2 ms·
Offhand remark regarding the title: everyone can recognize the brilliance of a 5 year old doing calculus, because it's still sort of in the realm of something p
by davidw 12y ago
Offhand remark regarding the title: everyone can recognize the brilliance of a 5 year old doing calculus, because it's still sort of in the realm of something people may have encountered, and can compare to their own experience. Compare with someone who is, say, 30, and doing some topological quantum lattice tensor dilithium crystal quark extractor thing, it's just "blub" - it's so far beyond most of us we can't tell much more than that person is quite smart at something we know nothing about.
- VLM 12y agoI would agree with and extend your remarks that it takes a certain level of competence in a field to correctly evaluate someone at a higher level in the field, and as the level of the evaluated person increases, the required level of the evaluator increases. Someone with a BS in physics level of knowledge or maybe grad degree can possibly evaluate Feynman vs Einstein as per the debate in the comments today. However, I suspect most people can't do a useful evaluation of those two. There are obvious HN on topic analogies with coding, system design, database design, network design.