3 ms·
> The problem is that the current IPK has lost a tiny bit of weight, in comparison with 40 similar cylinders held in other countries, which is a significant fla
by JadeNB 12y ago
> The problem is that the current IPK has lost a tiny bit of weight, in comparison with 40 similar cylinders held in other countries, which is a significant flaw in an object used to define a unit of mass. So the Avogadro Project has created two softball-sized, near-perfect spheres, made entirely of silicon-28 atoms, that should remain exactly one kilogram in perpetuity.
I seem to remember reading a while ago that no-one was quite sure why the reference kilogram was losing mass. Why should one therefore be confident that the new spheres will not do so?—or is this another 'distortion for convenience' of the article, like:
> Lie group E8, for instance, is a set of 248 different forms of symmetry that apply to a theoretical 57-dimensional object.
E_8 as a Lie group is 'continuous', and therefore infinite, and E_8 as a Weyl group has size much, much, much bigger than 248. The number 248 presumably comes from the dimension of the Lie group E_8 (and I suppose that one could twist words to accept that the dimension of the Lie group is somehow a reflection of the "number of different kinds of symmetries" that it contains); I'm not sure (but am not an expert on this, and so might just not know) whence comes the 57.
- micampe 12y agoThe sphere would not be defining the kilogram: it will be used to count the number of atoms it contains, which would allow to redefine the Avogadro number without reference to the kilogram, which would then define the kilogram as the mass of a fixed number of Si28 atoms. See the video I posted in another comment.
- JadeNB 12y agoI see. Indeed, this is the impression that I got from the last paragraph: > Now that the spheres are done, researchers in different countries will try to discern the exact number of atoms they contain, to get universal agreement on what exactly is the mass of a kilogram. However, when it is understood this way, I find the previous word choice confusing: > two softball-sized, near-perfect spheres, made entirely of silicon-28 atoms, … should remain exactly one kilogram in perpetuity (emphasis mine). If they are made entirely of silicon-28, and the kilogram is defined as the mass of a certain number of silicon-28 atoms, then they will remain one kilogram in perpetuity (by definition), right?