3 ms·
> When they permitted intelligence agencies to run amok [...] they thought very little about the long term consequences I don't think intelligence agencies ar
by toyg 12y ago
> When they permitted intelligence agencies to run amok [...] they thought very little about the long term consequences
I don't think intelligence agencies are involved here at all. In fact, them "running amok" would be easier in this case: they would have those emails already, process be damned.
In truth, this particular process would have happened at one point or another regardless of intelligence services, it's just a function of global internet services existing and laws having emerged to deal with them. Back before EU privacy laws were introduced, Microsoft would have just handed out anything they had to the FBI without really a second thought. Now they have to comply with two conflicting sets of laws.
It's not just a problem with the US Congress: it's a transatlantic (or rather global) conflict between incompatible laws.
It's like France had a law prohibiting a company from selling widgets at price X worldwide, and the US had a law forcing them to sell the same widgets at price X worldwide: you just couldn't obey both laws, since they both claim the same jurisdiction while mandating conflicting behaviour. You would need an international treaty to harmonize this, or one country to drop their law.
- CamperBob2 12y agoThe involvement of intelligence agencies is indirect but very much relevant. Widespread disclosure of illegal domestic spying, including misuse of intelligence data for commercial purposes, incentivizes customers to keep their data out of the US. As a result, companies like Microsoft need to be prepared to maintain customer data outside the US, or they won't be able to compete with providers in other countries.