2 ms·
The author doesn't seem to distinguish between qualitative and quantitative difference in computation. His criticism doesn't really address the argument he quot
by varjag 17y ago
The author doesn't seem to distinguish between qualitative and quantitative difference in computation. His criticism doesn't really address the argument he quoted. The reference to IQ test distribution is not a particularly good analogy, as his opponent was speaking about limits of intelligence.
It is also worth mentioning that the notion of superintelligence is at odds with Church thesis. Which, while can't be proven, is widely accepted and is a cornerstone of computer science as we know it. Personally I think there's a better chance of breaking light speed barrier than of intelligence capable of what human (or hypothetical "ordinary AI") inherently can't.
- jacquesm 17y agoIt may not be a question of 'can't' or 'can', it may be a question of how fast. Someone that can solve complicated puzzles quickly is perceived as smarter than someone who can solve those very same puzzles but slower. Even though to all practical intents and purposes they would be equally intelligent. All the tests by which we measure ourselves have a time limit associated with them. Society is quite biased against 'slow' people, even though they may be just as smart as the rest. I'm skeptical about claims that we will be able to engineer an intelligence that is 'smarter' than we are, but I'm open to the possibility that we can engineer one that is as intelligent as we are but simply much faster. I don't expect that to happen any time soon though (soon as in the next 50 to 200 years or so), and maybe we won't be able to do this at all. But one small fact about our ability to make tools to make things that we can not make is visible in the semiconductor industry, where we have made computers that make the next generation chips, and so on. If you wanted to re-start today from 1970's technology with all the knowledge that we have about making chips it would still take quite a bit of time to get us back to the present state of the art. Maybe something similar holds for 'intelligence', that once you achieve a certain base level of intelligence that runs faster than our own and so can try many more avenues than we are capable of that might yield results faster and lead to incremental improvements in the functioning of this intelligence over time. One big factor here could be that an AI could draw on a 'perfect memory', once something is stored it would accessible for ever at very high speeds. That alone would give it a tremendous edge.
- varjag 17y agoThis isn't however what usually meant by 'superintelligence', a philosophic device predating the now-popular singularity school. Imagine a puzzle that can't be solved by "normal", human or otherwise, intelligence in infinite amount of time, but can be solved by superintelligence. Speed of thought plays no role here, nor capability of particular specimen. We talk about the limits pretty much in the same key you'd talk about the limits of functions in mathematics. That's what his virtual opponent was addressing.
- jacquesm 17y agoRight, that's a different kettle of fish - or brains. Consider this though: a neuron is not particulary 'smart', if you have enough of them they get smarter. A single human of some given intelligence may not be able to solve that puzzle, but many humans of a given intelligence working together might be able to do it. So, a true 'superintelligence' should be able to solve things that we collectively can not solve. Anything less would be just a speedup, not a breakthrough.