3 ms·
@jamii > It's not just programming that is hard, it's editing, debugging, compiling, version control, packaging, deploying, upgrading etc. Existing tools give
by the_af 12y ago
@jamii
> It's not just programming that is hard, it's editing, debugging, compiling, version control, packaging, deploying, upgrading etc. Existing tools give you a huge amount of flexibility and power (that most end-user tasks don't need) at the expense of a brutal learning curve.
Sure, I agree all of those steps are painful, and I think everyone here agrees that anything that can improve them is welcome! At the same time, some of them only exist in specific contexts. For example, is the guy writing an Excel macro not bothered about version control because Excel is an easy-to-learn tool that achieves simplicity, or because he isn't building something collaboratively with a team of 5 other people, all working on the same task?
By the way, I read your article. I fully agree with this:
"Finally, environments can't be black boxes. Beginners need a simple experience but if they are to become experts they need to be able to shed the training wheels and open the hood. Many attempts at end-user programming failed because they assumed the user was stupid and so wrapped everything in cotton wool. Whenever we provide a simplified experience, there should be an easy way to crack it open and see how it works."
I'd add that they also need to be able to reach for the complex tools once they've mastered the simpler ones.
- jamii 12y agoI think you misunderstood my point somewhat. I'm not saying that Excel solved the version control problem - far from it. Manual version control by emailing copies of spreadsheets was identified as a major cause of errors in various studies. My point is that for end-user programming to work we need version control, deployment, packaging etc to scale down as well as up. The software industry has a tendency to fetishize scaling up and ignore scaling down. Experienced professional programmers still struggle with git in their day-to-day workflow (http://www.sussex.ac.uk/Users/bend/ppig2014/13Church-Soderberg-Elango-PPIG2014.pdf http://www.sussex.ac.uk/Users/bend/ppig2014/13Church-Soderbe...). The average end-user has no chance. Even if the underlying data model is something like git, the experience for the user needs to be more like undo-tree or etherpad. Excel smooths the learning curve for calculation/simulation - you can get started by just putting in some numbers and learning a few basic functions. If that's all you need, that's all you have to learn. I want to see the same pay-as-you-go approach for all our tools.