3 ms·
Banks too big to fail, now even biggerer
- RyanMcGreal 17y agoBigger share of the total != bigger.
- cwan 17y agoThe reason that they're considered too big to fail is the % of the market they represent and to a lesser extent the actual dollar numbers. This being said I think you'll find that if you look at both the actual numbers and percentages they have been growing in a number of metrics especially after the consolidation/failure of those like Bear Stearns and Merrill.
- 9oliYQjP 17y agoHaving bigger banks is not necessarily all bad. One of the reasons the Canadian financial system was rocked to a lesser extent than the rest of the world's is because our banking industry is dominated by a handful of big stable players. So their growth strategies recognize that they can't possibly take huge market share away from competitors. Instead, they focus on taking less risky gambles that will provide sustainable growth and minimize the risk of losing existing market share. The American banking sector seems to have a lot more competition but the competition breeds some idiotic pissing matches as each player jockeys for a better position while the opportunity exists. All this said, Canadian banks are notorious for being super conservative due to the lack of competition. During good economic times, this can be bad because they're less willing to say, provide small business loans. EDIT: was looking for marketshare stats and came across this article: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB124268900278332309.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB124268900278332309.html The top 5 banks in Canada have 85% of the banking assets.
- jhancock 17y agoInteresting take on why Canadian banks are doing well. I had heard a different take earlier this year. I read they were doing well because the Canadian gov did not deregulate to allow them to take the types of risks that banks, investment banks, and insurers have done in the U.S.
- pyre 17y agoWell, if they are not allowed to take on riskier ventures, then I was say that it's most likely that they didn't due to regulation rather than due to a more conservative stance on risk. That said, even if they simply weren't allowed to take on that risk, it's an interesting take on what could have played out had they been unregulated.
- 9oliYQjP 17y agoYes, that was also part of it. There was a period of time when the Canadian banks wanted to merge to form even bigger banks and reduce competition further. The Liberal government during the 1990s and early 2000s prevented two mergers that would have seen 4 of the top 5 banks merged into 2 companies. Then they went a step further and said they would not approve any mergers until a proper framework was in place for proving that a given merger would not a) unnecessarily concentrate economic power, b) reduce competition, and c) practically limit the government's ability to regulate the new entity. The Finance Minister at the time, Paul Martin, was the same man who brought Canada's spiralling deficit under control during the 1990s by helping to break a promise to cut a federal sales tax and cutting social program spending. He was a big factor in getting the Liberal party into majority governments between 1993 and 2003 even though he pretty much hated the Prime Minister of the time. Ironically enough, when the Prime Minister Jean Chretien decided to give up the reigns of power to Paul Martin, Canadians were pissed at the Liberals for a corruption scandal that saw tax payer money funnelled to various businesses in Quebec to promote the concept of a united Canada. Remember that in 1995, Quebec was 1% of the popular vote away from being in favour of separating from Canada; so close of a call that France had lined up in support for recognizing Quebec as a country while the Clinton administration lined up against it. Anyways, Paul Martin was popular enough that he won the election in 2003 but with a minority government, which in a parliamentary system means that the opposing parties can essentially gang up on the ruling party and force another election. This happened in early 2006, when Canadians had a chance to hear the details of how tens of millions of dollars were spent on putting Canadian flags on things like the F1 race in Montreal. They decided to vote in the Conservatives of Stephen Harper, but with a minority government, and we've been ruled by them ever since. I brought up all of these details because funny enough, one of the things the Conservatives wanted to do was push through the same financial deregulation reform that had happened south of our border. Unfortunately, having a minority government they could not do that. The Canadian banks were pushing the government to allow them more freedom and the government was simply waiting for a chance, one that they did not get because even after calling another election prematurely when they thought they had a chance to win big time, they got another minority mandate from the people. So you could say that Canadians were a bit lucky. A two-bit scandal involving tens of millions of dollars of tax payer money spent to pay for propaganda in the 1990s to help avoid the fracture of our country had the indirect effect of ensuring that our legislation could not "catch up" to the rest of the westernized world. And all the while Stephen Harper has been essentially counting his blessings because he knew that his government would have pushed through the banking deregulation reforms in 2006. That's why it makes me laugh when he goes on CNN or to Wall Street to boast about our banks. He wanted to change the rules he's now praising.
- nkassis 17y agoThey're so conservative that they only open their counter 2 hours a day. ;p
- vijayr 17y agoIs biggerer a word?
- jhancock 17y agoAccording to the Farrelly brothers, dumberer is a word, so I guess we can include biggerer as well ;)