10 ms·
The Expanding World of Poverty Capitalism
- brohoolio 12y agoThis seems expensive, inefficient and destined to trap people in a cycle of poverty. I'd rather my taxes cover the true cost of the court system and the courts focus on reforming individuals rather than cost recovery.
- fnimick 12y agoExpensive and inefficient for society, great for those who profit from the poor. Of course they're trying to trap people in a cycle of poverty - what's better than having customers who can't escape?
- tomjen3 12y agoPersonally I would tend to agree with you, except I want the money to be used to discurage crime in the first place - by making it much harder to be a criminal. I don't feel an ounce of pity for those who have to pay for their ancle bracelets. I do agree that you shouldn't go to prison just for not paying your court fees, but if you drive drunk or sell drugs on the street I am not crying for you.
- ctdonath 12y agodestined to trap people in a cycle of poverty. Only if those people persist in committing crimes.
- socialist_coder 12y agoIt doesn't seem like you understand. This privatization is creating a cycle that is contributing to people being repeat offenders. So yes, "only if these people persist in committing crimes", but the government is making it harder on them to get their life back together after committing the 1st crime.
- ctdonath 12y agoThe $free alternative of incarceration remains, independent of whether costly alternatives exist. Alas, human nature is such that making it easy "to get their life back together after committing the 1st crime" decreases the incentive to do so. The main point of sentencing is to discourage recidivism. I'm concerned about a subculture normalizing crimes, 1st or subsequent. Objecting to punishment with zero consideration of the cause thereof facilitates the underlying problem.
- mfringel 12y agoAlas, human nature is such that making it easy "to get their life back together after committing the 1st crime" decreases the incentive to do so. [citation needed]
- ZeroGravitas 12y agoI worry more about subcultures having their normal criminalized e.g. the drugs those people do need to be punished severely. This goes back to prohibition and the Ku Klux Klan supporting it to antagonise Irish Catholics.
- socialist_coder 12y agoThis is already happening with crack vs coke, but I assume you know that =)
- socialist_coder 12y agoIt's not easy to get your life back to together. It's very difficult already. These offenders are punished enough already, society should not be making it more difficult.
- swayvil 12y agoThe key word here is "defenseless". Add "criminal" to that and they lose the protection of society too. There's nothing keeping us from grinding them to pink slime on an optimized exploitation curve. They die at 35.
- williadc 12y agoI'd like to see the data behind this quote: "This new system of offender-funded law enforcement creates a vicious circle: The poorer the defendants are, the longer it will take them to pay off the fines, fees and charges; the more debt they accumulate, the longer they will remain on probation or in jail; and the more likely they are to be unemployable and to become recidivists."
- vinceguidry 12y agoThis state of affairs has been slowly accumulating since the 80s. There probably aren't any rigorous data sets that 'prove' the characterization of that statement, but one young social worker actually went and lived in a poor neighborhood that exhibited this sort of poverty / correctional custody trap, her account is here: http://www.amazon.com/Run-Fugitive-Fieldwork-Encounters-Discoveries-ebook/dp/B00JHCNVNU/ http://www.amazon.com/Run-Fugitive-Fieldwork-Encounters-Disc...
- pessimizer 12y agoThe quote that you've used is a deductive argument. It would be interesting to see if the effects are borne out in the data, but I'd look for a hole in the premises of the actual argument first - if only to see what data may or may not be relevant to its soundness.
- maxerickson 12y agoIt isn't deeply empirical, but this article provides some exposition on it: http://www.npr.org/2014/05/19/312158516/increasing-court-fees-punish-the-poor http://www.npr.org/2014/05/19/312158516/increasing-court-fee...
- wahsd 12y agoI know some will balk out of fear and comfort, but we are approaching a boundary that will force these schemes to expand into the socio-economic strata that you also belong to. Sure it's easy to ignore the brewing storm because it's at the horizon, but what happens when the government and the corrupt officials find that they have sucked the poor and down-trodden dry and their revenue streams are atrophying. Let's see, you speed, well we need to make sure that you are not a serial speeder and need to monitor you for an increasing number of months at a cost of $100 per month for equipment and services. Let's see...what else? You drink.... you've been drunk in public. Well we need to make sure you are not doing illegal things while you are drunk so we need to monitor you for an ever expanding number of months.
