3 ms·
Just a counter-point to your no health insurance view. I opted for health insurance while I was a healthy early 20s guy in grad school. $110/month, and 2 months
by Jtsummers 12y ago
Just a counter-point to your no health insurance view. I opted for health insurance while I was a healthy early 20s guy in grad school. $110/month, and 2 months later I needed my gallbladder removed. The surgery would've cost me $15k out of pocket. So with my premiums and copays I ended up paying a total of $2k for the surgery (effectively) and saved about $13k. At that age and employment status (stipend and free school with a research assistant position, but that wasn't much) I would've been fucked. As it was I lost nearly a month of academic progress that I had to make up because of the excruciating pain and isnomnia it induced. As a healthy 20-something male, the savings covered my insurance premiums through the rest of my 20s. And in that time I had other injuries [1] whose treatments (surgery or PT), again, dwarfed the cost of the insurance I continue to carry.
[1] I've had 2 infections since I was 14: food poisoning and an ear infection, every medical thing I've needed is the result of injury or organs gone mad. You just can't predict these things, a good immune system does not prevent you from needing medical care.
- jacquesm 12y agoI paid cash to have my gall bladder removed. It as 1500 Euros. I really don't know why the same procedure would cost 10x as much where you live (assuming a simplistic conversion rate, which is not correct, so maybe 8x) compared to where I live. And nowadays that's not even an option any more because we all have mandatory health insurance with deductibles that are mostly designed to keep you paying for everything unless something major happens.
- Jtsummers 12y agoThis was in the US. It's not cheap here for medical care, and there's really nothing that we get that's an improvement to justify the costs compared to the EU or Canada or, really, most other developed countries. Also, this was 8 years ago. The numbers stuck with me because I was trying to explain why, a couple years later, I was paying out of pocket from my (at the time) meager salary for health insurance to my coworkers. They had grecy's attitude. And then one of the idiots broke his ankle jumping down some stairs. His parents bailed him out financially for that cost, which was small in comparison, and he failed to learn the lesson: Debt for unexpected medical costs is not worth the short term savings of skippig health insurance (in the US).
- jacquesm 12y agoThe reason I paid cash was very simple: because of a nasty little slip-up during my immigration into Canada I ended up un-insured (you have three months to apply for OHIP but being in the heat of a launching start-up I totally missed out of it). Many years later, on a short trip to NL I got hit with the gall bladder issue and I was rather pleasantly surprised that it was as cheap as it was.
- Jtsummers 12y agoAn infographic [1] comparing the cost across states. Those high cost ones seem absurd to me. But I've read my EOBs on every surgery I've had. One hospital charged something like $200-300 for the stitches (maybe 20 stitches used) . Not stitching, the stitches. The personnel costs were listed separately. US medical costs are broken. [1] http://www.bernardhealth.com/woofstreetjournal/bid/197140/Gallbladder-removal-How-much-does-it-cost http://www.bernardhealth.com/woofstreetjournal/bid/197140/Ga...
- jacquesm 12y agoThat's a terrible situation. Thanks for that graph, I had no idea it was this bad.