies having anywhere between 1 and a handful of cars. A medallion costs the administration fee and can be freely obtained, they're more or less unlimited. Certainly, the cab owners are somewhat organized and have some influence, but the degree is much lower than that. Uber alone has more lobbying power.
- malka 12y ago> There is no way to legislate competition Reality checking in.
- pgeorgi 12y agoIt's not about legislating competition. It's about Uber avoiding regulations (that the taxi coops already implement): insurance for passengers, insurance for commercial car use, car checkups every year instead of every second (like for private cars), yearly health check for the driver. That's essentially it, and as soon as Uber follows the rules, they can operate freely. They can organize it themselves (with employed drivers) or require their freelance drivers to do so. If their business model doesn't allow for that, their business model is flawed, and the German society has no obligation to bear Uber's costs just so they can feel "disruptive". [edit: it's somewhat more involved given that the court refers to PBefG, which as a whole needs some creative interpretation to allow for Uber to work, eg. running things as "car rental with driver" (which requires that customers don't state where they want to drive to beforehand). Still, Uber tries to work around any and all regulations, and it's no surprise that this won't be tolerated, and for good reason.]
- yoodenvranx 12y agoThere is also the thing that cabs in Germany always _have_ to provide service, regardless of vacation, weather and so on. A private might decide to operate only at those times of the day with a lot of potential customers but that is not possible for official cab companies. The same goes for heavy rain and snow and so on.
- _pmf_ 12y ago> There is also the thing that cabs in Germany always _have_ to provide service, regardless of vacation, weather and so on. A private might decide to operate only at those times of the day with a lot of potential customers but that is not possible for official cab companies. In my experience as a German waiting for a taxi after midnight in a suburban area (but with a major road going through), this is a merely theoretical construct. I've called 3 taxi providers in the rough area; the result was a brisk 1.5 hour walk home because they did not seem all to interested in dispatching a driver to that location at that time. I might have a theoretical legal handle on this behavior, but I doubt this has ever been successfully challenged in court (since the providers can always weasel out by claiming the did not have and free drivers at this moment).
- _pmf_ 12y ago> "None of these can be answered, because these precisely are the questions that can be answered only by the mechanism of a free market." By that logic, we should happily accept monopolies, cartels and huge conglomerates. The notion that the free market is beneficial to society as a whole was a cute idea, but the slave workers of Foxconn are probably not quite in agreement.
- simonh 12y agoThe workers in south china queue round the block for hours to apply for jobs at Foxxcon and other high tech manufacturers. They're some of the best paying manufacturing jobs in the area and are lifting hundreds of thousands of families out of rural poverty.Some become team leaders, get involved in negotiating wages and working conditions, or take classes and move up to secretarial and administrative positions. Many of these workers are women and are returning to the countryside with experience, training and even line workers often have the capital to start their own businesses. As a result it's also leading to a sea change in the position of women in rural society. http://www.cnn.com/2012/09/30/opinion/chang-chinese-factory-workers/ http://www.cnn.com/2012/09/30/opinion/chang-chinese-factory-...
- cousin_it 12y agoIn the past few months I've been trying to find strong arguments against free-market beliefs. Here's what I have so far: 1) Saying that some businesses ought to disappear due to the invisible hand of the market, is just like saying that things ought to stay down due to the invisible hand of gravity. The market is a powerful force, but that doesn't mean its outcome is always what we want. 2) It's a feature of the free market that firms go out of business all the time. But from a market point of view, people are like small firms that sell labor. We don't want a system where people can "go out of business" and be unable to survive, because that's inhumane. It looks like (1) proves that we need some restrictions on competition, and (2) proves that we need some redistribution. We may quibble about how much, but taking a Strong Principled Stance against these things seems wrong.
