4 ms·
Words have meaning. When we hit the edge of technology those meanings tends to be obscure or wrong and so we need a new word. Murder is so final, while this is
by tomjen3 12y ago
Words have meaning. When we hit the edge of technology those meanings tends to be obscure or wrong and so we need a new word.
Murder is so final, while this is more akind to shutting down a computer that you hope to be able to start up again. Hence active shutdown being a more appropriate idea.
- jacquesm 12y agoUntil someone is revived we can consider it final.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoWell, the whole idea of cryopreservation is that it's a hedge against the progress of technology. One can't be sure we'll ever get to the required level of development (in my belief, we will inevitably, if we won't destroy our civilization beforehand), but it's still better than Just Dying, and - as opposed to religious afterlife vision - it's clear that restoring a cryopreserved person is possible in principle.
- jacquesm 12y agoIn my view it is exactly equivalent to just dying until it has been proven otherwise. > it's clear that restoring a cryopreserved person is possible in principle. Is it?
- TeMPOraL 12y agoTo quote from Wikipedia, "A central premise of cryonics is that long-term memory, personality, and identity are stored in durable cell structures and patterns within the brain that do not require continuous brain activity to survive.[13] This premise is generally accepted in medicine; it is known that under certain conditions the brain can stop functioning and still later recover with retention of long-term memory." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cryonics#Neuropreservation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cryonics#Neuropreservation What we can do today, is preserving the brain structure. What we can't do today is to restore the brain and body after prolonged preservation, and to fix whatever illnesses caused the patient to undergo this procedure in the first place. Both of those problems seem to be tractable with nanotech, which we know is real and works (we usually call it "life", but life is nothing but a nanotech that's not ours and we can't controll well enough yet). So at this point I'd say cryopreservation is a bet against continued technological progress (which is not bad, because not taking it means certainly dying), not an act of faith. One can argue against economics of such, and the cost a cryopreserved person imposes on the living, but comparing it to faith in God and resurrection is IMO wrong.
- jacquesm 12y agoThere are so many assumptions here it might as well be religion: - that death does not alter the structure irrepairably - that the structure and information contained therein will not degrade over time - that the freezing process itself won't damage the information - that the information will be recoverable - that we will be able to make sense of such information - that the information after successful restoration can be transplanted into some other medium - that this other medium will be able to 'execute' using that information - that the electrical component of brain activity once lost can be restored - and that all of the above will result in a restoration of consciousness - and that this consciousness will somehow be given the status of person (that's more of a social issue) All of these together to me are equivalent to or maybe even greater than believing in God.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoLet's go line by line. - that death does not alter the structure irrepairably As far as we can tell, if we freeze it quick enough, it won't. No magic required. (death doesn't mean something magical is happening to matter, it only means molecular machines stop working the way they should) - that the structure and information contained therein will not degrade over time Possible. Manageable with technology. Testable. No magic required. - that the freezing process itself won't damage the information Possible. Subject to fixing by improved technology. Testable. No magic required. - that the information will be recoverable Possible by definition of solving previous two points. Subject to advanced enough technology, which cryopreserved people are hedging against. No magic required. - that we will be able to make sense of such information See above. - that the information after successful restoration can be transplanted into some other medium Not required. Technology advanced enough to revive a cryopreserved patient will likely be able to fix the original medium. Technology already exists (in form of nanotechnology - viruses, bacteria, proteins, enzymes), but we don't know how to use it yet, as we didn't build it. No magic required. - that this other medium will be able to 'execute' using that information See above. Also, if you really insist on another medium, then it depends on whether or not brains run on magic. If they are not, then the problem is addressable with technology (develop a good enough medium). - that the electrical component of brain activity once lost can be restored Evidence suggests that this component is mostly irrelevant. Even if, it's solvable with technology (tough luck to those already preserved though). No magic required. - and that all of the above will result in a restoration of consciousness Unless you believe consciousness is magic, it's possible by definition of solving #2/#3. - and that this consciousness will somehow be given the status of person (that's more of a social issue) That's a social issue, but again, if consciousness is not a magical process, we can hope the society will mature enough to be able to accept revived people as persons. > All of these together to me are equivalent to or maybe even greater than believing in God. Now this IMO does not follow. There're no supernatural phenomena required to address any assumptions you stated, so isn't this by definition requiring qualitatively less faith than religion?
- tomjen3 12y agoThat is certainly one option. It is also the most pessimistic version, which is why a pro tech forum like HN is not likely to take it as the majority view.
- meepmorp 12y ago> Murder is so final, while this is more akind to shutting down a computer that you hope to be able to start up again. Hence active shutdown being a more appropriate idea. The flaw in the analogy is that there's fairly widespread experience in restarting computers after shutdown, as well as a wealth of knowledge about how fix the computer if it doesn't come back up. None of that holds for cryonics and human death.