6 ms·
The other commenters have listed some advantages, but you really meant to ask whether any of those advantages make this complex writing system "worth it." They
by lern_too_spel 12y ago
The other commenters have listed some advantages, but you really meant to ask whether any of those advantages make this complex writing system "worth it." They don't.
Increasing literacy by slightly modifying the writing system is why the PRC created Simplified Chinese in the first place. Now a more radical simplification of just using Hanyu Pinyin directly and not having a computer transliterate is an obvious next step. Hanyu Pinyin is not intelligible to speakers of non-Mandarin dialects, but this shouldn't be a showstopper for a government that is capable of this: http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guangdong_National_Language_Regulations http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guangdong_National_Language_R....
- thaumasiotes 12y agoMinor point: simplified characters weren't intended to make Chinese easier to read (which is good, since they'd be a miserable failure at that). They were intended to make it easier to write (by hand!) -- the idea was to reduce the number of strokes used to write common characters, and the accompanying propaganda was to the effect that using simplified characters would cut a piece of typical text from so many strokes to so many (less) strokes. Characters were targeted for simplification not based on how ungainly they were but based on a combination of how many strokes they required with how frequently they were used. Then the advent of computers and typing made stroke count mostly irrelevant.
- seszett 12y ago> Increasing literacy by slightly modifying the writing system is why the PRC created Simplified Chinese in the first place While it was an interesting experiment, the fact that Taiwan still has a higher literacy rate than Mainland China, and one comparable to the other developed countries using the latin alphabet, shows that traditional Chinese isn't that much of a hindrance.
- MichaelGG 12y agoHow does that show it? In a developed country, even if literacy is more difficult, we'd expect the education system to have compensated or calibrated for it to achieve an overall good rate. If schoolkids must spend an extra 10% overall time due to increased literacy requirements, that's really but gonna show up on the overall literacy rates, right?
- seszett 12y agoIf that doesn't show up on literacy rates, or GDP, or crime rate or... can you really consider it a hindrance?
- MichaelGG 12y agoSure! For instance, more kids might commit suicide due to increased stress. In response, more people may work harder, and culture might shift to view this as virtuous thing, so those general numbers might still fair alright.
- seanflyon 12y agoIf one factor isn't so terrible that is overcomes all advantages of a wealthy educated society, can you really consider it a hindrance?
- CmonDev 12y agoTaiwan has a much higher rate of english speakers as well. Hence the higher literacy rate.
- seszett 12y agoLiteracy rate has not much to do with English speakers, as speaking English does not help people read and write Chinese.
- bodyfour 12y agoIt is interesting to ponder how much the world would have been different if the PRC had just gone all the way to Pinyin when they decided to simplify the writing system. Also interesting: the linguist who developed Pinyin is apparently still alive at age 108 -- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zhou_Youguang http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zhou_Youguang
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- NaNaN 12y agoI think that radical simplification is just a joke. It is not possible to replace logograms like Chinese completely with phonograms like Hanyu Pinyin or English without considering the grammar and the culture. Chinese has its own flexibility for writing/speaking/thinking.