- ctdonath 12y agoThe alternative is incarceration; would you rather that be mandatory? Crimes were committed (whether what was committed should be a crime is a different discussion), incarceration is the normal punishment and means of ensuring the crime (nor others) is not repeated within a given period of time. Thanks to technology & private services, we can give the convicted an option which prevents/discourages recidivism within that period, but otherwise lets them largely return to freedom. Being costs above and beyond what the jurisdiction has budgeted (on the represented will of the people), either let the convicted opt for paying for the means for that freedom, or take the free route of being locked in a box for a prolonged period. Sure there are issues subject to objection in this, but remember: the alternative is dump these options and just incarcerate. BTW, PSA: an out-of-state driver in NY caught speeding can be subjected to an additional >$300 "safe driving assurance" (or some rot) fee, paid to ensure said driver is not arrested outright next time discovered (for any reason) driving in the state. No 3rd-party services/mechanisms involved, just straight-up legal extortion which, per the lead article's premise, hits the poor harder than the better-off.
- yasth 12y agoThe issue with shifting to "soft" enforcement is that the softer enforcement allows the punishments to be extended for much longer than a jail sentence. Instead of 3 days for public intox it might be a year of ankle monitoring at $350 a month, and because the city wants the year to look attractive they either take away the incarceration option or increase the sentence. So the very poor get incarcerated for longer, and the less poor end up with a fairly massive chunk out of their income. Also because the city isn't paying they have a lessened interest in reducing the fees. If you look close you can see some hidden pernicious issues with it. Fundamentally it means that the state can be really mean to the poor and not impact the better off. Penalties that one can buy their way out of can even to an extent encourage lawbreaking.
- netcan 12y agoSounds like a good idea.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Bsharp 12y agoThis is all sick in it's own way, but it's not capitalism. Why do people equate every system in which someone makes a profit with capitalism?
- masklinn 12y ago> This is all sick in it's own way, but it's not capitalism. In the same way that the USSR wasn't communism. Does that matter if it's the result when you don't just deal with spherical humans in a vacuum?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- cpr 12y agoIt's the evil twin of capitalism, crony capitalism, which is what we have in this country. (Technically, it should be called fascism, since it's the binding together (fasces) of government and business in an unholy union.)
- boomlinde 12y agoCrony capitalism, corporatism... Call it whatever you want, but it doesn't really exist outside the framework of capitalism. I'll keep looking for the true scotsman just in case I'm wrong, though.
- fennecfoxen 12y agoEh. There's one thing where people are able to purchase, own, and maintain capital, and make money off its output. There's another thing that's about using the coercive force of the state to force people to send you resources that they wouldn't if they were free to do as they pleased. It's meaningful to refer to the former as "capitalism" and call the latter something more like "fascism". It's also quite meaningful to discuss the discuss the manner in which they interact and the impurity of extant capitalist systems. But the big people in charge (or at least with connections) forcing the little people to send them resources? That's a pattern far older than the notion of capital investments, and dates back to our early primate days, before our most basic notions of investing in the future through things like, say, agriculture. So I say it's pretty much orthogonal to capitalism.
- vegancap 12y agoThe very fact this article is talking about government and business in symbiosis means the author doesn't understand the word 'Capitalism'. When big business are in cahoots with government, to good or bad effect (usually bad) it's Corporatism, not Capitalism.
- ThomPete 12y agoI often hear this kind of argumentation and I frankly don't buy it. When businesses are in cahoots with each other it's called cartels. Lets not pretend there is some pure version of capitalism that isn't tied to some special interest.
- eglover 12y agoMixing business with government is government. It takes the power from the customer and puts it into the hands of regulators.
- scarmig 12y agoMixing government with business is business. It takes power from the citizen and puts it into the hands of capital. This is not a disagreement with you, by the way. But just as Rawlsian liberals can't postulate a government that's immune to corruption into existence, libertarians and market fundamentalists can't postulate businesses that don't co-opt government to entrench their market positions.
- sseveran 12y agoThe ability for a business to use the government to its own ends its directly proportional to the size and power of the government. One of the best examples I can think of is Gazprom. While technically a private company its really just an extension of Vladimir Putin's government. In the US you find the similar arrangements in the defense and intelligence sectors. The less powerful the government, the less power there is to be had by co-opting it.
