2 ms·
His attitude seems to be more "slow CS down" than "speed Stats up". He talks about "let's consider the problems in CS first", but then never gets around to seri
by moron4hire 12y ago
His attitude seems to be more "slow CS down" than "speed Stats up". He talks about "let's consider the problems in CS first", but then never gets around to seriously discussing the problems of the Stats profession.
The most he seems to admit to is "Stats hasn't been awake, hasn't been present", like it's some kind of defendable excuse. It's a major problem! If you don't show up to the game, you can't say anything about the "competition" playing unfairly or not playing by the right rules or what have you.
We've seen this before in all kinds of discussions. "Them damn kids and their Rubython on Djrails think they invented everything." It paints a picture of some new, young beast hunting down and devouring the old guard bit by bit in some kind of cruel game designed to torture body and mind. Which is completely ridiculous. The new gang never "attacks" the old. They just walk away.
For all sets of tools, the reason people prefer one over another is because they are finding answers quicker and more easily with A rather than B. Nobody cares about the purity of form (or in other words, the ones who do care are statistically insignificant). They care about getting work done.
None of this is to say that working on theory is inferior or superior to working on applied use and engineering. They are all equally valid pursuits. But we all need to be able to admit when people don't share our passions, and not blame them for having their own.
Show up to the game. The game is industry. It's work. Stop focusing on academia as the only legitimate outlet for graduating mathematicians and statisticians. Talking about "adult supervision" is really just armchair quarterbacking. Sit in a meeting with a person with a 30-year-old, unused history degree with absolutely zero understanding of statistics--thinks ALL math is ivory tower bullshit not worth the paper the textbooks are printed on--and explain to him why his desired results can't be obtained from his current data. See how much your statistical models stand up to "let's turn that can't into a can" or "can't is unacceptable, we're not going to leave here until we figure it out".