2 ms·
Would it be reasonable to charge women more, an ethnical minority, or people with blonde hair? No, of course it wouldn't. That's why. Being born tall is out of
by Someone1234 12y ago
Would it be reasonable to charge women more, an ethnical minority, or people with blonde hair? No, of course it wouldn't. That's why.
Being born tall is out of a person's control. It isn't a choice. Why should they pay 50% more as a result?
If you (or anyone else) thinks it is different from the other "out of your control" categories I listed then explain /why/ that is the case. Because from my perspective charging tall people more and charging e.g. women more aren't different at all and both equally unreasonable.
- mikeash 12y agoHere's a direct quote from your previous comment: 'Alternatively just offer a new seat class for taller people. If you're over 6' then you can sit in an economy seat with 3" more pitch for $100 more. No extra "free" baggage, no better food, no express security line, just those 3" and nothing else.' Literally 45 minutes ago you were apparently just fine with paying extra for more room. But now that you've discovered you can have that, it's no longer good enough. Wat.
- Someone1234 12y agoI am never fine with paying more, ever. But $100 or similar more is reasonable, 50% more is not. You're pointing at existing services which cost 50-3000% more and claiming "problem solved already." Wat? Nobody should be paying 0c more just due to the way they were born. But if there MUST be a charge (e.g. due to actual increased costs) then it should be somewhere within the region of $100-200, not $350-700 more.
- mikeash 12y agoThat's really confusing. You compare it to racial and sexual discrimination, but then say that $100-200 more would be OK. You seem to switch between making a principled stand and trying to save money, depending on whatever's more convenient at the time. Which makes the "principled stand" sound like a crock. So let's concentrate on the price. First of all, how do you decide that $200 is OK but $350 is not OK? The airline industry is pretty competitive. If one doesn't offer what you want, use one that does. If none of them offer what you want, it's probably because it's not actually cost effective (assuming that it's legal). Secondly, you're just wrong about the cost. I picked a United roundtrip between IAD and SFO, and they want a whopping $84 for Economy Plus on the outbound leg, and $79 on the return leg, on top of a $414 base roundtrip fare. That's $174 extra for the roundtrip, within the range you state as acceptable. For another example, I flew IAD-PEK on United earlier this year, and it was $200 each way for Economy plus, on a $1,400/person trip that takes 14 hours each way. I checked on American and for a similar trip they wanted $50-60 per flight for "Main Cabin Extra" which is their equivalent. Finally, I checked JetBlue, which cost a total of $115 extra each way for "Even More Space". Now, one might expect you to delighted at this, since apparently you didn't know before, and it's exactly what you asked for. Somehow, I don't think that's going to happen, though.
- Someone1234 12y agoIt isn't confusing at all. When the reason to charge more is material cost (i.e. increased fuel cost) some charge can be justified even if it remains discriminatory in nature (see mens Vs. womens' health insurance for one example). > First of all, how do you decide that $200 is OK but $350 is not OK? That is easy, look at a normal ticket, figure out how much you're paying per inch and then calculate how much they should be charging for ADDITIONAL inches based on that figure (even ignoring the savings presented by taking less passengers (less luggage, less admin, etc)). They're charging too much. > The airline industry is pretty competitive. If one doesn't offer what you want, use one that does. None of them do. They're competing for 90% of the audience who aren't tall, nobody wants a niche in that 10% of the market. So they sell a "premium" product to people who want, don't need, it. So they charge a premium price. > Secondly, you're just wrong about the cost. I picked a United roundtrip between IAD and SFO, and they want a whopping $84 for Economy Plus on the outbound leg, and $79 on the return leg, on top of a $414 base roundtrip fare. That's $174 extra for the roundtrip, within the range you state as acceptable. That's a 50% increase which I stated was unacceptable. Let's ignore fixed figures and say 50% is too much, period. That is too much and that is my point. > For another example, I flew IAD-PEK on United earlier this year, and it was $200 each way for Economy plus, on a $1,400/person trip that takes 14 hours each way. That's a very interesting way of wording things. You use three techniques there to mislead, first you conflate single trip with round trip costs, secondly you are vague about if the $1,400 is the relative cost (of a normal economy ticket) or the new cost after you added in the Plus, and lastly you use a personal anecdote nobody can possibly verify. So I won't respond to that. No way I can argue with vague "facts" and unverifiable anecdotes anyway. Plus looking at the cost of flights your figures all seem inaccurate. > Now, one might expect you to delighted at this, since apparently you didn't know before, and it's exactly what you asked for. Somehow, I don't think that's going to happen, though. As you didn't state the cost of the economy tickets along with the cost of the "upgrades" those figures are utterly meaningless as you well knew before you posted them. You likely went and found the shortest cheapest flights you could, then noted the upgrade cost (e.g. $50 on a $100 flight) and used that as "proof" that upgrades are inexpensive. But relative to the base ticket they're not and that's the only thing that matters. 50% is 50% is 50%. You can find a $100 ticket or a $5,000 ticket, if the cost is 50% more for the legroom (while offering less than 50% more space) then they're over charging people who were born a certain way. This is the last time I'll reply to you as some fact checking in the above post as made me deeply distrustful of you and your motives. Frankly I don't want to have a conversation with someone who will be intentionally misleading in this way.