2 ms·
Yes. Open minded comments like this, questioning the limits of science get down voted here on HN.
by collyw 12y ago
Yes. Open minded comments like this, questioning the limits of science get down voted here on HN.
- goblin89 12y agoI didn't downvote, but if you ask me I'd say others did it mainly because grandparent brought philosophy into scientific discussion. (And with reasoning or phrasing issues at that: “we can't do something even if we can”, for example, contradicts itself.)
- halfcat 12y agoIronic that science is a subset of philosophy.
- goblin89 12y agoThat's precisely why, IMHO, if you aren't prepared to make a complete well-thought-through argument, then you should think twice before venturing into a philosophical discussion. On the other hand, due to the nature of HN, one has to choose between either spending a few days researching the comment and posting it with a very slim chance of being read or answered, or blurting out something not very polished. In this case it's the latter. (How you define “objective”? “reality”? A rough example of how could the answer to the question “what reality is” roughly look like? Any links to existing research—people certainly attempted to ask a question of this nature before?) The resulting discussion may be worth it, though.