4 ms·
Forgive the long post - I still am missing some clarity. 1. Holier than thou / positive thinking This just irks me : "I breast feed, therefore I am better tha
by lifeisstillgood 12y ago
Forgive the long post - I still am missing some clarity.
1. Holier than thou / positive thinking
This just irks me : "I breast feed, therefore I am better than you" is the short hand I can give. It smacks of the same rather arrogant and unforgiving Oprah-style idea that you can have good things happen to you by positive thinking (as opposed to selection bias) and therefore if bad things happen to you it's your fault for not being positive enough. It is closely linked to the faulty thinking that leads people to turn off their mobile charger before getting on an airplane.
2. Bacteria is not a grey goo
The theory seems to be we have destroyed our bacterial ecosystems and this will have some effect. - it seems a very likely and good theory. Except that instead of making the leap to "1/3 of us have wiped out bacteria X, or bacterial group Y" we leap to "good Bacteria and bad bacteria" and we should somehow replace it with other peoples fecal matter.
I will go with Tokenadult on this - or perhaps one step further. My conjecture is one set of bacteria is responsible for the allegen protection (probably one set per allergen) and that may well have a genetic jigsaw component to match. This is a wildly complicated picture to assemble and will be quite provable. Add in the next most likely cause - some hitherto unnoticed poison we are throwin around like fire retardants, and there is a lot of research to be done.
3. The causes don't seem to match the sufferers
Obese != allergic. Sedentary != allergic. At least use tobacco smoking and lung cancer correlation rates as our gold standard here. Maybe we do (I am lacking the google-fu to find it) but I will be amazed if every obese sedentary Caesarian born anti-biotic taking person is allergic to pollen - in fact I would bet there is a large and worthwhile study to be done for those that aren't.
4. The comparisons are apples to oranges - I think.
I was struck by the 1/3 of us westerners and 1/1500 of those hunter gathers statistic. That's an enormous gulf - how did they test these hunter gathers for asthma? Did they ask their GPs? Apart from glimmers of point number 1 (noble savages) I am amazed at the vast spread there. As those people and their children start to get eaten By the modern world perhaps we could take samples ...
But overall I worry that we blame our "lifestyle" as if we forgot to unplug the mobile charger, and use it as a chance to demonise those who do not meet our cultural standards, and idolise those who would rather swap asthma for our maternity care.