4 ms·
why we still test effectiveness on animals when there are several thousands of people who has no downside and only upside for the drug to be tested on them? Eth
by trhway 12y ago
why we still test effectiveness on animals when there are several thousands of people who has no downside and only upside for the drug to be tested on them? Ethics? It would be a strange ethics that had worked only until an American needed the cure. Something isn't right that this drug got out of shadow only when there was a need to cure an American. I mean, of course, thanks God, that i have real chance of soon becoming an American too :)
- lauraura 12y ago"And two out of seven people given the drug, have later died from the disease." Sounds like they're already doing precisely that.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- hdevalence 12y agohttp://mobile.nytimes.com/2014/08/13/world/africa/ebola.html http://mobile.nytimes.com/2014/08/13/world/africa/ebola.html The first four paragraphs describe what happened: different decisions were made by different doctors, and the drug did not "get out of the shadow only when there was a need to cure an American".
- trhway 12y ago>different decisions were made by different doctors that is exactly my point. It is a discernible trait of the system level behavior with many different people involved.
- Crito 12y agohttp://scientiasalon.wordpress.com/2014/08/14/on-the-science-and-ethics-of-ebola-treatments/ http://scientiasalon.wordpress.com/2014/08/14/on-the-science... (related HN discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8189528 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8189528) The second paragraph does a good job of summing up ethical concerns related to this particular outbreak (standard ethical concerns also apply): "The first two patients to be treated were Americans. Prior to this came the old (and historically justified) fear of testing potentially dangerous new treatments on vulnerable populations in developing countries rather than on privileged first world patients. The first ever treatment was not given to an African doctor because of this concern [1]. After Westerners were treated, complaints rose about giving infected Westerners access to a new drug while infected Africans went without. These two concerns are obviously mutually exclusive. People are concerned, they are just not sure about what, sometimes even voicing both concerns in the same article [2]."
- makomk 12y agoOne would hope that African doctors would be reasonably capable of assessing the risks and benefits of taking experimental new treatments themselves. I seem to recall the trials that people have been concerned about involved large-scale testing on poorly-educated members of the general population. (Also, I think that kind of testing still happens even now!)
- DanBC 12y agoTreating an ebola patient is complicated. Treating an ebola patient who has a bunch of weird side effects caused by an experimental drug makes a sub-optimal situation much worse.
- xtrumanx 12y ago> ..makes a sub-optimal situation much worse. I guess the OP's point was how much more sub-optimal can the situation get if the alternative to not trying the experimental drug is the death of the patient.
- roywiggins 12y agoThe alternative is a about a 40% chance of survival without the drug. With the drug, maybe it will be higher, but maybe it will be lower. We don't actually know (though this new trial is very encouraging). A bad drug could also cause suffering beyond what Ebola causes: even if the patient was going to die anyway, it could make their death even more painful.
- selectodude 12y agoI guess that's when you hope you're not in the US, and get someone to inject you with a fatal dose of morphine.
- mrexroad 12y agoif walking dead and zombie movies taught us anything, it's that things can get a whole lot more sub-optimal.
- kvb 12y agoWhy do you say there is no downside? As Jonathan Kaplan points out in the comments of the article Crito links to, Ebola is not 100% fatal and several drugs that have worked in animals have proven to have catastrophic effects when administered to humans (see e.g. TGN1412 [1]). [1] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TGN1412 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TGN1412
- colanderman 12y agoseveral drugs that have worked in animals have proven to have catastrophic effects when administered to humans This is an argument for animal testing?
- Crito 12y agoThe argument for animal testing would be that several drugs have had catastrophic effects on animals, and would have had those same catastrophic effects on humans had we not tested first on animals. Not all drugs effective for humans will be safe for animals, and not all drugs effective for animals will be safe for humans. Animal testing aims to operate in the middle-ground between the two, where things work similarly in both animals and humans.
- colanderman 12y agoYa, too bad humans with terminal diseases can't give consent to receive experimental treatments. Better to forcibly test on a being that can't say "no".
- Crito 12y agoEven if the established/widely accepted standards of ethics made human testing in lieu of any animal testing the clear ethical choice, it still would not be practical. Think about it, how would you work on potential cures of ebola in the (several times many year long: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Ebola_outbreaks http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Ebola_outbreaks) gaps between ebola outbreaks? Deliberately infect humans to be used as test subjects? Put all research on hold until the next outbreak came around? You'd be able to find plenty of human test subjects for diseases like malaria or HIV, but for many diseases you would rapidly exhaust your supply of sick humans.
- colanderman 12y agoBecause only humans are made in God's image. Therefore it's ethical to test drugs on enslaved non-human sentients incapable of acknowledging consent. EDIT: Very curious whether the downvoters (a) don't get the sarcasm, (b) get the sarcasm and are offended that I question their religious tenets, (c) think animal testing is justifiable beyond reproach, (d) disagree that monkeys are sentient, (e) think that monkeys consent to testing, or (f) just don't like how I worded things.
- trhway 12y agoopponents of animal testing in particular or anthropocentrism (like in "humans are the top of the God's creation and the Earth is given to humans into their dominion to be [ab]used as they wish") in general don't fair well on this much more conservative than one might expect site.
- colanderman 12y agoYa, unfortunately, humans don't react well when you question their worldview.