- Padding 12y ago> But from a market point of view, people are like small firms that sell labor. We don't want a system where people can "go out of business" and be unable to survive, because that's inhumane. You're conflating issues here. Something (or someone) that's not adding any value to an economy has no place (and no reason to participate) in it. That being said, letting people starve is obviously inhumane. However, the answer to this isn't opening up bullshit positions in the economy, by introducing artificial inefficiencies, in order to accomodate those otherwise "useless" people. Regulations (ideally) are there to keep the markets efficient (in the long term) by maintaining "fairness". Not to ensure that individual humans don't starve. Keeping people, that are unable to support themselves, alive and well is a welfare issue, and is not otherwise adressed by markets (directly).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- cousin_it 12y agoHmm. I guess many free market proponents also conflate these issues, when they claim that free markets and wealth redistribution are opposed to each other. That said, I have sympathy for the idea that markets and welfare can work well together. I've long suspected that "the welfare state is a libertarian's wet dream", e.g. a system of universal basic income would allow more people to become entrepreneurs because the risk would be lower. Not sure how Ayn Rand missed that point.
- legulere 12y agoThere are several real world examples where regulation was needed for a market (in contrast to a monopoly) to be created.
- adamnemecek 12y agoHow do you know that you can completely ignore someone's opinion? They quote Ayn Rand.
- thu 12y agoFree market can destroy itself, for instance by the creation of a monopoly. How to apply the mechanism of the free market, as good as it can be, if it disappears ? Anyway here, it's not about competition (that's what they want you to believe it is), it's about regulations (e.g. ensure some safety rules).
- icebraining 12y agoFree market can destroy itself, for instance by the creation of a monopoly. Can it? Are there any good examples of a market with a significant size (with enough profits to support multiple suppliers) devolving into a monopoly without any "help" from outside the market?
- gambiting 12y agoUS and Comcast situation? The market is huge(pretty much everyone needs Internet), the profits are huge as well, yet in a lot of places Comcast has dominated the market.
- aianus 12y agoThat's a government granted monopoly, not a natural one.
- icebraining 12y agoComcast hasn't dominated the market through market forces, it bought it from AT&T in 2001. Comcast has now ~21M customers - AT&T Broadcast, which they bought, had 22M. AT&T, has one should know, was a legal monopoly; hardly a free market participant.
- rhino369 12y agoAcquisition is a free market tool.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- digitalengineer 12y agoCareful now. It's daytime in Europe, so the more Laisser faire (US-free-market-style) arguments have a higher change of getting down voted. This will correct a bit in about 6 hours when the East Coast wakes up. I'm not judging it, it's just the way us europeans are 'wired'. The taxi market is one ripe thats ripe for disruption. There's lots of demand and low, all-the-same companies offering a low quality/high cost service. It's also one thats build a lot of rules around it, some for the clients protection and a lot to prevent competition. Large established companies always prefer more rules because it absolutely kills new companies trying to enter a market.
- jacquesm 12y agoThe taxi market is absolutely ripe for disruption. But GP did not provide any reasons why Uber should be the way to do it. Taxi companies are regulated for a variety of reasons, not just to keep out the competition and as far as I know nothing stops Uber drivers from getting the same certifications as regular taxis. If they do that and they are still blocked or if they are denied certification then you have a genuine case of unfair competition. Until then Uber is tilting the playing field in their direction by offering a product that competes unfairly with the regulated drivers. Maybe this is the only way in which such a regulation effort can be challenged but I'm not convinced of that. As for the 'careful now' and so on bits, anybody quoting Ayn Rand verbatim without adding much to the conversation is probably going to get downvoted, it's not as if she's an authority in the field of economics, and most of her writing displays a shockingly bad understanding of the field.
- digitalengineer 12y agoThank you for the insights. A quick reply: >Taxi companies are regulated for a variety of reasons Correct. But mostly because they made a mess of their nr1 job: transporting people Today we have new and far better ways t regulate a driver's behavior. Payment in advance, navigation to check the route and a easy way to judge the driver afterwards. That takes care of most of the complaints.
