3 ms·
> Can it be done quickly enough to prevent the damage from climate change? Actually the renewable push in Germany is accelerating climate change, not preventin
by ars 12y ago
> Can it be done quickly enough to prevent the damage from climate change?
Actually the renewable push in Germany is accelerating climate change, not preventing it. They don't get enough sun to make solar cells worth it, yet they do it anyway.
What it means is they will never make EROEI for them. On paper everything is wonderful (as a country emissions are low), but actually all they are doing is shipping the emissions to China which is where the solar cells are made.
- Retric 12y agoThat's pure FUD. EROEI for solar in Germany vary's a lot but it's from a physics standpoint it's ~20x. However, EROEI has no set standard and it's easy to fudge the numbers. Yet, gasoline generally ends up as less than 1 using those metrics. PS: Though from an economic and EROEI standpoint Rooftop solar is significantly less appealing than solar farms.
- ars 12y agoNo it isn't. EROEI for solar barely reaches 5 in sunny areas, in Germany it would not surprise me if it was below 1. If the EROEI was so high they would not need massive government subsidies to encourage adoption - people would do it without encouragement.
- throwaway5752 12y agoYou don't understand the difference between EROEI or ROI if you believe this. This is a really fundamental problem with your point, and it's like not grasping big-O notation in algorithmic analysis. Edit: I take it back. Based on your comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8248722 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8248722 you are either dense as a rock or spreading FUD like the preceding comment suggested. I suspect I am not engaging in a good faith discussion. Edit 2: Just something to leave you with. Nuclear disposal costs are externalized (deferred), educating the workforce is externalized (navy), risk is externalized (indemnified), fuel is currently underpriced (megatons to megawatts), construction (highest single input cost) is massively subsidized, and in the end it's still burning unrenewable fuel so even assuming it's cheap and we never have an accident we're just kicking the can down the road a couple of hundred years.
- ars 12y ago> You don't understand the difference between EROEI or ROI if you believe this. Actually I claim there is virtually no difference. Every single time I read an EREOI calculation I kept wondering "But he ignored that energy, and that, and that". After thinking about it I realized that money makes an excellent proxy for EROEI. Every step in the process that costs energy also increase the cost. So the money essentially acts as "book keeping" for energy. Everyone always gets mad when they encounter this for the first time, but think about for a while. Think about the basic cost for every single thing we make, and you'll realize at its core its always energy. There is one exception that I thought of and that is pollution. Reducing pollution is a valuable thing even if it costs extra energy to do so. Because at the end of the day we don't care how much energy we use, we care that we don't dirty our environment, and that we don't run out. Your edit #2 is well taken. I will need to think about that. My initial impression is that nuclear costs more energy (all those externalities you mention) than hydrocarbon fuel, but makes less pollution. So maybe it's worth it anyway.
- Retric 12y agoThink about this from an engineering standpoint. Let's suppose you your buying a large scale solar system with actual money right now. Utility system prices are $2.04/W in Q3 2013. http://www.seia.org/research-resources/solar-market-insight-2013-q3 http://www.seia.org/research-resources/solar-market-insight-... it's less now but that's close enough. Standard warranties offered in the market offer 90% rated power output for 10 years and an 80% rated power output for 25 years http://www.solarenergyhome.co.uk/performance.php http://www.solarenergyhome.co.uk/performance.php With real world numbers averaging ~90+% of stated efficiency over 25 years. 1W solar produces ~8-10 wh/day * 365 days * 25 years /1000 kw per w = 65.7+ kwh over 25 years. 2.04 / 65.7 = 3.1 cents per kwh worst case. Panels don't instantly die at 25 years. So, actual lifetime output is guaranteed to be higher so costs are lower. But there are vary low maintenance costs and occasional physical damage so that's a reasonable estimate on average. The time value of money is only meaningful if you want to compare your returns with other options over the long term there is no point in including inflation etc. As it's not like 1kwh will magically turn into more than that just by time passing.
- 12y ago
- power_rated 12y agoYeah, well they don't get massive government subsidies.
- ars 12y agoYes they do. They get a fixed feed-in tariff that is higher than the market rate. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_Renewable_Energy_Act#Payment_scheme https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_Renewable_Energy_Act#Pa...
- lispm 12y agoThat's not a government subsidy. It's a feed-in tariff depending on the year, capacity, type of producer etc.. It is not paid by the government. The money is paid by the electricity consumers. The energy intensive industry does not pay this, btw. Their electricity is 35% cheaper than in France, according to 'Uniden'. http://nuclear-news.net/2014/03/19/frances-nuclear-electricity-costing-industry-35-more-does-germanys-electricity/ http://nuclear-news.net/2014/03/19/frances-nuclear-electrici...