3 ms·
War, or use of force to take or defend territory, is part of human nature. You cannot look at history and deny this. There is nothing fundamentally different ab
by ams6110 12y ago
War, or use of force to take or defend territory, is part of human nature. You cannot look at history and deny this. There is nothing fundamentally different about humans in "this day and age" than there was 100 or 1,000 years ago.
- viraptor 12y agoMedia is different. Until cameras could be used by everyone to distribute information about everything, people could only meet those who returned after a victory. People were recruited for crazy service for glorious goals before. These days everyone has seen painfully dying soldiers on all sides of recent conflicts. Even now most real recordings from WW2 show running people, tanks, bombings from the air. There should be way more closeup dying and blood. The wars we get on the TV are way too clean. I really wish that changes the minds of at least some people...
- anigbrowl 12y agoLook at a film like 300, which is awash in gore. There's a big audience for that sort of thing, based on some sort of physical dunning -Kruger effect - the same sort you see among a small fringe of gun aficionados who spend their time fantasizing about the collapse of society and their imaginary subsequent dominance - such conversations tend to involve a great deal more consideration of optimum ammunition loadouts then discussion of triage strategies or injury management, despite the presumable non-availability of hospitals or medical supplies.
- viraptor 12y ago"awash in gore" is not what I mean - 300 is full of the glorification which is the problem. Sure there are people who are going to enjoy real brutality - but that's a tiny minority. I don't mean stuff you normally see on the TV where big heroes die. I mean people being aware of what soldiers actually go through and see - what gives them PTSDs for life.
- javajosh 12y agoYes, the fundamental difference is that we are wealthy. Wealthy enough to afford professional standing armies. This is a remarkable invention that gives leaders the tremendous power to wage war with hardly any personal involvement of it's citizens. War without a draft, without extra taxes, without rationing. Without widespread death, particular for the aggressor. I mean, look at the US in Iraq & Afghanistan! War these days only costs a few thousand (American) lives. Just a few billion dollars. Presidents have ridden war to political benefit for a long time. Presidents have extended the concept to "the war on drugs", and "the war on terror" and so on. Putin is taking this trend to it's logical conclusion: war is entertainment! Every good Russian will shout: the Russian team is going to win. In a few months or years, the Russian people will look at the territory that was once the Ukraine, the bodies freshly buried, and beam with pride: "We won!" they will say. Wealth has made the normal pushback (that stems from the unwillingness to die for no good reason) irrelevant, and political leaders know it.