3 ms·
I've noticed that the divide in the "recline debate" seems to fall based on a person's leg length. I try to avoid booking economy whenever possible (it isn't a
by Someone1234 12y ago
I've noticed that the divide in the "recline debate" seems to fall based on a person's leg length.
I try to avoid booking economy whenever possible (it isn't always possible) at great expense, and that's fine. But the few times I do have to sit in economy someone in front will recline onto my knees and then as the aircraft moves I have this person's body weight literally bouncing up and down on my knees for a 2-9 hr flight.
I literally have to take strong painkillers to sit in economy and even that doesn't really work. My knees feel like someone has stood on them for several days after also.
So for me what this "debate" becomes is: "one person's comfort Vs. another person's pain and potential long term health issues."
But ultimately I don't blame these "pro recline" people, I just think they're inconsiderate jerks, the people who I really blame for all of this is the airlines and the complete lack of rational legislation.
Once one airline reduces seat space (e.g. -1 inch) and gets an extra row of seats, now all of the other airlines have to follow suit or they'll be "charging more for the same service."
What we need is for government (e.g. EU, US, etc) to sit down and come up with rational minimums based on different flight durations. 2-3 hour flights can have X seat pitch, 3-5 have y, and 5+ need Z.
Alternatively just offer a new seat class for taller people. If you're over 6' then you can sit in an economy seat with 3" more pitch for $100 more. No extra "free" baggage, no better food, no express security line, just those 3" and nothing else.
On a related note: Aircraft seat design sucks. I read once that only a single company makes aircraft seats and that they basically haven't changed the design in 30 years (due to certification or some nonsense), this just boggles my mind and annoys me endlessly.
- eurleif 12y ago>Alternatively just offer a new seat class for taller people. If you're over 6' then you can sit in an economy seat with 3" more pitch for $100 more. No extra "free" baggage, no better food, no express security line, just those 3" and nothing else. Aren't you describing United's Economy Plus seats, and other airlines' equivalents?
- Someone1234 12y agoNo, I am not. I don't fly United as they're terrible but every other airline I've flown on offer more than just legroom in Economy Plus/Comfort/Premium Economy. For example Delta: Priority boarding, free alcohol, better snacks, sleep kit. British Airways: Better food, larger drinks menu, more "free" baggage, power plugs Virgin Atlantic: Dedicated check in desk, priority boarding, free newspaper/drinks, amenity kit, additional "free" bag And so on. Most come with additional perks. Plus the cost is quite a bit more. A £730 return flight is £1100 on Premium Economy, 50% more expensive! Just for leg room. That's a lot of money.
- bjterry 12y agoUnbundling the value of the leg room and the value of the perks would reveal that people pay essentially nothing for those extra perks. It's not like if they had a "leg" package and a "better food, priority boarding, etc." package, that the latter would be 50% of the premium and the former 50% of the premium, probably more like 90/10 (and notably, all of those other things cost essentially nothing for the airline to provide). They offer those perks as an enticement so travelers will feel like they are getting more stuff. Of course, you aren't even really paying for just more legroom. It's also used as price discrimination since invariably the Economy Plus seats are the last seats booked. So you are really paying for a combination of legroom and the flexibility to purchase your flight closer to the departure date. I don't even have an estimate on what would be the split if you could unbundle this fact, but eyeballing some flights in the next couple days between SFO and London or SFO and New York, all the economy seats on United are full but there are still 7-10 seats available in Economy Plus.
- mikeash 12y agoEvery airline I've flown with in the past few years has offered more room in exchange for more money, even ignoring first/business class. At the very least, you can pay extra for an exit row seat. Many also have a separate economy section with a bit more room. The solution is available right now, and you apparently just don't want to pay for it. Why is government intervention required?
- Someone1234 12y agoWould it be reasonable to charge women more, an ethnical minority, or people with blonde hair? No, of course it wouldn't. That's why. Being born tall is out of a person's control. It isn't a choice. Why should they pay 50% more as a result? If you (or anyone else) thinks it is different from the other "out of your control" categories I listed then explain /why/ that is the case. Because from my perspective charging tall people more and charging e.g. women more aren't different at all and both equally unreasonable.
- mikeash 12y agoHere's a direct quote from your previous comment: 'Alternatively just offer a new seat class for taller people. If you're over 6' then you can sit in an economy seat with 3" more pitch for $100 more. No extra "free" baggage, no better food, no express security line, just those 3" and nothing else.' Literally 45 minutes ago you were apparently just fine with paying extra for more room. But now that you've discovered you can have that, it's no longer good enough. Wat.
- Someone1234 12y agoI am never fine with paying more, ever. But $100 or similar more is reasonable, 50% more is not. You're pointing at existing services which cost 50-3000% more and claiming "problem solved already." Wat? Nobody should be paying 0c more just due to the way they were born. But if there MUST be a charge (e.g. due to actual increased costs) then it should be somewhere within the region of $100-200, not $350-700 more.