3 ms·
That's a post hoc justification. By that logic, Americans traveling overseas should pay extra taxes for that bit of "insurance" coverage. There are about 30 mil
by dalke 12y ago
That's a post hoc justification. By that logic, Americans traveling overseas should pay extra taxes for that bit of "insurance" coverage. There are about 30 million overseas tourists per year (see http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0778210.html http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0778210.html ); according to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emigration_from_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emigration_from_the_United_Stat... there are about 5 million US citizens living overseas. (I've excluded Canada and Mexico from both of those populations.)
Assuming overseas tourists travel for only a week, this suggests they should pay an extra 2% in taxes, because they are about 10% of the overall cost. (I suspect it's higher, since tourists often need rush jobs, like an emergency passport replacement, or information about local hospitals, that residents don't need.)
I notice, though, that this isn't the case, which tells me that the underlying logic is at best incomplete.
In addition, taxation is a pure headache when combined with jus sanguinis. The Forbes article pointed out the backlog in Canada. This is because a lot of US citizens moved to Canada and had children there. By US law, these children are also US citizens, even if they've never entered the US nor consider themselves such; nor even ever plan to leave Canada.
They are still supposed to file taxes to the US, report information about their bank account holdings, etc. In addition, 'foreign financial institutions banks, brokers, pension funds, insurance companies, hedge funds, mutual funds, trusts' etc. are required 'to report to the IRS holdings of their clients who are U.S. persons.' These can be a large headache, and may even limit some financial options as certain foreign financial institutions now refuse to accept US citizens.
Hence, the US has put obligations and restrictions on them that they don't want, and must pay money to actively remove.