4 ms·
>>> What you find is completely different from what most people would think. The person with the higher status uses the word "I" less. Here's a hypothesis. The
by analog31 12y ago
>>> What you find is completely different from what most people would think. The person with the higher status uses the word "I" less.
Here's a hypothesis. The higher status person has learned to express their thoughts in a way that makes them seem more objective and authoritarian -- and less susceptible to negotiation or debate. The implicit assumption is that your words convey opinions, but their words convey facts.
- akerl_ 12y agoI'm not sure how that holds up against the example shown, where the same professor fell at different levels on the scale depending on whether he was talking to someone lower or higher on the status hierarchy. If the language shift was a learned skill that developed as part of performing the roles of the higher status, wouldn't two people of high status converse using similar rates, even if one of them is relatively higher than the other?
- PeterWhittaker 12y agoImplicit in your second paragraph are the notions of absolute status and of mutual recognition of absolute status. I'd suggest social status is always relative and is likely assumed by participants prior to their initiating an interaction: The student used lower status language when writing to the professor, who used lower status language when writing to the famous professor.
- akerl_ 12y agoI'm saying the same thing you said. The hypothesis in the comment I was replying to is that speaking with fewer of the noted words is a skilled learned as part of reaching higher status, presumably because speaking that way allows you to better wield your station. That isn't shown in the evidence, because the evidence in the article shows that the speech used is indeed relative.
- thinkersilver 12y agoNot necessarily. It has little to do with learning to speak in a higher status manner. The comment box doesn't allow for a clear concise explanation but the language shift is something that the brain does on a subconscious level. A person's emotional state is related to how they see themselves in relation to their world at that moment. The 'language shift' is a manifestation of that. It is a tell in a way, the same way different clusters of body movements are, unlike body language, though, it is something that goes undetected by either party and hence can't be actively expressed or detected. That's why the LWC software was built. Check out the book that Pennebaker wrote. It does a better job explaining this than the article does and it will clear any confusion. Pennebaker doesn't provide an explanation for why their's a need to be more personal when assuming a lower status or when experiencing emotional trauma but he does provide plenty of evidence for the relationship.
- freditup 12y agoI wonder if the email examples are simply a byproduct of the specific conversations / order of the discussion. Maybe 'cold-call' emails demand a lot of 'I's in them as part of the initial explanation while responses to these emails do not.
- thedevopsguy 12y agoAccording to Pennebaker status is negotiated at the beginning of a new interaction when the perceived status of the participants is unclear. The frequency of the filler words mark the status/role that has been adopted by the participants. Which is clearly marked in the email examples given. The article does not imply that this is a learned skill, since the whole theory is based on function words which are accessible at even the most basic proficiency of a language. It is merely describing what happens to our language when we enter a social interaction. Note the words used aren't necessarily important but rather the function of the words are, i.e are they referencing social objects ( the role of pronouns) or referencing concrete or abstract non-social objects.
- MetallicCloud 12y agoBut the professor used language without using 'I' when he held the power with the undergraduate, but he used it a lot when talking to a famous professor.
- PeterWhittaker 12y agoCorrect. See my reply to akeri_, above: Status is relative, not absolute.
- golemotron 12y agoI think it is simpler than that. A person who uses -I- is asking for attention. A person in power feels that they already have the other person's attention or is unconcerned with it.
- rkaplan 12y agoInteresting to note that you started this reply with "I think." Would it have carried more weight if you started with "perhaps" instead, or stripped it altogether? Maybe. Either way it's fun to think about.
- golemotron 12y agoTrue. :-)
- grok2 12y agoAnother thought -- perhaps an "I" form of statement would invite more discussion in a forum than something that appears to be a factual statement and not a opinion.
- mnarayan01 12y agoAlso it would seem (to me) to be more polite (mainly in that it would allow more polite ways to disagree).
- anon4 12y agoOr the person in power is speaking from the point of view of the power he represents rather than for himself personally.
- Stratoscope 12y agoThanks for that hypothesis. It makes sense to me, including the idea that we're talking about relative status here, not absolute. BTW would "authoritative" be closer to what you meant instead of "authoritarian"? A nitpick perhaps but definitely a different shade of meaning!
- analog31 12y agoAgreed.