2 ms·
You're falling into the common fallacy of assuming that a phenomenon looks like something simple you already understand. Studio EQ is not the same as Fourier f
by TheOtherHobbes 12y ago
You're falling into the common fallacy of assuming that a phenomenon looks like something simple you already understand.
Studio EQ is not the same as Fourier filtering. Canonical digital DSP filters are vastly more efficient than Fourier processing. Analog EQ circuits add significant amounts of distortion which add character to the sound. Some of the better digital EQs try to emulate this.
Studio effects, pedals included, do not actually correspond to convolution. Many commercial reverb algorithms use complex time-varying effects that can't be modelled with simple convolution. While you can buy convolution reverbs from a variety of sources - and they're very popular for certain reverb effects - they're a long way from being the whole story.
Bottom line is audio engineering is much more complex than you seem to think it is. Numerical techniques, including Fourier and convolution, have been studied since at least the 1950s, and there are good reasons why they're not a one-size-fits-all solution for audio effects.
The image filter, on the other hand, is a lovely piece of work. I'm surprised no one has made it available as a Photoshop plug-in (although I expect someone will soon.)
- calhoun137 12y agoI am willing to accept that "audio engineering is much more complex" than I seem to think it is, and because of your comment I will look more closely into things before making any claims like that again. Would you be willing to explain in more detail the "good reasons why they're not a one-size-fits-all solution for audio effects"?
- dspig 12y agoA big reason against FFT is latency - for good resolution at low frquencies you need a big FFT, so it takes longer to buffer that many samples before you can FFT them. Also a lot of the processes we want to apply to audio have much more efficient methods available than FFT or convolution such as IIR filters - which also have no latency apart from whatever phase shift they introduce. Or if the process is time varying or has embedded non-linearities then it lends itself to sample-by-sample processing and not block based like FFT and (efficient) convolution.
- chipsy 12y agoSome examples... The reverberation algorithms mentioned by TheOtherHobbes often bear no resemblance to the methods used for analog gear. The most commonly understood setup, in the first digital reverbs described by Manfred Schroeder [0], uses banks of all-pass delay lines set up in "aesthetically interesting" sequence and series, employing various levels of feedback. Digital frequency filters (and I'm pretty unclear on all the details myself, not having enough DSP background) generally apply the Z-transform [1] to turn a filter specification into a fast state-variable algorithm. This technique is crucial to modelling certain aspects of analog audio since it allows the filter to behave in more chaotic, animated ways: for example, resonance in analog domain is achieved through filter feedback, which causes the filter to self-oscillate at high gain levels. Resampling algorithms contain some of the most straightforward applications of Fourier transforms. The theory tells us to treat each sample of the original signal as a point convolved by the sinc function; the resulting output signal is resampled from this convolution, and is thus dependent on the _bandwidth_ of the convolution - as bandwidth goes up, our convolution grows wider, as it goes down, shorter. The bandwidth modulation guarantees that the output signal contains frequencies underneath the Nyquist limit. However, in practical use, we immediately have to compromise by at least windowing the sinc; thus we get into various approximations to minimize artifacts. Resampling can become a distinctive effect when done with lower fidelity or unusual filter kernels(example: The SPU of the Super Nintendo employs a Gaussian kernel). [0] http://valhalladsp.wordpress.com/2009/05/30/schroeder-reverbs-the-forgotten-algorithm/ http://valhalladsp.wordpress.com/2009/05/30/schroeder-reverb... [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Z-transform http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Z-transform