- 12y ago
- jacquesm 12y agoThe court order is here: http://docs.dpaq.de/7814-beschluss-landgericht-ffm_uber-taxi-deutschland_2014-09-01.pdf http://docs.dpaq.de/7814-beschluss-landgericht-ffm_uber-taxi... It's (obviously) in German. The fines are 250K per violation, Uber has already announced they will fight this. Uber is looking for a communications lead in Germany: https://www.uber.com/jobs/18835 https://www.uber.com/jobs/18835 , they'll definitely be needing that and more. Deutsche Welle has it here (in English): http://www.dw.de/smartphone-app-uber-ordered-to-halt-transportation-services-in-germany/a-17894286 http://www.dw.de/smartphone-app-uber-ordered-to-halt-transpo... edit: thanks!
- pgeorgi 12y agonitpick: dw is "Deutsche Welle".
- recentdarkness 12y agoimho not really a nitpick, it's just plain wrong. As 'Die Welle' refers to a completely different thing ;-) So yes it is 'Deutsche Welle'
- Smrchy 12y agoI live in Germany and i am happy that some things are more regulated here. I like that Taxi companies need to have extra insurance and the cars and drivers are checked on a regular basis. Just like the TÜV (a mandatory checkup every two years for every vehicle) makes sure all vehicles have functioning lights, brakes, proper tires etc. This ruling only makes sure Uber follows those same rules other transportation businesses follow as well. There is competition in the transportation business here but there is no room for people sidestepping completely sane rules everybody should agree on. I am in no way affiliated with the taxi business and i like lower fares too. But not at the cost of safety and less checks for cars and drivers. Once Uber agrees to comply i am happy to use their app and their drivers. I doubt they will be able to operate much cheaper though - i am fine with that.
- golemotron 12y ago
- blackdogie 12y agoJust checked Munich, and no black cars are displaying but Uber Pop's are. I wonder how much notice you would get about such an action. image : https://twitter.com/paulsavage/status/506714057609867264 https://twitter.com/paulsavage/status/506714057609867264
- ChuckFrank 12y agoThe irony of this, with regards to their brand name, is delicious.
- oska 12y agoDeutschland: Uber 0, Alles 1
- darklajid 12y agoNot sure if you intended that, but I'm reasonably sure you did: I found your comment offensive. Not a reference I like to see and not related to the topic at hand. Certainly not funny. Yay, downvotes. For the people that "Don't Get It": That funny guy is basically referring to the first line of the 'Deutschlandlied' - the source of the German national anthem. Thing is, while we kept the third (and just the third) verse as our national anthem, the reference above and the complete first verse, is really just associated with Nazi idiots (it was the only verse used THEN and is still part of their propaganda, plus it's the most silly line ever - even without that heritage it would be something utterly ridiculous to say, write, sing or whatnot). While it's use is not illegal over here, singing (or using) that line makes you a potentially dangerous moron and is generally considered highly offensive. For this particular German he's basically singing a Nazi song.
- ryanx435 12y agoare you also offended by the phrase "grammar nazis"? do you believe that all "Hitler cat" memes should be removed from the internet? maybe we should just ban all references to anything related to nazis. maybe burn all copies of "mein kampf" so no one gets offended? or maybe we should round up everyone who posts a joke on the Internet and throw them in concentration camp because their beliefs are different than yours. calm down buddy.
- VMG 12y ago> generally considered highly offensive It would be considered too boring for Titanic magazine. Good job holding up the stereotype of the humor-impaired German.
- oskarth 12y agoI live in Berlin and this is extremely disappointing. I'm beginning to doubt European cities in general have any clue what makes startups in US work. Here's what pg tweeted when there were protests in London: Lots of cities say they want to be the Silicon Valley of Europe. Uber tests whether they mean it. (https://twitter.com/paulg/status/477428094530121728 https://twitter.com/paulg/status/477428094530121728) Talk all you want about Uber being evil, predatory and not really the One True Sharing Economy - this right here is why Europe won't catch up to US in terms of startups, despite all the nice talk about being friendly to them.
