4 ms·
"Nobody 10,000 years ago had blue eyes," My reaction is that he misspoke here or he overstated his claim to make a point. I know nothing about the proportion
by breck 17y ago
"Nobody 10,000 years ago had blue eyes,"
My reaction is that he misspoke here or he overstated his claim to make a point.
I know nothing about the proportion of people with blue eyes back then or right now for that matter. But I think at the very least, you could only make that claim with a tiny, tiny, tiny amount of confidence.
Maybe the proportion of humans with blue eyes was smaller back then, maybe it was larger, or maybe it was the same. I don't know. But to claim nobody 10,000 years ago had blue eyes is an impossible point to prove unless you have DNA samples from every human alive 10,000 years ago. We might be able to say that all the people alive today with blue eyes descended from one ancestor, but we can't claim to know about the population of people with blue eyes back then. For all I know, half the population 10,000 years ago could have had blue eyes but then got wiped out by swine blue.
That's like saying no one 100 years ago was over 7'6" tall. I know a bit more about height and think that this statement may be true. But it would be real hard to prove. Now shift the timespan back by 2 orders of magnitude, and I think it'd be harder to prove.
I'm not saying that the general idea is wrong, but I'm just it would be a good idea to question that claim a lot before thinking about reasons why that might be the case.
- aaronblohowiak 17y ago" We might be able to say that all the people alive today with blue eyes descended from one ancestor" -- exactly. And, if you follow the science of using mitochondrial DNA to date genetic changes.. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molecular_clock http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molecular_clock http://www.livescience.com/health/080131-blue-eyes.html http://www.livescience.com/health/080131-blue-eyes.html
- BRadmin 17y agoAll blue eyed people traced to 10000 year old ancestor: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-511473/All-blue-eyed-people-traced-ancestor-lived-10-000-years-ago-near-Black-Sea.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-511473/All-bl...
- breck 17y agoInteresting. Thanks for the link. Although I'm not convinced from the results of one study, now I understand what the genesis of the original comment was. Evolution is a fascinating subject. I think it would be neat if all our schools taught 12 years of Reading, Writing, Arithmetic and Evolution.
- KWD 17y agoWhat I don't understand is how they can say the blue-eye mutation occurred in one single individual. I would think it is just as possible that the mutation could have occurred multiple times, and thus there would be multiple origins to those with blue eyes. I did find a different source that would tend to support the randomness of mutations, and that also indicates that there are two different mutations that can lead to blue eyes, and as such, it is unlikely there is only one ancestor. http://www.thetech.org/genetics/ask.php?id=160 http://www.thetech.org/genetics/ask.php?id=160
- frossie 17y agoAlso, it doesn't mean the blue gene aids reproductive success - it might just be related to another gene that is adaptive.