4 ms·
Bonuses Are the New Raises
- gopalv 12y agoVariable pay is also paid in bulk at the end of the year. There are people I know who just struggle through to stick around till that pay day, particularly when the winter days are long and painful to get through at work. That works for retention for a certain mind-set. For someone like me, my last job triggered the right impulses. By having quarterly review cycles - keeps you on your toes (with the extra management overhead of going through the reviews/budgets etc). Someone around you was getting a raise every quarter - next time it could be you ... just buckle down for 3 months. Plus they gave promotions in role 3 months before the raise.
- colanderman 12y agowinter days are long and painful to get through at work. ??? Winter's the best time to be employed, at least in moderate climates. It's freezing outside, and inside there's the glow of a warm terminal. Summer's when I can barely keep myself working. You can actually get outside and enjoy life.
- ianstallings 12y agoThe short days of winter make some of us gloomy unfortunately.
- colanderman 12y agoAh OK. I forgot about Seasonal Affective Disorder. I wonder what causes humans to have such polar-opposite reactions to the seasons?
- jobu 12y agoThere was a great TED Podcast called "The Money Paradox" that talked about how poorly money works as a motivator for creative professions: http://www.npr.org/2014/04/04/295368808/how-much-does-money-motivate-us http://www.npr.org/2014/04/04/295368808/how-much-does-money-...
- MadManE 12y agoIt should be noted that this assumes that a basic level of income has been reached. While it's not usually a concern for the type of crowd that might frequent HN, it is a pretty big caveat.
- incision 12y agoI was just about to suggest Daniel Pink's book [1] when I clicked through and saw that a talk from him is a segment on the podcast. In any case, the book is worth a read. I had a copy forced on me years and didn't crack it open for ages - I wish I'd started reading it sooner. 1: http://www.amazon.com/dp/1594484805 http://www.amazon.com/dp/1594484805
- syntern 12y agoWhile this is true for many, not necessarily for all, and I'd definitely call bullshit if you try to generalize it. It boils down to personal goals. Let's assume I want to build a real-world helicopter. I don't work in that industry, nevertheless, I earn something reasonable, and I am happy with it. Money may not be a prime motivator for my everyday job, but any 'above-the-minimum-happiness' money contributes to my long-term plan of building a real-world helicopter. And having such a long-term goal, in addition with the money that helps me to achieve that will increase my happiness way more than I've had been just with the job and less money. Having more money without a goal is not a motivator. Getting more money to achieve an already established goal is.
- jobu 12y agoThere are two problems with setting goals for anything but menial tasks: 1) It's incredibly hard to set goals for complex projects without having unforeseen problems or side-effects (e.g. the product shipped on time, but it's buggy) 2) Experiments have consistently shown that creativity is negatively impacted by incentives (possibly due to stress causing narrowed focus)
- encoderer 12y agoIn the market for prized tech talent in the SF Bay Area, a good environment, self direction, room to develop mastery, etc, are table stakes. So what's left? Cash, equity and benefits. And they definitely matter.
- ethanhunt_ 12y agoScheduled cash bonuses and multi-year stock vesting schedules are a great way to retain employees who don't want to work for you anymore. I have no clue why companies think this is a good idea.
- endtime 12y agos/Scheduled cash bonuses/Raises/ and I don't think you'd take the same critical tone. I work for Google, and a significant chunk of my comp is in stock. I was awarded an additional $N of stock over four years this year, and I just considered it a raise of $N/4.
- jonknee 12y agoYes, the point being that if you started to hate your job there's a good chance you'd stick around to the next vesting period. The same happens with an annual bonus, no one wants to leave before the bonus checks come out. The Valley likes stock, Wall Street likes bonuses (funny in a way). Update: it also means you can stay at the job all year for the bonus/stock and then get laid off right before the end of the year. It's deplorable.
- scottm01 12y agoMaybe Wall Street is made up of "grunts" who understand the value of cash and properly discounts the promise of paper profits later! That said, like earlier posters I can only budget around my base salary. I would of course prefer that "guaranteed" bonuses come in the form of base comp paid every check. If you want to incentivize me to create shareholder value and stick around; offer a generous ESPP.
- tcoppi 12y agoPersonally I wouldn't use an ESPP at all. You've already got your current job invested in the company, why would you want to put more eggs into that basket?
- busterarm 12y agoChanging jobs is the new raise.
- allegory 12y agoThis, a million times. In the UK, by changing jobs a few times, I managed to get from £14k to £46k in 4 years :-)
- purringmeow 12y agoHow did that happen? Did you need more XP for the higher-paying jobs and got it from the previous ones?
- allegory 12y agoThree things: 1. working every hour of every day to be the best I could be and proving it on a daily basis. 2. Don't move job without taking a big raise. Play offers off against each other 3. Circulate amongst old fashioned corporates. It's easier to look good there as most of the staff are crap.