- Tomte 12y agoI guess that's one part of "the Silicon Valley" that I don't want to catch up with.
- nodata 12y agoWhat do you find disappointing about it?
- Xylakant 12y agoI live in Berlin and this is extremely satisfying. I'm beginning to doubt that Silicon Valley startups have any clue how European cities work. We germans in general are weary of evil, predatory enterprises that start a spiral to the bottom. Jest aside: This is just not how things work here, for good or bad. I think there's also not that much room for disruption in the Uber case, at least in Germany. The market for cabs is very much unlike the market in the US - there's not a single huge company owning all the cabs in Berlin and a medallion does not cost a million EUR. Service has been pretty ok for me so far and I use a lot of cabs, so I actually don't see much of an upside but I do see a lot of potential downsides, not that much for me who could easily afford a surge pricing but for people that maybe can't and have to rely on regular cabs.
- smsm42 12y ago>>> I think there's also not that much room for disruption in the Uber case, at least in Germany I suspect there is, otherwise there would be no need to ban it.
- Xylakant 12y ago> Uber plans to appeal the decision and said it would continue offering its services until a final ruling has been made. I'm curious how they'll do that. They already said that in the Hamburg and Berlin case, but those were administrative decisions where an appeal blocks the injunction until a court decides. This time it's a preliminary injunction from a court, where an appeal has no delaying effect. The injunction can be enforced. The fines are also much much higher - in Hamburg it was a measly 1000 EUR per violation, this time it's 250 kEUR per violation or up to 6 month in prison for the CEO.
- crapshoot101 12y agoInteresting, took an uber in Berlin about 3 days ago. The options here are much more limited (its UberPop, instead of UberX), and the driver coverage is smaller (my friend recognized the driver as being the same one he had seen a month ago). Cabs are relatively easy to get here and so cheap, haven't felt the need to really fire up Uber much at all for the most part - ie, it was raining last night, and found a cab in 1 min.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- charlie_vill 12y ago'Uber of 250,000 euros ($328,108) per ride'. I don't think this is accurate.
- Xylakant 12y agoIt is. Alternative: Up to 6 month of jail for the CEO.
- noelwelsh 12y agoAgainst my better judgement I'm going to attempt to contribute to this thread. There are good arguments on both sides but most people are talking past one another. As I see it, it comes down to this: Uber says there is a surplus, people driving cars with empty seats, and they attempt to capture that surplus. From an economic point-of-view that is a good argument. The surplus undeniably exists, and it would be beneficial to reduce it. The argument on the other side is that this is an issue of public policy. Various countries have decided it is beneficial to legislate people driving strangers in exchange for money. The general arguments are ones of safety, but quality of service also comes into it. Again this is a reasonable argument. There is an information asymmetry when hiring a taxi (I don't know what kind of driver I'm going to get) so legislation reduces that. The main point seems to be who gets to decide public policy? Uber and "Silicon Valley" types believe that private individuals and companies should be allowed to set public policy. Most others reject this. The next argument is whether current legislation is appropriate and whether Uber has sufficient features to make existing legislation unnecessary. E.g. are ratings and ubiquitous GPS sufficient to reduce information asymmetry. If Uber wants to engage in this argument it should use the usual methods of setting public policy. I don't know if Uber has started any court cases but I expect they will be involved in some soon if not already, and this is one way to effect public policy.
- Xylakant 12y ago> Uber says there is a surplus, people driving cars with empty seats, and they attempt to capture that surplus. From an economic point-of-view that is a good argument. The surplus undeniably exists, and it would be beneficial to reduce it. This is actually not what Uber says. Ride-Sharing would be fully valid as long as the fee paid is lower than the cost for the car owner. It's specifically exempt from the law. However, the fee that Uber proposes is far above the accepted costs per kilometer (it's roughly 1 EUR, while the accepted costs are roughly 30cent), so they don't qualify. There's a german startup (Wundercar) that tries to capture specifically that market and they just reduced their prices in response to a similar injunction.
