4 ms·
“Now, I can think of three really good reasons why you shouldn’t do something like that, George.” 1. The process to revive a person after freezing does not exi
by teddyh 12y ago
“Now, I can think of three really good reasons why you shouldn’t do something like that, George.”
1. The process to revive a person after freezing does not exist. Current speculations about how it would work are so mired and poisoned by wishful thinking that it is essentially impossible to know whether it will ever exist.
2. Even if the process will some day exist, it will be too late for you if you were not frozen correctly. It’s like writing a zip/compress program and speculating that someone in the future might one day invent unzip/uncompress – if unzip or uncompress eventually does appear, it is extremely likely to show bugs in the implementation and/or specification of the original zip or compress program, making all data previously thought to be “compressed” instead utterly corrupt and worthless.
3. The incentives are all wrong for the actual truth to surface. The incentive for a company in this business is to imply that the science is (or will soon be) much farther along than it currently is, and a customer has the incentive to believe this, since the alternative is death. To paraphrase: It is difficult to get someone to understand something, when their life depends upon them not understanding it.
- kvee 12y agoAlcor is a non-profit, and they're not implying anything other than the truth, which is that you're unlikely to get unfrozen, but it'd be cool if somehow you could be and maybe one day someone will figure it out. And this is exactly why more research should be done to figure it out. Human creativity when provided the right incentives and not over-regulated is a pretty powerful thing. Future generations may look back on us as unbelievably primitive and may have trouble believing that we suffered physical death and thought it an inescapable and acceptable part of life.
- teddyh 12y ago> […] maybe one day someone will figure it out. So it’s like Pascal’s wager, except it is a real wager which costs money. > […] more research should be done […] Absolutely, but it is very hard to guard against wishful thinking, which absolutely everybody has an incentive to succumb to. > Future generations may […] have trouble believing that we suffered physical death […] …and there it is.
- blueskin_ 12y ago>So it’s like Pascal’s wager, except it is a real wager which costs money. Even if you have the money, it's recommended you don't pay directly as it can get caught up in legal battles, all the while your brain is rotting. the vast majority pay via life insurance, although if you were for whatever reason uninsurable and had sufficient cash on hand, I guess they might accept it while you are still alive as a donation. Unlike pascal's wager, it's also the only game in town when it comes to avoiding death, unlike religion where if you picked the wrong one out of any of the millions that have existed in human history, you made a mistake that ruins your chances under the vast majority of them (AKA "What happens if you spend your life praying to Jesus in the hopes of getting a reward, then you end up facing Hel, Anubis, Hades/Pluto, Erebus, Allah, Mormon Space Kolob God, any of the native american myths, Flying Spaghetti Monster, or even Cthulhu instead?").
- afafsd 12y ago>Alcor is a non-profit I'm not convinced that being a non-profit vs for-profit really changes the incentives for an organisation. No doubt the founder and CEO is paying himself a comfortable salary out of Alcor's money.
- blueskin_ 12y agoSo, like every other charity in the world? Actually, they are still better than that as they don't blow millions worth of donations on long guilt-tripping TV adverts. Honestly, if a few employees make a living, I'm fine with that; good for them for advancing the field of life extension.
- teddyh 12y ago> So, like every other charity in the world? Yes, the incentives in this case are the same.
- apsec112 12y agoMaking data "utterly corrupt and worthless" is actually really hard, even if you're deliberately trying to erase it. That's why we invented secure disk erase programs (eg. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gutmann_method http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gutmann_method), because people keep inventing better ways to get back 'deleted' data you might not have wanted them to see. This goes triple for the brain, which is analog and highly redundant. You can have large chunks of your brain physically ripped out (examples on request) and still live a pretty normal life afterwards, unlike modern computers where a single off bit can crash a program. http://www.benbest.com/cryonics/CryoFAQ.html http://www.benbest.com/cryonics/CryoFAQ.html
- DanBC 12y agoJust a side note: the Gutmann algorithms have nothing to do with defeating better methods of recovering data. He created optimal patterns for each drive controller he had available. You would only ever use the full set if you didn't know what controller you had - otherwise using a single set would be fine. Gutmann himself says that a few overwrites of random data is about as good as you can do.
- teddyh 12y agoFirstly, the Gutmann method is seriously outdated. Nowadays, for modern SAS/SATA drives, a normal overwrite of the data is perfectly sufficient for all cases – if I recall correctly, nobody has been able to restore any data thusly overwritten. (This is for magnetic drives. For SSD drives, “overwriting” does not actually overwrite, so anything and everything might be still accessible.) Secondly, it has happened that people has suffered major brain damage and survived with ”only” personality changes and mobility impairments, but I posit that these cases are rare, and not nearly the normal case you make them out to be. Thirdly, it is a rather large step to go from simply having your data all there and usable to having to hire, no, wait, invent, data recovery technology.
- blueskin_ 12y ago1. Nobody has been frozen since the 80s. The process is vitrification, which is designed to mitigate most of the damage and cracking that occurs. Vitrified animal organs (a rabbit's, iirc) have been successfully restored and implanted into an animal which stayed healthy. The main danger is in ischemia if you are not given cardiopulmonary support during the cool down process, which might cause brain damage. 2. That would be true if brains worked on all-or-nothing integrity, but they don't. The last people to be preserved will be the first to be brought back; as techniques get more advanced they will allow saving older patients. There are a few people that are likely nonviable due to extreme circumstances (one suicide and one murder victim where the body was autopsied and so left warm for a long time, as well as having the brain removed from the skull (it is normally preserved within the skill), for example) but as the brain is still intact in both cases, they are certainly still potentially recoverable with adequate medical technology. Remember when any random disease could kill someone simply because it wasn't treatable? We're at that stage with brain injury. As it is, even if something went wrong and I died and wasn't preserved, I wouldn't even know as I would be dead. 3. Go and read Alcor's site some time. It's full of useful information including very detailed reports of procedures. Alcor admit that it will likely be a long time until many patients can be recovered, but the entire company is structured in a way to ensure that money is kept in long term investment. People's life does potentially literally depend on cryonics and Alcor at least would not wish to have a patient without an understanding of the process.
- teddyh 12y ago1. You ignored my point to instead attack my word choice. I actually took that word (“frozen”) from the article title. But we could call it “mummification” for all I care – it does not alter any point I was making. 2. (I have nothing to add to this beyond my other replies in this thread.) 3. I argued that any information from a company in this business is likely to be biased, and you suggest I read the company’s information because they would like to have informed customers? What? That does not follow.