4 ms·
> I'm not sure how much value there is in putting it out there I'm sure there is great value in putting it out there if people find it later. The problem is t
by dspillett 12y ago
> I'm not sure how much value there is in putting it out there
I'm sure there is great value in putting it out there if people find it later. The problem is two fold: firstly where do you put it (journals with limited space and limited time for reviewing content aren't going to be all that interested, and people aren't going to trust some random page on the Internet), and secondly will people even look for it before starting their work?
This affects many scientific area and not just this one - just think how many instances there have been of medical experiments going ahead based on the results of a study or two despite the fact that a bunch of other studies contradicted the findings? Those studies either were not where they could be easily found, were not searched for, or were not published at all at the time. This is particularly problematic when there is a conflict of interests due to studies being commissioned by those selling the products/processes/ideas they hope the studies will support: there is a commercial drive to publish every success and down play every less positive result.
- harvestmoon 12y agoMaybe this type of issue would be ideal for a highly curated, online database. At the moment, for instance, I've done a lot of research into biomedical topics, and get pretty much all my info through online pdfs linked to from PubMed. (Though, of course, most of those have been published in a reputable journal.) Still, if the content was both checked for being reasonable and also classified well, then this type of online database could possibly provide a lot of value to researchers.