4 ms·
I just came from a class today where Stephen Roach (ex chief economist at Morgan Stanley) criticized this same gap between reported and actual unemployment. He
by chatmasta 12y ago
I just came from a class today where Stephen Roach (ex chief economist at Morgan Stanley) criticized this same gap between reported and actual unemployment. He actually focused on a different worrying number: participation rate. The number of people who qualified as "part of the labor force" declined 3 percentage points, in the same period of time that "unemployment" increased by the same amount.
His point was that the way we model economics data will inherently result in missed predictions. We need to remember this fundamental flaw of modeling when we interpret the results of a model, like unemployment rate.
- judk 12y agoWhy is it surprising that participation drops as unemployment grows? x vs 1-x.
- npkarnik 12y agoNo, unemployed people count as participating. Non participating people don't count towards the official unemployment rate. For participation to drop as unemployment grows is the worst possible combination of trends.
- nhaehnle 12y agoConceptually, the working age population is divided into participating and non-participating. The participatings are further divided into working and unemployed (and working-but-looking-for-more-work is a useful category as well). It is indeed unsurprising that participation drops in a period of high unemployment, but it's not just a matter of mathematics. Instead, it's the effect of people simply giving up looking for work. That said, it's important to watch out for what the participation rate is measured against. Obviously, the participation rate of the population as a whole can drop for entirely benign reasons (higher percentage of retirees).