- noelwelsh 12y agoI didn't know Germany had laws about this case. I meant in the general sense that their business model is based on exploiting this surplus. It is their value proposition, if you like.
- wellboy 12y agoAnyone knows why Uber has to pay 250k fines and all the other German taxi apps, such as MyTaxi that have raised $10M, don't?
- zenbit 12y agoMyTaxi targets commercial drivers that adhere to legislation whereas Uber targets non-professional drivers and does neither check nor care whether they follow regulations (proper license, permits, insurance, etc.)
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- wellboy 12y agoAh got it, so Germany doesn´t like the "Lyft-part" about Uber, right?
- jasonisalive 12y agoBanning Uber (or upholding laws that restrict market-entrants such as Uber) is just another example of banning "Walmart Scotch." Recommended: http://theumlaut.com/2014/04/30/how-net-neutrality-hurts-the-poor/ http://theumlaut.com/2014/04/30/how-net-neutrality-hurts-the...
- billynomates1 12y agoThis is a safety thing, not a competition thing.
- jasonisalive 12y agoSorry I'm not getting it. Feel free to correct me at any stage if I'm wrong. 1) You can drive a car in Germany if you meet some basic legislative requirements (Führerschein etc.) 2) You can carry a friend as a passenger - perfectly legal. 3) You could carry a stranger who asked you for a ride - perfectly legal. 4) That stranger could give you gas money - perfectly legal. 5) But if you use your smartphone to find strangers willing to pay you for a ride at this point your activity becomes so unsafe that you need to jump through a whole bucketload of extra hoops? Why is that exactly?
- zeeed 12y ago1-4 correct. 5 is not about safety. You enter a regulated market once in case 4 the money you give to the stranger exceeds the cost attached to the ride, smartphone or not. On top, you have no insurance coverage anymore.
- DanBC 12y agoUp until 5 you have two people making free decisions. When you get to number 5 you have a commercial company and an individual, and that changes the relationship. Here's a US example. I can drive a car, but if my employer asks me to take a parcel from work to the post office to be posted I need to make sure my insurance covers that commercial activity or I am uninsured.
- jfoster 12y ago"Violations of the injunction will result in a fine against Uber of 250,000 euros ($328,108) per ride. Uber plans to appeal the decision and said it would continue offering its services until a final ruling has been made." Is that an error in judgement on Uber's part? Perhaps they'll settle or get the fine reduced if they remain unsuccessful, but with a fine like that per ride, there is a slim possibility that defying the order could send them out of business, isn't there?
- exDM69 12y agoNot sure about German laws, but in many places a court order is not put into effect before the appeals have been dealt with. If and when the appeals are declined, I'm sure they have to shut down business with that kind of fines.
- Xylakant 12y agoIn this case, since it's a court-granted injunction ("Einstweilige Verfügung") an appeal has no delaying effect. The preliminary injunction gets only granted if the court feels that the risk associated with the action in question is sufficiently high to warrant immediate action. IANAL, but from what I know this injunction can be enforced until it's overturned in an appeal. That's different from the last two bans (Hamburg and Berlin) where Uber was banned by administrative action (Verwaltungsakt). In that case, an appeal has delaying effect until the case gets heard in court.
- cromwellian 12y agoI really wonder how much of this is protectionism for Taxis, and how much of it is protectionism against foreign companies. I don't have any particular love for Uber (the way they waste Lyft resources makes them d-bags in my book), but I don't buy the 'safety' excuse being given. It reminds me of the bullshit safety concerns used to continue Oregon's ban on pumping your own gas at gas stations: http://www.oregonlive.com/opinion/index.ssf/2014/06/its_for_the_children_and_other.html http://www.oregonlive.com/opinion/index.ssf/2014/06/its_for_... The reality is, it's a form of protectionism for gas station attendant jobs, just as this German decision smells like regulatory capture. My guess is that if Uber changed policy to actually meet whatever requirements safety they're asking, they'd devise a new set of excuses for the ban, because this is ultimately about preserving the status quo.
