3 ms·
It seems that the modern idea of "art" is something that (a) has not been done before and (b) something that makes you pause and think "is this art?" To me this
by IgorPartola 12y ago
It seems that the modern idea of "art" is something that (a) has not been done before and (b) something that makes you pause and think "is this art?" To me this is a very bad way of separating art from failed attempts. First, I do not think that you can objectively call something "art" just because it's creator called it that. They can be an artist and call it whatever they want, the same way that I can write a bunch of 1s and 0s and say "that is a beautiful computer program"; in other words some stuff artists create is not art, it's attempts at art.
Secondly, art need not be novel. I enjoy sculpture, such as marble and bronze statues from Ancient Greece and Rome, as well as the Renaissance era Europe. There are lots of very similar pieces here. They all use the same mediums, similar techniques, very similar themes, and share an overall style. Yet, I enjoy this type of art. Why? Because it is so difficult to make rock look like a moving human body. Throwing dog vomit on the floor of an art gallery as commentary on the current geopolitical situation may be novel, but it is not art in my book.
Edit: as an exercise, compare Rodin's sculptures to those of Joel Shapiro. Can you really say that these are somehow on the same level?
- Detrus 12y agoIs Joel Shapiro special and famous? His work looks boring but there is more than enough aesthetic mastery in art today, someetimes on par with Rodin. Abstract, surreal, real, take your pick. Just took a quick scroll through a popular portal: http://butdoesitfloat.com/The-question-of-integrity-will-get-finer-and-finer-and-more-delicate http://butdoesitfloat.com/The-question-of-integrity-will-get... http://www.xavierhufkens.com/exhibition/2006-09-antony-gormley http://www.xavierhufkens.com/exhibition/2006-09-antony-gorml... http://butdoesitfloat.com/The-bastard-form-of-mass-culture-is-humiliated-repetition-always-new-1 http://butdoesitfloat.com/The-bastard-form-of-mass-culture-i... http://butdoesitfloat.com/The-randomness-to-which-mutation-testifies-is-implicit-in-the-very http://butdoesitfloat.com/The-randomness-to-which-mutation-t... http://www.stephan-balleux.com/index.php?id=2 http://www.stephan-balleux.com/index.php?id=2 There is so much of this it will take one weeks to wad through just the quality work. And then there is a huge sea of ugly dog vomit. Just as with any product category, if you put enough crap out there, someone will bite. If everyone sees mostly crap, they think this is as good as it gets and bite en masse. The schools producing dog vomit artists are providing a valuable service to the art market by adding variety.
- IgorPartola 12y agoMinor note: I have seen Shapiro's work in at least two major museums and one minor one. The latter was actually featuring Rodin's work at the time.