3 ms·
#1 I care more about the number jobs over time, not the unemployment rate. Absolute numbers vs ratios. #2 I also want to get an idea of how many people are ove
by specialist 12y ago
#1 I care more about the number jobs over time, not the unemployment rate. Absolute numbers vs ratios.
#2 I also want to get an idea of how many people are over employed and under employed.
--
Payroll tax receipts show how many people are employed.
Then do a straight forward head count.
Employment rate = jobs / people.
Then guessimate (tally) the number of hours worked.
Yearly Employment load = hours reported / ( people * 2080 )
Why is this hard?
Why do we need sampling, when we can just measure the totals (with a margin of error)?
Why do we have fudge factors like "discouraged workers"? People are either working or they're not. Student, disabled, retired, whatever, they're still unemployed. When elderly people continue to work past 65 and the working poor have multiple jobs, I'm really not terribly interested in splitting hairs. Break up employment rates by demographic group, if it matters that much.
- clebio 12y agoI always figured that sampling, and electoral voting, are legacy mechanics from when it wasn't as easy to tally large numbers quickly (via technology). Real, per-person voting (there's probably a term for that?) -- and even itemized taxation (e.g. choose schools, sanitation, law enforcement, 'defense', etc.) -- should be entirely within our capabilities now. But, of course, politics is a slow-rolling stone.
- byroot 12y ago> Real, per-person voting (there's probably a term for that?) I suppose you mean direct election[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_election http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_election
- ctdonath 12y agoThere are very good reasons for the "electoral college" outside of "real per-person voting" issues.
- mhurron 12y agoAnd they are? The Electoral College is in place just for Presidential Elections because it used to be that it was impossible for the various candidates to peddle their platform all over the country. No other position had that issue, governors, senators, congressmen are all far more local elections. That issue doesn't exist anymore. There is no reason the president can not be directly elected.
- ctdonath 12y agoThis is the United STATES Of America. The states cast their vote, balancing the equality of states vs population - ensuring both that one large state doesn't get outvoted by a couple much smaller ones, and that one large state doesn't render multiple small ones politically impotent. CA & NY have strong leanings toward urban political interests which conflict with legitimate interests of WY, MT, AK, etc ... but in a direct vote, the former would completely overwhelm the latter rendering their cumulative votes irrelevant. With electoral college, we have a "progressive" vote whereby neither the majority overwhelms the minority, nor the minority have an undue power over the majority - instead, we have a sensible balance. Switch to direct election, and there will be no need for the various candidates to peddle their platform all over the country: candidates will focus on high-density population regions, ignoring "flyover country" entirely and unfairly biasing political power toward urban interests.
- djur 12y agoRepresentative democracy isn't just about the difficulty of arranging a plebiscite for every single decision the legislature would make. At some point, the electorate of a democratic society has to delegate decision-making. Legislatures name committees to originate, review and flesh out bills, and even those bills tend to consist of authorization and funding to hire people to coordinate particular tasks ("bureaucracy"). In the fantasy version of direct democracy, every decision there is to be made is a clear yes or no on an easily defined question ("Do we invade Iraq?"). In such a system, the power would end up belonging to the people who write and pose the questions. Look at the history of the initiative system in the US for an idea of what that looks like even on a limited scale -- the potential for graft, corruption, incompetence, and capture by special interests makes the current system look like rule by benevolent genius saints.
- zhte415 12y ago> Why is this hard? Because these vary. What is employment? Does sitting at home creating an app that could have future rewards employment? Possibly. The labour force varies according to factors including living costs, available prospect of work, potential compensation, and many other factors. For example, a new plant in a town offering part time work could encourage stay at home parents to take a part time job - while not previously unemployed (chose not to participate in employment) they are now employed. Vice versa, for example, a sudden decline in living costs could encourage a fall in workforce participation. Then there is the unreported number of jobs, which tend to be picked up be census rather than tax receipts. People create jobs, jobs don't create people (well, kinda inverse, as better incomes sometimes or often lead to lower birth rates, but that's a tangent). It is not a process of children's puzzles where blocks are put into holes, and after the box is full no more blocks can be inserted. If someone doesn't want to be employed, they're not unemployed, this is a definition of (un)employment, and the distinction is important. When employed but not reporting this through any important means, this is also important. Measuring this is hard.
- TheCoelacanth 12y agoWhat you are describing is "labor participation rate" which is something that the government does track[1]. [1] http://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS11300000 http://data.bls.gov/timeseries/LNS11300000