3 ms·
>With their field stuck at a nasty impasse of course. Natural thing when a field is dominated by orthodoxy that closes their eyes to everything that they don't
by trhway 12y ago
>With their field stuck at a nasty impasse
of course. Natural thing when a field is dominated by orthodoxy that closes their eyes to everything that they don't want to see. Like yesterday "entangled photon imaging" where what really happens is that a beam modulated by an image heats/excites crystal (with that heating/excitement thus obviously modulated by the image) which generates another beam (thus that another beam is obviously also modulated by the image) which hits CCD - no miracle of entanglement here, yet Nature published it as such :
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8234221 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8234221
as "entanglement" and "mutiverse" are very much in fashion this season and get you published.
With Higgs as a "mass" boson it was also non-starter because the theory of it failed to address gravitational and inertial mass equivalence. I mean i don't doubt that CERN found new particle of course, yet nowhere it was shown that it is the boson "generating mass". The article seems to suggest that finally the mainstream physics starts to seriously ponder whether the mass is a result of dynamic interaction - that has been obvious for decades to the "fringe" physicists, who couldn't just dismiss the above mentioned gravitational and inertial mass connection, a pretty fundamental fact that has to be at the center of anything called physics :)
- l33tbro 12y agoI wouldn't say that the "field is dominated by orthodoxy that closes their eyes to everything that they don't want to see". I'll admit most physicists I've met are suspicious of wild-eyed theory. But I wouldn't say they're overly orthodox. I think it's more a healthy skepticism of anything which involves humans projecting science-ficiton wish-fulfilment into science. I'd go further and say that "entanglement" and "multiverse" are not at all en vogue. I think most seasoned physicists realize that these were trendy fields some years ago (for solipsistic reasons - ie, make us feel special). So I think the return to a fundamental assessment of phenomena is pretty natural thing. Calling out assumptions like scale. What's more, I think the more discerning will also be suspicious of the "post-multiverse" dialectic. It's just the process really.
- trhway 12y ago>I'll admit most physicists I've met are suspicious of wild-eyed theory. ... >So I think the return to a fundamental assessment of phenomena is pretty natural thing. Calling out assumptions like scale. i see big difference between "Calling out assumptions like scale" as a "return to a fundamental assessment of phenomena" and "Calling out assumptions like scale" in order to fit it into a wild-eyed theory like superstrings (basically to salvage the theory).
- Strilanc 12y agoI'm not sure why you're grouping entanglement in with the multiverse. One of those is a theoretical idea for reducing the Solomonoff complexity of the universe with no clear experimental implications. The other is an integral component of how we predicted and explain experimentally confirmed phenomena like violations of Bell's inequalities, the Elitzur-Vaidman bomb tester, quantum cryptography, and quantum teleportation.
- trhway 12y agobecause both violate Occam's razor (and both stem from very specific treatment of superposition). Like in the above mentioned "imaging by entanglement", a closer look at the experiment always reveals explanations for the observed effect without necessity to involve the "magic" of entanglement.
- Strilanc 12y agoHow do you explain Bell inequality violations without involving entanglement? If we get quantum computers working at a non-trivial scale, would you consider that to be strong evidence for entanglement?
- trhway 12y ago>How do you explain Bell inequality violations without involving entanglement? i still can't in details :) I so far have worked my way only until double-slit experiments - no superposition there :) For Bell violations i bet we have the same mis-interpretation of statistical aggregate description as individual realization (this "mis-interpreation" is the Copenghagen's superposition) as in double-slits. In case of Bell violations experiments it seems to be the same as "disjoint sampling loophole" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loopholes_in_Bell_test_experiments#Disjoint_sampling" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loopholes_in_Bell_test_experime... >If we get quantum computers working at a non-trivial scale, would you consider that to be strong evidence for entanglement? it would be strong evidence for superposition and thus for entanglement. Want these computers like anybody else, yet don't really see them happening :(
- 12y ago