- pgeorgi 12y agoThe "excuse" is the Personenbeförderungsgesetz (law on [commercially] transporting people). Taxis have to implement it (and they do), and so they can complain in court about competitors who don't (as a remedy to state intervention: regulation has to apply to everyone). That's what happened here, nothing more, nothing less. If the court hadn't stopped Uber, we'd actually see some special treatment (that is, protectionism) in Uber's favor.
- Sarahanderson 12y agoGabriella . I can see what your saying... Adam `s postlng is impressive... on tuesday I got a gorgeous Maserati from having made $4435 this-past/five weeks and would you believe, 10k this past month . without a question it is the most comfortable work I've ever done . I began this four months/ago and pretty much straight away startad bringin in minimum $71 per hour . Read Full Report >>>>>>>> www.jobsfish.com
- einrealist 12y agoI use Taxis several times a week (in Germany). A lot of the drivers are already complaining about their income. Most of them are below the minimum wage, which will come in 2015. And a lot expect their company to shut down business. When I ask them about their opinion about Uber, many of the drivers speak positively about such an alternative. It would allow them to work without the need of a concession and to keep more money of the margin. But they also demand the same standards for such an alternative. I prefer the Taxi (and my employer would not allow Uber in the first place), because of insurance and other minimum standards demanded by regulation (federal, country and town (via concessions)). So I see a conflict, that is not just about Uber, but about the working conditions and the income in general. If Uber is allowed to work at lower limitations than the Taxi businesses, it will be a distortion of competition. It would make more Taxi companies to go out of business, which already struggle to keep their business and to pay their employes wages above the minimum (today and 2015). So yes! Uber drivers must maintain the same standards as Taxi businesses, if they offer a commercial service.
- gioele 12y ago> If Uber is allowed to work at lower limitations than the Taxi businesses, it will be a distortion of competition. Let's stop talking about "competition". The issue here is "the regulations". Are they too broad? Or too narrow? Or ineffective? Or inadequate? Or just fine? It Uber is allowed to work at lower limitations than the Taxi businesses, then either the Taxi business is too regulated (then some regulations should be dropped) or Uber is taking shortcuts somewhere damaging the costumers or the workers (the reason why the regulations exist in the first place). I think that, if the current regulations are justified (and this is to be seen place by place), then there is no other outcome other than Uber becoming simply yet another Taxi company, maybe the one with the nicest website.
- einrealist 12y agoIts both - competition and regulation. If one company does not follow them, but others do, then you have a distortion of competition. The difficulty is in to tell whether Uber is operating like a Taxi company or not. They certainly operate on a different model than the usual Taxi business. So that's why Uber ignored the laws until someone cried foul. Btw. I think the business is regulated fairly. The income is not. Most difficulties are with the concessions and the natural oligopols around them.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Roritharr 12y agoLiving in Frankfurt, I still see Uber Pop Drivers in the Uber App. Doesn't know what that means tho.
- steilpass 12y agoHas someone looked at the scope of the German law? http://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/pbefg/__1.html http://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/pbefg/__1.html >Diesem Gesetz unterliegen nicht Beförderungen 1. mit Personenkraftwagen, wenn diese unentgeltlich sind oder das Gesamtentgelt die Betriebskosten der Fahrt nicht übersteigt; => As long as the total fare is below the actual costs the law is not applicable. It seems if Uber operates at a loss they are fine. ;-)
- _up 12y agoI think the drivers themself would have to operate at a loss. But they also have an exemption for ambulances. Maybe they can offer medical services for their clients. ;)
- throwawayaway 12y agoDeutschland uber Uber!
- domrdy 12y agoBlack cars have all vanished from the map while 'pop' seems to be operating just fine, at least I can see several cars in my area (Munich).
- Xylakant 12y agoInteresting effect, since the ban affects "Pop" and not "Black" which is basically a limo-for-hire service and (mostly) complies with the legal requirements.
