4 ms·
If you are restricting your tools on the grounds of philosophy you subscribe to, you are doing it wrong. Ditch the philosophy, stick to math, try everything and
by scotty79 12y ago
If you are restricting your tools on the grounds of philosophy you subscribe to, you are doing it wrong. Ditch the philosophy, stick to math, try everything and go with what results in models of predictive utility. That's what actual scientists do.
- analog31 12y ago... and test the prediction.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoThat is implied in model being of predictive utility.
- judk 12y agoHow do you decide which models actually have predictive utility, under real world incomplete information? Back to square One.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoHow do you decide if the water in your bathtub is warm? Stick your finger into it and see for yourself. Similarly here, you use your models to predict something, check if they predicted it right, and either try to fix them or ditch them completely.
- eruditely 12y agoIncorrect. The philosophers know 'math'. The half-mathematicians that think they can escape philosophy should read.... well anything. Almost all grand-standing that people have about 'philosophy' is some weird fictional idea that people have in their mind. Notice how all the recipients of the Lakatos awards and how they are people like Judea Pearl. Here's a quote from here (Terrence Tao, definitely a mathematician). http://terrytao.wordpress.com/2010/01/01/254a-notes-0-a-review-of-probability-theory/ http://terrytao.wordpress.com/2010/01/01/254a-notes-0-a-revi... "probability theory is only “allowed” to study concepts and perform operations which are preserved with respect to extension of the underlying sample space." Any attempt to side-step these issues leads to people wandering off into the middle of nowhere. Misuse of mathematical tools to areas where is does not apply and all sorts of other major and minor errors that could have been avoided. There is no computer science without Godel, Frege, Russell, and Turing.