4 ms·
The percentage of government controlled TLDs is rapidly declining though. And making the CA an integral and evident part of the domain and url is a vast improve
by fulafel 12y ago
The percentage of government controlled TLDs is rapidly declining though. And making the CA an integral and evident part of the domain and url is a vast improvement to the current state of affairs.
Is the USA-controlled DNS root a problem here? Hopefully interference would require highly visible and suspicious changes to the DNS root.
- tptacek 12y agoI do not understand your first paragraph. If the last 5 years have demonstrated anything, it's that the US DOJ more or less controls the 3 most popular TLDs. I am not seeing the same decline in government control you do. Please be more specific? Also: I have a really hard time seeing how baking a CA into the fabric of the Internet is a vast improvement over the current situation we have now, in which we are continually tormented by our reliance on CAs.
- fulafel 12y agoI meant what I said: there are 700+ TLDs listed at https://www.iana.org/domains/root/db https://www.iana.org/domains/root/db and the percentage controlled by governments is declining - currently 297 country-code TLDs and a handful of other state controlled domains (including .com). ICANN has been giving out new top-level domains pretty generously and the vast majority of the new ones are non-state domains. Hence, the percentage of state/government controlled TLDs is declining. No matter what the PKI system is, there will be more and less trustworthy actors around. I agree that many state controlled TLDs are currently quite popular, but I don't see them as generally less trustworthy than the commercially operated TLDs. Both groups will contain some iffy elements, but I don't know if there's any way to build a system where iffy actors can't play. At least they can only mangle their own domains with DANE. And sounds like DNSSEC should be quite a bit more tamper-evident than our current CA sysetm.