- ulfw 12y agoI know I won't be popular with this comment and most likely downvoted, because Uber is so beloved (especially in Bay Area circles). But here it comes: Why do people support a single company (like in this case Uber) taking over the business of thousands and thousands of existing companies and hence monopolizing an industry? In most European cities, taxi companies are small, almost mom-and-pop entities with anywhere between one and say twenty taxis. In fact where I am living now I can call 4-5 different ones all in my vicinity. If there was an app that consolidated the booking process for those - awesome! But why would there have to be a company that owns the market globally - from Karachi to Karlsruhe, from Amsterdam to New York, taking 20%, killing competition by it's pure überstrong market presence, brand and financial backing. The same people that hate Comcast for oligolopolizing it's market (and hence using it's almost-monopoly powers for their benefit) yet somehow wish Uber would succeed and take over the market around the world. Why? Because it's a hip SF 'startup' (if you can still call an entity with $1,500,000,000 in funding a startup)?
- skwirl 12y agoYou're completely missing that Comcast is a "monopoly" because its customers have no choice while Uber is becoming a "monopoly" precisely because people do now have a choice.
- untog 12y agoUber is taking a huge injection of investment cash and spending it on technology, to a scale that these small mom and pop companies could never replicate. I still don't see that as a good thing in the long term - once Uber has cornered the market there is no choice left.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- benlc 12y agoUber is mostly present in major markets where Taxi companies are more of some sort of mafia than a mom and pop business. The truth is that these very same companies are present in smaller cities as well and asking a driver what he thinks of who's working for quickly shows that they share their hatred with their customers towards the terrible service they have to provide for very little money in return. These companies keep most profit, while Uber, Lyft, Sidecar etc... only take ~20%
- PaulRobinson 12y agoUber are lying liars who lie in many markets. This is demonstrated by the fact that in London, they simply went out and got the PHV license, and made sure the vehicles comply (checks every 6 months, public liability insurance, etc.) - if they did this in every other market, no problem. The issue is that isn't a very sexy business. It's not "disruptive" like car pooling. And in some markets, the cost of complying with the regulations is extremely high. Even in London, it's been argued that the app in the car is a meter, and therefore breaches legislation relating to metered trips: only black cab drivers are allowed to meter, and the regulation bar there is much, much higher in part because those drivers are free to just pick people up off the street without pre-booking. It seems to me that they should either focus on ride-sharing and get out of the private hire business, or they should focus on the private hire business and do it properly. The regulations around private hire are not some idiot state actors nannying around: in London they have evolved over centuries. Literally. They are constantly reviewed, and London has an incredibly diverse and active PHV market with many innovators (Addison Lee, Hailo, Kabbee, etc.) improving things in regards to customer choice.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- kenster07 12y agoThis is not about evaluating what is objectively better for the consumer. There is much less tolerance for the "ask for forgiveness, not permission" mentality in Germany than America, and this ruling proves that. If a competitor like Lyft goes into Germany now, plays by the rules, and shows respect to the existing order, I would not be surprised to see them welcomed and take a huge lead in Europe.
- johlindenbaum 12y agoI liked UberX while I was in the city. Awesome ridesharing. Great. I don't understand why Uber, in a regulated taxi eco system like London or Berlin, wouldn't just start with UberTAXI? Why not start the process gently by being able to hail a cab and pay through the app. This is the most problematic issue for me as a user. Getting a dedicated cab to show up to my location, just for me. While living in the Bay Area, I talked to several (yellow) cab drivers that love Uber because it guarantees a fair that their dispatch service can't. Why does Uber not enter new markets by making booking Taxis easier first, then introduce X at a later point when their brand is better known in a new market?
- diminoten 12y agoThey're not "banned" entirely, just UberX. The black car service is still allowed. What I just don't get about that is the fact that the black car service is the thing that's most "analogous" to a taxi service, isn't it? Maybe I'm not understanding something here.