3 ms·
> As a landlord (in a different city where things are sensible and I can raise my rent or evict my tenant any time I darn well like because it's my fricking pro
by Someone1234 12y ago
> As a landlord (in a different city where things are sensible and I can raise my rent or evict my tenant any time I darn well like because it's my fricking property) this kind of thing makes me really angry.
It would be interesting to see how quickly your attitude would change if you weren't wealthy and were living under a landlord such as yourself.
Any day, for any reason or no reason, your entire life can be turned upside down. You can be effectively made homeless and given a very limited amount of time to find a similar alternative place to live that may or may not exist and may or may no be close to your work (which matters when you're poor and cannot afford public transport).
The power imbalance in this type of situation is just horrifying. Even if the tenant pays their rent on-time the landlord could still easily utilise the eviction threat in order to control the tenant (e.g. "your apartment is untidy, clean it or I'll evict you." "You went to a protest last week that I disagree with, goodbye!" "Give me your postal vote or I'll evict you.").
It might be your "property" but it is someone elses HOME. Their basic rights trump your property rights.
That's why regulation has to exist to stop people like you, so people (particularly poor people with fewer choices), get basic rights and the power imbalance is corrected.
I'm not referring to rent control: I am talking about privacy of the tenant (inspection notification periods, etc), notice for evictions (e.g. 30 days), written understanding of both the tenant and landlord's responsibilities (or default ones under the law if they lack), and so on.
It is your property, but when you rented it to someone to be their HOME part of that transaction is taking money but in exchange knowingly enabling someone else's basic rights. Those basic rights don't start and end at a rental cheque.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoYou can be effectively made homeless... You seem to be postulating a landlord that owns all the property. If you don't want to rent to me I can always find someone else. Incidentally, your concern about poor people being unable to commute to work is a bit silly. Most poor people don't have a job but do have a car. http://www.bls.gov/cps/cpswp2012.pdf http://www.bls.gov/cps/cpswp2012.pdf http://www.census.gov/prod/2008pubs/h150-07.pdf http://www.census.gov/prod/2008pubs/h150-07.pdf
- Someone1234 12y ago> You seem to be postulating a landlord that owns all the property. If you don't want to rent to me I can always find someone else. I am not postulating anything, it is a hard cold fact: If a landlord evicts a tenant with no notice they're at that point homeless (as in "with no home"). They might be able to find another property, maybe, but they also might not. It doesn't take a single landlord to own all properties in order to make it difficult for a tenant to find no place to live on literally 0 days notice (particularly when a lot of tenants living in rental accommodation are very cost constrained). > Most poor people don't have a job but do have a car. People in general don't have cars in the city, poor or rich. If someone is living on near minimum wage, and their home is moved from 10 minutes away to 20+ minutes away that is a big financial blow. That's more money, which they likely don't have, going to transport. It will be harder to find the "right" apartment if you have 0 days notice within which to do so. If you had a month or more to look for a new apartment you might be able to find something more suitable to your needs and budget. > Incidentally, your concern about poor people being unable to commute to work is a bit silly. There are people who can barely afford to put food on the table, my concerns about public transport costs are quite valid I assure you.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoIf you are worried about finding a place with 0 days notice, ask that your lease include a "30 days notice" clause. I've never seen a lease agreement that didn't have one. Most lease contracts are 12 months. That gives you 1 year of warning. If someone is living on near minimum wage... Most poor people aren't. http://www.people.vcu.edu/~lrazzolini/GR2010.pdf http://www.people.vcu.edu/~lrazzolini/GR2010.pdf There are people who can barely afford to put food on the table Poor people are typically fat. The typical poor person has no job, if he does have a job it isn't minimum wage, and he has a car. He would also be healthier if he put less food on the table. Why do you keep discussing these completely atypical poor people, and extremely uncommon rental contracts?
- Someone1234 12y ago> If someone is living on near minimum wage... >> Most poor people aren't. >> http://www.people.vcu.edu/~lrazzolini/GR2010.pdf http://www.people.vcu.edu/~lrazzolini/GR2010.pdf That link doesn't claim what you claim it claims. It talks about impact, and excludes a large chunk of the population for different reasons that it doesn't go into great lengths to justify (see page 597 (6 on the PDF)). Also the definition that they use for povery is extremely literal, see here for more info on that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty_in_the_United_States#Measures_of_poverty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty_in_the_United_States#M... Even with their massive amount of exclusions it still impacts almost 10%. >> There are people who can barely afford to put food on the table > Poor people are typically fat. That's an incredibly ignorant thing to say. It is like responding to global warming by saying "it is snowing outside!" Obesity is a side-effect of poverty. One person being obese doesn't exclude another from starving. > The typical poor person has no job, if he does have a job it isn't minimum wage, and he has a car. He would also be healthier if he put less food on the table. That's just raw bigotry now. You have given up the pretence even, you just hate poor people. > Why do you keep discussing these completely atypical poor people, and extremely uncommon rental contracts? They aren't atypical, they're extremely typical. Even according to your own link they make up around 10%. According to less exclusionary sources they make up more.
- pkaye 12y agoMost landlords have a loan and haven't fully paid for their property. If the property goes into foreclosure, do you want to owner to go to debtors prison until they pay off their debt because obviously is the banks/investors money? Fact is as a property owner you have gotten certain concessions from society and similar ones are given to renters.
- afafsd 12y ago>It would be interesting to see how quickly your attitude would change if you weren't wealthy and were living under a landlord such as yourself. It's funny because I do live under a landlord such as myself, in a different city. I'm both a landlord and a tenant. >Any day, for any reason or no reason, your entire life can be turned upside down. You can be effectively made homeless and given a very limited amount of time to find a similar alternative place to live that may or may not exist and may or may no be close to your work (which matters when you're poor and cannot afford public transport). Sure, that would be inconvenient, but I'd get a reasonable amount of notice (60 days in any case where I haven't done anything wrong) which would be sufficient for me to line something else up. >I'm not referring to rent control: I am talking about privacy of the tenant (inspection notification periods, etc), notice for evictions (e.g. 30 days) Oh, so we're actually in agreement. I agree, there certainly needs to be notice if you feel like kicking your tenant out. That's just a matter of practicality.
- FireBeyond 12y ago"but I'd get a reasonable amount of notice (60 days in any case where I haven't done anything wrong)" Tangential trivia: in some states, even "progressive" states like Washington, this number can be as low as 20 days. That can be a burden: "Quick, find a new house, move, come up with at least first month's rent and a security deposit that is usually equal to a month's rent, in less than three weeks".
- secabeen 12y agoYou can't "evict my tenant any time I darn well like because it's my fricking property)", as you have to give "a reasonable amount of notice (60 days in any case where I haven't done anything wrong)".