- msluyter 12y agoAlex Tabarrok has been discussing this passionately on the Marginal Revolution blog: http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2014/08/ferguson-and-the-debtors-prison.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2014/08/fer... http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2012/04/debtors-prison-for-failure-to-pay-for-your-own-trial.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2012/04/deb...
- watwut 12y ago"in Washington state, N.P.R. found, offenders even get charged a fee for a jury trial — with a 12-person jury costing $250, twice the fee for a six-person jury." Is that legal/constitutional?
- bostik 12y agoNo idea about legality (not being in or from US I have an excuse for my ignorance); however the idea of charging the defendants for administering justice can be traced back to at least the inquisition. They had a price list for "interrogation" operations, which were payable by the subject being tortu^Winterrogated. Because a good number of their subjects failed to survive the administrations, these costs were often extracted from their family and relatives, retroactively. On the director's commentary track for Brazil, Terry Gilliam notes that the inquisition's practice of charging fees for their (in)justice was one of the major ideas when honing the script and the storyboard.
- zackmorris 12y agoTax the rich.
- innguest 12y agoAnd the right to steal from, or "tax", the rich, comes from where? In other words, I'm curious how you think this is moral.
- gress 12y agoI'm curious how you think it's moral to deny justice to, or steal from the poor.
- innguest 12y agoI don't think those are moral things to do. But if you vote you do, because you are funding a group of people (the government) that does exactly that: denies justice to the poor (e.g. the war on drugs), and steals from them (e.g. the poor have fewer tax-evading strategies at their disposal).
- gress 12y agoThis is obviously false. Voting is a way of interacting with the state. Neither voting nor not-voting implies support for any particular state policy any more than using a state issued currency or holding a passport does.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 12y agoMoney (and property) are social constructs.
- ctdonath 12y agoWe do. Heavily. They pay the bulk of all taxes.
- scarmig 12y ago
- cardamomo 12y agoThis is surprisingly reminiscent of a particular scene from a Terry Gilliam's Brazil: http://youtu.be/nSQ5EsbT4cE http://youtu.be/nSQ5EsbT4cE No doubt other science fiction authors and directors have tacked this topic as well.
- known 12y agoTo Curb Global Poverty Every 3rd World Currency Should Be Pegged To OPEC Oil For 4 Years Till https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triffin_dilemma https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triffin_dilemma Is Resolved.
- snowwrestler 12y agoSeveral comments here are addressing the use of the word "capitalism." It's being used because this op-ed writer knows his audience. Writing on the editorial pages of the Times, he knows he is reaching a primarily liberal audience. He is writing in the context of Democratic political campaigning against big corporations about the financial meltdown, growing income inequality, poor job growth coincident with record corporate profits, and tax shenigans like inversions. In short, he's speaking to an audience that tends to be suspicious of businesses larger than the local grocer, and that has already been whippped up in that direction for several years now. So: he frames his pet issue in those terms, in order to get the maximum response from the audience. (It's also why he name-drops several Republicans, despite the fact that these fees are charged in localities controlled by either party). Seen objectively, the issue is not actually with capitalism, since one of the major examples of fees hitting the poor are municipal court fees--which don't go to private companies at all. They are directly assessed by the local government to pay government expenses. But they're still hurting the poor. NPR had a great story about it recently: http://www.npr.org/2014/05/19/312158516/increasing-court-fees-punish-the-poor http://www.npr.org/2014/05/19/312158516/increasing-court-fee...
- lasermike026 12y agoNo good can come from this.
- grecy 12y agoIt seems more and more every day the government of the United States is not there to serve or help it's citizens - it's purely there to serve and help big business. Sooner or later this has to end. I just hope it's not too violent when it does.
- hgsigala 12y agoWhy does it have to be violent at all? Many people on this site are a fan of Larry Lessig. Check out his alternative to the "violent end" of big business Mayday.us
- grecy 12y agoI don't think it has to be violent, but I think the way things are going it will be. Tens of millions of people are without healthcare, getting their homes taken away and are unable to provide for their families. To put it bluntly, they're desperate. Also, America has a history of violence, an armed populace and a "I'll take what's mine" foundational attitude. Combine desperate people with a history of violence, and you get Ferguson, New Orleans, etc. etc.