3 ms·
That's a bad analogy. For years medallions were owned to be flipped and sold at a higher price. Owning a taxi medallion is like owning a McDonald's franchise
by dnautics 12y ago
That's a bad analogy. For years medallions were owned to be flipped and sold at a higher price. Owning a taxi medallion is like owning a McDonald's franchise in the middle of a city where property values have skyrocketed to the tune of 20% per annum for the past decade.
- rayiner 12y agoYou mean like any boomer who bought a house in NYC or SF or DC in the 1980's? The point is that taxi medallion owners aren't Goldman Sachs-esque financial fatcats. That's an absurd part of the Uber versus taxi cab narrative.
- dnautics 12y agothey don't have goldman-sachs-esque assets, but they have experienced goldman-sachs-esque asset growth, and they have done it in large part colluding with the government. (http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/06/02/government-sachs-goldmans_n_210561.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/06/02/government-sachs-go...) Anyways those boomers are annoying (my father is one); explaining to him how he got incredibly lucky is like bashing my head against a wall, especially contrasting with my own personal, relative financial failure.
- rayiner 12y agoThey didn't "collude" with the government. The whole premise of taxi medallions was to limit supply to maintain taxi driver wages and limit oversupply of cabs in a crowded city. Indeed, the number of cab medallions issued has outpaced population growth in NYC over the last several decades. As for "Goldman Sachs-esque" returns, the price of a taxi medallion increased from about $100k in 1985 to $250k in 2005. Less than the return most Americans got on their house over that time. There was a major spike in the last decade, but it doesn't seem to be correlated with any real change in demand for cabs, or any specific regulatory action. As far as I can tell, the spike in price is just the result of the general attractiveness of safe but low-yield investments in this poor economy. In any case, these are $1 million investments that net maybe $50-75k per year, and are appreciating quickly but not more so than say real estate in SF or NYC. The owners of these medallions aren't big money players. The investors behind Uber are.