8 ms·
A psychological addiction is defined as when you spend time doing one thing instead of doing something else that you feel is more important. It's self-referenti
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
A psychological addiction is defined as when you spend time doing one thing instead of doing something else that you feel is more important. It's self-referential: only you can define whether you are addicted or not.
By this measure, if the youths are self-reporting that they feel addicted to the internet, that's very, very interesting. It says that the youths themselves feel they should be doing something else, not some old, stodgy institution.
I know it's fun to play the old folks against the young, but you just can't keep waving your hands around and yelling various buzzwords. At some point there are real, independent metrics that come into play. Kids can't spell. The ability to put together (or appreciate) a cogent argument spanning more than ten words is being lost on a generation. No amount of technology is going to give critical thinking skills back to people who spent their formative years on FaceBook and WoW instead of somewhere else -- anywhere else.
It's not like being instantly connected to the world's body of knowledge and each other is going to make up for cognitive potential lost through inattention.
We've got some really cool stuff going on now -- stuff that has the potential to change the nature of what it means to be human. But we shouldn't put on blinders to the sucky stuff simply because the cool stuff is so neat.
- Ixiaus 17y agoThen the important question is, whether students are labeling themselves as addicted or are being labeled by the examiners. I never intended to play the old folk against youth; I was attempting to argue that, instead of worrying about the cogency of self-expression or critical thinking skills in the framework of traditional systems (which never had the level of technology we see today, including my schooling) I think the focus should be placed on how to inspire youth to develop/learn logical thinking, rhetoric, and grammatical skills within the context of an evolving system. I'm arguing for the reform of our educational system to grow with these new technological advancements and with it all of the changes to language and thought processes. Is this not how new languages and forms of expression are created/evolved? I fully agree that precise, clear, and centered thinking as well as mindful and accurate self-expression are of the utmost importance in the development of an individual. However, I think a fine line must be drawn between compatibility of thought and expression between generations: should we conform to their new and developing form of communication and thought? Or should they conform to the old ways? You are correct, that technology will and should never replace the use of the brain. It is, however, becoming a deeply integral aspect of our culture; just as the book did once the printing press was invented. There is a lot to say on this subject, I'm going to leave it at that as this input box is too tiny and I have trouble reviewing what I wrote! Fun conversation :)
- roundsquare 17y agoA psychological addiction is defined as when you spend time doing one thing instead of doing something else that you feel is more important. I doubt the people taking the survey (people 11 to 18 years old) knew that. Its generally problematic to use a technical definition in the interpretation of a survey of non-technical (in the relevant field) people. Likely they read "addicted to the internet" as "spend a lot of time on the internet." It says that the youths themselves feel they should be doing something else Maybe to a degree, but given their lack of knowledge about the definition, I wouldn't necessarily draw that conclusion. All it means to me is they are spending a lot of time on the internet. I agree with the rest of your post though, so that might lead to the conclusion that kids are spending too much time on the internet (or the parts of the internet that aren't educational...).
- rsaarelm 17y agoBy this measure, if the youths are self-reporting that they feel addicted to the internet, that's very, very interesting. It says that the youths themselves feel they should be doing something else, not some old, stodgy institution. They aren't old enough to define worthwhile ways to spend their time all by themselves. Their sense of what people are supposed to be doing with their time is going to be affected by the educational institution which has very poor sense of how to efficiently factor technology into education. So it's likely that they will be feeling a conflict, even if a properly guided use of technology would actually lead to an equal or better education. For a parallel, imagine what things would look like if the educational establishment was dead-set on teaching oral tradition, the students were literate, but the use of written word would be pretty much dismissed in proper education in favor of recitation and rhetoric. The students would be left to their own devices with coming up uses for writing. The students would probably mostly use writing in pretty useless ways and occasionally feel guilty about not spending more time learning to recite the sagas of macroeconomic world history and the verse for basic electrodynamic theory.