3 ms·
Ditto with audio APIs -- the last major change was the changeover from OSS to ALSA, in 2002, and to this day there's an OSS compatibility layer. ALSA, as an AP
by SwellJoe 17y ago
Ditto with audio APIs -- the last major change was the changeover from OSS to ALSA, in 2002, and to this day there's an OSS compatibility layer.
ALSA, as an API for building modern audio applications, is useless. Yes, literally, useless.
I have tried for over ten years to move my home studio recording to Linux-based tools...but, to this day, reliable, glitch-free, low-latency, multi-track 24 bit 96kHz audio from multiple applications and external sources is simply not possible under Linux (without dedicating a machine to the task, which I've never been willing to do, and which I don't have to do under Windows or Mac OS X).
First up, audio requires an rt kernel. The rt kernels trail behind the mainline kernel by several revisions, and usually include a few major security or stability issues. The latency of a non-rt kernel is such that even with extremely large buffers, audio still stutters.
You also need a sound server to permit multiple apps to share and route sound amongst other apps. The competing and barely compatible sound servers for Linux are targeted to different audiences, and generally don't do a very good job even for their specific niche. JACK is the professionals choice, but in my experience, it's never been stable enough to be usable for any real work. PulseAudio is laughably unreliable...it consistently fails when returning from sleep on my desktop, and makes weird popping noises after playing sounds on my laptop. It never worked at all on my mid-range audio devices (Delta 66 on the desktop and FireWire Focusrite Saffire LE on the lappy), as it seems to just freak out when there are multiple devices (to be fair, Vista also freaks out a bit when changing sound devices and using both for various tasks; I've been able to find a delicate balance that allows Flash and movies and such to play through the built-in audio and audio software to use the good devices).
Anyway, I use, and have used, Linux as my primary operating system for all of my machines for over ten years for everything except audio. I try to make the switch at least once a year, and I've failed every single time because of failures of both the kernel and the audio APIs on Linux. I'm not a neophyte at this stuff, either. I've written and maintained patches for the Linux kernel over the years, I'm not nervous about any of the required steps to make things work, it's just that when all is said and done, the system is either not capable of working with high quality audio at all (non-rt kernel, normal desktop PulseAudio configuration), but usable as a desktop system for normal work...or it's configured exactly right for pro audio (rt kernel, jackd, etc.), and sort of works for a few minutes or hours at a time, but is otherwise useless as a desktop system because 3D video drivers are too flaky in this configuration, kernel has stability or security issues, and normal software (like Firefox+Flash) can't talk to the jackd server and can't get access to the audio device because jack is holding it.
Music software that does happen to support Linux (Renoise, for an example of one of my favorite tools), there is confusion among the developers about what they should be doing to provide good support to Linux users...which of the several sound servers is the "right" one? It depends on who you ask.
So, while I spend 90% of my day running Linux, when I want to record music, I have to reboot into Windows.