6 ms·
The Dubious Sources of Some Supreme Court ‘Facts’
- rayiner 12y agoThe article glosses over an important distinction between the two kinds of "facts" implicated in a Supreme Court case. On one hand are the "facts of the case." These are the details of the specific dispute under review as formally developed in the trial record. These are the "facts" to which the Court applies its interpretation of the law. Applying the law to any other facts than these would be unsound. Then there are "facts" which give the Court a broader context in which to place policy arguments. These facts are often not developed in the trial record, but are also not central to the disposition in the first place. When the Court makes a policy argument, potentially relying on "facts" cited by amici, they almost always do so in a way that is ancillary to a rationale based on a more concrete interpretation of the law and precedent. All of the examples cited by the article are ones where a dubious "fact" in an amicus brief is mentioned only to add color to the opinion. The article, while it quotes Scalia, also misses out on a key aspect of his judicial philosophy. If you eschew nebulous policy or empirical arguments, in favor of concrete statutory or legal interpretation, as Scalia tends to do, you are naturally insulated from reliance on dubious "facts" (and let's face it, even many assertions appearing in properly sourced and cited "studies" are dubious). It's only when you venture out into arguments like "the law should be this because X% of Americans do Y" that you open yourself up to reliance on questionable facts and interpretations. This is particularly true because the lower courts tend to eschew such heavily reliance on policy arguments, and so don't develop a record that includes the facts necessary to support them. Thus, the Justices that favor such policy arguments often have no choice but to rely on amici.
- thirdtruck 12y agoIt's similar to how computers handle analogue vs. digital data. The court must "quantize" the facts before deciding policy (through restrictions on discovery, on issues to be ruled, on the length of filings, etc.) because it lacks the processing throughput to handle high-fidelity cases in a timely fashion.
- ScottBurson 12y agoOkay, fine, but doesn't that mean the Court should have a staff of policy researchers to verify these claims?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 12y agoA tiny minority of all significant cases get cert at SCOTUS. So really, you're suggesting an even larger staff of policy researchers covering all the federal courts. Note, when you consider that, that those courts can barely keep up with their caseloads as it stands. Really, the reason this doesn't already exist is because as far as the Article III courts are concerned, it does: it's called the legislature. The constitutional design of our government assumes that legislatures are far better fact-finding bodies than courts are. Our balance of powers is especially sensitive to the issue that the courts, built up further than they are now, would in effect be a panel of unelected lifetime-tenure philosopher-kings.
- pessimizer 12y ago>So really, you're suggesting an even larger staff of policy researchers covering all the federal courts. Note, when you consider that, that those courts can barely keep up with their caseloads as it stands. I don't understand why you wouldn't throw more resources at something that seems under-resourced. Am I missing something?
- x1798DE 12y agoPresumably there's a limited amount of money that people are (and should be) willing to shell out for this sort of thing. I think the point is that if those resources were available, they would likely be spent on adding more personnel to exacerbate the existing problems, not adding fact-checkers for the entire federal system.
- rayiner 12y agoThe problem isn't the resources. It's the avoidance of creating an unelected bureaucracy with a lot of power. As it is, the judiciary is really quite lean. The Justices have a secretary, and four clerks, usually recent grads that only spend a year on the job. And that's really it in terms of staff, discounting court administrative staff. The lower courts are all just as lean. If you add a staff of researchers, you're adding a whole new class of people with influence.
- judk 12y agoIt doesn't pass the "smell test" to think that Scalia's opinions on law are in colored by the facts he not only believes but also elevates to a privileged position in his formal declarations. If he illustrates an opinion with a substantively wrong "fact", the opinion is suspect.
- scott_s 12y agoI read most of Scalia's dissent, and I found it interesting: http://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/10pdf/09-11311.pdf http://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/10pdf/09-11311.pdf It starts on page 31. He gets to the amicus briefs on page 35. In this instance, the other justices did appeal to the amicus briefs to establish what constitutes a "violent" crime. (Well, Scalia claimed they did, and I admit I'm taking his word for it - I don't want to go through the other opinions, and I doubt he would misrepresent such an important point.) His claim is that the law and precedent are vague when it comes to defining a "violent crime". The prosecution, as I understand it, are making a statistical claim that crimes which tend to cause serious injury should be called "violent". They have amicus briefs with statistics on injury related to particular crimes. His point is that it is dangerous for them to rely on such statistics, as they have not been vetted. It's an interesting point, and certainly has me thinking.
- tomohawk 12y agoThe supreme court simply does not have the capability to perform fact finding like a legislature or executive can. A legislature can subpena witnesses, etc. It's designed to create law. It's designed to decide policy. The supreme court should stick to what it was designed to do. It should stick to the law and avoid policy.
- hownottowrite 12y agoProfessor Larsen's work on this subject goes back quite a way. http://www.virginialawreview.org/sites/virginialawreview.org/files/1255.pdf http://www.virginialawreview.org/sites/virginialawreview.org...
- rbanffy 12y agoShouldn't it be considered perjury to knowingly submit faulty information in an amicus curiae brief?
- DanielBMarkham 12y agoAs a layperson, this story could use a LOT more context. Over-reliance on amicus briefs may be bad, but having one law professor complain and then writing a story around it isn't much of a news article. Some things I think I know about this subject. 1) SCOTUS is given broad latitude on how to do their job. Like complete latitude. One justice says publicly that they looked to foreign courts for guidance in resolving matters. That sounds totally whacked to me, but what do I know? 2) If you get the impression that the justices are sitting around the laptop, surfing the internet for blogs to agree with their preconceived opinions, you missed it. Each judge has a team of clerks whose job is to stay on top of both the case law and facts of the case. Justices are notorious for working the crap out of these folks and they're expected to do their work flawlessly 3) AFAIK, the amicus briefs are never used to determine the outcome, but can be cited as supporting material. That means, by definition, that they could go away and it wouldn't change the results. So the courts aren't certifying some off-the-wall facts; they're deciding based on the law and then citing all sorts of other things like the amicus briefs in their long-form opinions. Who knows if the same decisions would be made without those briefs? It is beyond arguing about, since it's a counter-factual. All of these points should have either been discussed in the article or referred to by the article. Dear Mr. Writer. It's called context. Get you some of it. I really wish the NYT would do a little more quality control. Hell, find some old cranky guy and run some of this stuff by them. Speaking from personal experience, the internet is full of assholes who would be happy to help. It shouldn't be the case that they run with it and then get taken apart so easily. And for the record, even though I took a potshot at the writer, I do not blame them, I blame the system they have. They could easily do a better job than they're doing. It's called editing.