2 ms·
If the water line can be made to change when scaling the boat up, it should be trivial to make a pathological object that will sink when scaled. Just make the s
by baddox 12y ago
If the water line can be made to change when scaling the boat up, it should be trivial to make a pathological object that will sink when scaled. Just make the shape of a box without a lid, weighted so that the water line is just at the top of the walls. If scaling the shape raises the waterline, then water will flow into the box and it will sink. I still can't intuitively convince myself that the waterline would shift when the model scales.
- lutusp 12y agoI should have made clear what I meant by "sits lower in the water", and I'm responsible for the confusion. Because the boat is a three-dimensional object, and because the subsurface part contacts the water in three dimensions, if it is scaled up with all else the same, it should still have the same waterline, but (obviously) its keel is deeper in the water. > I still can't intuitively convince myself that the waterline would shift when the model scales. Your instincts are serving you well, and the answer is simple -- I wasn't sufficiently careful in how I described it, and I let an error creep into yesterday's conversation. In fact, a model whose dimensions are held constant but is scaled up, should show the same waterline at all scales. Again, I apologize for sounding so sure of myself when I wasn't.
- baddox 12y agoOkay, so you were talking about the keel of the larger model being deeper underwater in absolute terms. I suppose that would effect buoyancy, because pressure increases as depth increases. This might be significant enough to warrant adjustments, at least when scaling very large ships down to very small models.