3 ms·
I'm guessing that you are over 30. People who are young professionals now do not remember the Cold War at all, and have grown up considering the U.S. to be ess
by snowwrestler 12y ago
I'm guessing that you are over 30.
People who are young professionals now do not remember the Cold War at all, and have grown up considering the U.S. to be essentially invulnerable on the international stage.
The terrorist attacks of 9/11 were the worst thing they've experienced. But while those were terrible, they were clearly not an existential threat to the entire country, the way that the Soviet Union was for 50 years, or Germany or Japan before that.
Thus, many young people see international espionage primarily as a means of corrupting lesser states for our own benefit--an abuse of our considerable power.
- DanBC 12y agoHow much of that existential threat was really real though? Apart from the Cuban missile crisis was there ever any real threat to the US from Russia? This is a genuine question, I really don't know the answer. I do know that Americans spent a lot of time with "Duck and Cover" exercises. the UK equivalent was "Protect and Survive" - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protect_and_Survive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protect_and_Survive
- snowwrestler 12y agoI think there are really two questions here. 1) How much of an existential threat really existed? This question can be answered by looking through the vast archives of Soviet-era information which has now been made publicly available. I'm not an expert, but I'd say it's a mixed answer--the capability for total destruction really did exist, and there were some close calls [1]. But the USSR was a lot less interested in killing everyone than folks in the U.S. thought. Which brings me to the second question: 2) How much did people in the U.S. feel that they faced an existential threat? Note that this is not the same thing as what the threat actually objectively was. I lived through the end of the Cold War (born in the mid-1970s), and I can tell you that most Americans did in fact feel deep unease and fear. More importantly, they felt that the USSR was an equal opponent--a powerful nation that the U.S. did not and could not dominate. Following the end of the Cold War, that feeling went away. Once the USSR dissolved, and Russia went through hard economic times, the self-perception of American citizens was that we were the "last superpower" or "sole superpower"--a nation that could not be seriously threatened by anything on Earth. This self-perception persists today. In fact I think it has become a serious source of angst, as many Americans perceive we are "slipping" because we can't dominate every situation we want to (examples: Syria, Lybia, Ukraine, China). But IMO the reality is that our dominant position has simply been a temporary blip in our long history as one of several equal international powers. [1] http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2013/05/the-ussr-and-us-came-closer-to-nuclear-war-than-we-thought/276290/ http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2013/05/the...
- bsaul 12y agoYeap, although i'm just 35 (which makes me old enough to remember world maps showing "USSR" in school). But i suppose being a european makes it a bit different. We've been hit by terrorism a lot more frequently, and are involved in wars much closer to us than the US. Although to be fair a lot of european would have the same point of view as the typical HN user. Which reminds me of a recent trip i did to Israel. At the airport, some guy complained that people were searching his bag. Saying "why are they doing this, come on...". He seemed pissed. As for me, well I was extremely glad those people searched every single bags coming in the plane. But you're right, that was exactly my point.