4 ms·
Traffic Ghost Hunting
- dkarapetyan 12y agoI like the idea suggested in the article. I'd like an IoT device that broadcasts my breaking and acceleration pattern to nearby drivers to help dissipate the jamiton.
- deathanatos 12y ago> However, in reality, the flow is constantly exposed to small perturbations: imperfections on the asphalt, tiny hiccups of the engines, half-seconds of driver inattention, and so on. I could see this — random imperfections and subtle movements of drivers causing someone to back off or brake. (I've definitely noticed other drivers being fearful of other drivers solely through their positioning on the road.) Engine hiccups sounds a bit fishy; does that happen to people? That said, I've also witnessed drivers with several hundred meters of open road in front of them — sometimes road as far as the eye can see — inexplicably brake. I've always wanted to ask them why. > Those who drive preventively can dissipate jamitons, and benefit all of the drivers behind them. I think it mostly boils down to listening to your driver's ed teacher, if you had one. Leave following distance. Other drivers tend to make this exceedingly hard, but if you can keep enough, you can keep your velocity relatively stable (and hopefully everyone behind you's velocity, too!) even when the car in front of you is doing a lot of braking and accelerating. I do it just so I don't have to move my foot so darn much in a traffic jam. Likewise, if you pay attention to how much following distance exists in front of the car in front of you, you can predict fairly well when that driver will need to brake and how hard. If they're tailgating, you'll need a larger following distance yourself if you don't want to tap the brake when they brake. I also use this when traffic looks like it's speeding up again, and I might want to close the gap in front of me a bit — I take into account how much of a gap is in front of the guy in front of me, to see how likely he is to brake while I try to catch up to him. …of course, these are just my experiences.
- bitJericho 12y agoI might break if I thought I saw something coming out of the side of the road for some reason. That doesn't happen very often. I might break if I realize that exit is the one I need, but oh! I should be more careful, nevermind I'll get the next one. Might break if I realize I'm suddenly going way too much over the limit, and maybe hard if I believe there's a cop that could be watching me :D I can't really think of any other reasons I might break inexplicably.
- UrMomReadsHN 12y ago> I've also witnessed drivers with several hundred meters of open road in front of them — sometimes road as far as the eye can see — inexplicably brake. I've always wanted to ask them why. I've always thought that was because some people drive automatic transmission with their left foot on the brake. Your left foot eventually gets tired and hits the brake slightly.
- barrystaes 12y agoHere (Netherlands) the overhead matrix highway signs indicate lower (legal!) maximum speeds the nearer you get to a traffic jam. I was under the impression that this wasn't spectacular.. it just makes sense. Of course there are smart-ass people (mostly driving Audi here) who race on only to break hard later.. this of course is futile in itself and even worsens the traffic jam. And if the authors point is to use this in car-to-car communication: what else do you think car-to-car communication is for..? On a related note, i propose using telephones for talking.
- vog 12y ago> Here (Netherlands) the overhead matrix highway signs indicate lower (legal!) maximum speeds the nearer you get to a traffic jam. Same here in Germany. I know this from Berlin's inner highway which has automatic traffic signs. Sometimes just a jam warning sign appears, sometimes the maximum speed is reduced, sometimes both at once. > On a related note, i propose using telephones for talking. I often had a similar thought: What if I could talk to the people in the cars next to me? What are they thinking? Why do they act the way they do? However, I quickly abandoned that thought. The traffic is moving very fast, decisions must be made very quickly. There's no time for a quick chat with all the drivers around me. It would be an additional distraction that would probably do more harm than good.
- Huggernaut 12y agoThese exist in the UK on some motorways as well. However, my observation is that the new maximum speed is always indicated miles and miles before an incident so drivers ignore them anyway until they reach the jam.
- nl 12y agoIt would be interesting to see a similar study done on (racing) cyclists in a peloton. It's fairly rare to see similar behaviour in that environment, and I'm not sure why. Maybe the fear of road rash is enough to make people ignore phantoms.
- teddyh 12y agoSee also: Traffic Waves (1998, William Beaty, http://amasci.com/amateur/traffic/traffic1.html http://amasci.com/amateur/traffic/traffic1.html).
- snarfy 12y agoMost cars show the current miles per gallon. This naturally dips to a very poor amount when you accelerate quickly. Instead they should show the rate money is being spent based on the current price per gallon. It would be a better incentive to have a light foot when driving. Going with the flow is going to be the most efficient use of gas, so naturally it will avoid jams.
- UrMomReadsHN 12y ago>Instead they should show the rate money is being spent based on the current price per gallon. That would be incredibly complex. You'd have to have internet connectivity and a central server to download that data. Average where? Average in Hawaii or Kansas? Gas prices change every day, too. So the solution would to be have a GPS on when you fill up your tank and record a timestamp and average price for the current area where the tank was filled up. I'm not convinced that the benefit would be worth the work and privacy implications and would only be available on the highest end cars. It could be argued people spending their money on a higher end car are less worried about how much they are spending on transportation so less worried about how much they are spending on gas... I'm also not convinced anyone would pay attention to that number or if they did understand how to improve it without clear instructions. It is just another number being displayed. They would have to be paying really close attention to notice a pattern at all and if they are paying so much attention I'm arguing they aren't paying attention to the road.
- snarfy 12y agoOr you could tell the car how much you paid when you get gas. Actually, it doesn't matter what the current price is. What's being measured is the fuel efficiency, which is already done. Screw it, bring on the self driving car overlords.