2 ms·
To be honest I think I don't understand how ethics work, at all. What else can there be than the "law of the stronger"? If somebody points a gun at you and want
by Tichy 17y ago
To be honest I think I don't understand how ethics work, at all. What else can there be than the "law of the stronger"? If somebody points a gun at you and wants to steal your car, is there any hope of convincing him through some universal ethical argument that he shouldn't do it?
What I can understand is societies creating rules for living together. But all these rules have targets that the individuals decided on beforehand. I don't think anything universal enters it. The best hope for arriving at acceptable ethics is to try to understand the consequences of their application, so that individuals can decide if they like the consequences or not.
The only way to compute something comparable to universal ethics then would be evolution in the form of competition among societies and their rules. I understand that one set of ethics might make the society employing it more successful than another one. Even that does not allow for the creation of universal rules, though: the individuals would still have to agree that survival of a particular society is desirable.
- astine 17y agoYou're assuming that ethics is the search for universal moral principles. That's not ethics, it's moral philosophy. Ethics is the search for 'right human action'. That is, the search for principles on how to live. You're right that for moral principles to be meaningful they require some kind of universal law-giver (nature is one kind of law-giver, but not one we would expect.) If you assume a physicalist universe the best you can hope for in moral philosophy is a law of the stronger, or a more egalitarian notion that what is good for my neighbor is ultimately good for me (something that Plato believed for example,) but this has nothing to with the validity of ethics. If you read Aristotle's ethics, you'll find that he doesn't assume a universal moral code in the same way as our post-Christian culture is inclined.