- _random_ 12y agoThey simply ask what is your previous salary and offer a 5-25% increase. You skills are simply a pre-requisite, but they don't define your starting salary. Depending on your risk appetite and potential background checks one can lie and get a fairer deal (the firm is always protected since they have a notice period).
- conradfr 12y agoWhich is why I don't get people staying at their current job if the company simply match the offer, especially for a company that never gives raise otherwise. Looking for jobs, going to interviews, negotiating, it takes time and energy.
- like_do_i_care 12y agoBonuses - the single incentive that turns colleague against colleague, after all, it is not enough to get a bonus, but if you can make out your colleague under delivered, maybe you can grab a share of their potential bonus pie slice too. See this every day in a large Investment Bank. Bonus chasing bastards do not protect or grow the brand, they just ensure short term decisions remain the order of the day.
- seanflyon 12y agoAny system that incentivizes having coworker under deliver is a bad idea. There is no reason bonuses have to fall in that category and in my personal experience they never have. Where I have worked bonuses we bases on a combination of personal performance, team performance and company performance so you got a bigger bonus if your coworkers did well.
- ianstallings 12y agoI think a better plan for retention and performance would be ownership plans of some sort. Equity, options, stock purchasing plans, employee ownership plans, etc.
- jonknee 12y agoHaving compensation be arbitrarily controlled by management makes it easy to tweak your numbers in a hurry. End of the quarter approaching and sales are still soft? Sorry "team member", no bonus this time. Just working on "proving yourself" and you'll be getting a bonus in no time!
- djur 12y agoI appreciate bonuses for what they are, but salary is always more important to me than a bonus. An offer of $x/yr salary and $b/yr bonus is less valuable to me than $x+n/yr salary, even if n<b and the bonus is characterized as a sure thing. My budgeting has to be based on my salary, not my bonus, and my monthly budget defines my standard of living. What I can spend on housing, food, and entertainment depends on salary, as does how much I can expect to put in savings every month. Over the long term, sure, bonuses can contribute to that baseline. They can go into discretionary expenses like vacations, home improvements, new furniture and gadgets, and they can help bolster savings and investments. But depending on bonuses when making long-term financial commitments is more of a risk than I'm willing to make. And don't even get me started on equity/stock options/etc. That stuff is usually granted in terms that are heavily weighted toward the employer's benefit. Work should be compensated with money, not investment opportunities.
- encoderer 12y agoHow is equity granted in a way that favors employers? I'm curious what you mean. The caveat I'd add to your first point is... bonuses for me have been an important part of accelerating savings and retirement. I personally do not define my financial success by my month-to-month standard of living but rather by my net worth. And in those terms, a bonus dollars spends the same. Of course, though, that in the hypothetical case you were offered $10,000 raise or $10,000 bonus, certainly the raise is better. But that's a strawman. A more interesting analysis would be where is the line drawn? Is a 5k raise better than a 10k bonus? I'd probably take the bonus in that case, honestly, because time value of money and all. So where is the line drawn?
- djur 12y agoLong vesting periods, and the fact that, well, what you get at the end is an investment in your employer. So it's like getting money, except you don't get it for a few years, and someone else invests it for you. As far as 10k bonus vs. 5k raise, sure: if you're being offered 10k now versus 5k over the next year, and you expect to receive another 10k next year in lieu of the same 5k, then you're coming out ahead. But the case I'm talking about is when you're getting a compensation offer including a bonus, in which case you're choosing between 5k over the next year versus 10k in a year (maybe). A signing bonus of some sort, where you're receiving an immediate guaranteed payoff (or even a guaranteed payoff at some point in the future), is a completely different beast than a performance bonus as part of a compensation package.
- forgotAgain 12y agoThis is the only way we're going to encourage those on top to be super-productive and provide for the rest of us. Be happy for what you have or there will be no gruel for you anymore.
- cryoshon 12y agoYou mean that bonuses are the new raises for employees who work in a few narrow white collar fields? Sure. But really, the "new raise" for most of the proletariat is leaving your salaried job which won't give you a raise because "money is tight" (despite record profits) and finding a new job which will pay you %10 more. No loyalty from the employer begets no loyalty from the employee; this labor situation favors the employers, which is why it is so. If we're talking realistically, there is no "new raise", and the majority of workers (especially hourly workers) don't get substantial bonuses whatsoever. There's yearly wages losing out to inflation and higher cost of living, and a stagnation in wage increases that has gone on for 30 years, on the broad view of things. The article also mentions an "economic recovery" while failing to mention that labor engagement as a percentage of the population is at a 30 year low even when controlling for demographic factors. It's as though the author is living in a fantasy land where only positive information is taken into account when drafting an article.
- encoderer 12y agoAmen. Real wage growth stalled in this country since the 1970s. Corporate profits through the roof in same time frame. Stock market, what, 5x?
- Iftheshoefits 12y agoSince when were bonuses measures of merit or performance? It's more likely they're measures of company financial performance (in the case of the net pool), and the political whims of a manager (in the case of individual distributions).