8 ms·
Unfortunately that is far too simplistic. For example eating meat: if you don't eat meat because you love cows, becoming a vegetarian might actually hurt cows.
by Tichy 17y ago
Unfortunately that is far too simplistic.
For example eating meat: if you don't eat meat because you love cows, becoming a vegetarian might actually hurt cows. If people weren't eating meat, there would certainly be a lot less cows around than are now.
I am all in favor of feeding all hungry people, but once again it is not so simple (note: not trying to pass off hardcore opinions, just thinking and playing devil's advocate). The problem are always the incentives. If you know your children will always be fed, maybe you'll worry less about having kids - you'll just have them. Eventually because of overpopulation it might become impossible to feed everyone. If people worry about having to feed their kids, maybe on average they'll only have kids when they know they can be fed. (I don't know a good solution to this).
It get's really bad when he claims that "people who don't want what they should want are usually just deluded".
The incentive problem goes further - if people are only allowed to get "equal" things, competition is eliminated, and hence also progress. In former eastern Germany, there was only one kind of car, made from plastic. It is a bit like with the cows - you think you are helping everybody, but suddenly people are forced to drive in shoddy vehicles endangering their health.
As I said, it is a dilemma, I don't know the answer. But I suspect that ultimately there will always have to be some competition and struggle. Unfortunately.
- hvs 17y agoAgreed. Ethics has been challenging human civilization as long as we can tell and we still don't have any answers (and there probably aren't any). The only people I worry about ethically (besides psychopaths) are those that think they have all the answers. Whether they are religious fundamentalists, political fundamentalists (Communists, fascists, etc), or what have you. I only know one thing: once you think you have ethics figured out for sure, you're wrong.
- astine 17y agoonce you think you have ethics figured out for sure, you're wrong. Well then, it seams like we should stop trying. :)
- hvs 17y agoNo, simply that if you approach ethics from the standpoint of trying to find the "ultimate truth," you are doing it wrong. If you approach it from the view that ethical dilemmas don't have one right answer and that human society is inherently "fuzzy," real progress can be made.
- astine 17y agoIf you are trying to find 'ultimate truth' in ethics you misunderstand the field. (You might like teleology.) My point isn't to say that there is no right answer but that if you can never get to the point where you can definitively say that this one is right, or at least more right than the alternative, then you are wasting your time. I have no patience for moral relativists that dabble in ethics. If you approach the problem from the standpoint that there is no right and wrong answer, then there is no progress to be made. Ethics is a difficult subject as it deals with the entire scope of human action. It ranges from emotional and intellual states, to changing subjective circumstances, to general (dare I say "universal") principles. Wether I should kill one man to save many depends on more than wieght of the collective needs of individuals. Do I have the right to kill even for a good cause? Does it matter if the man to be killed is at fault for the predicament of the many? Is allowing someone to die morally equivallent to actively killing them? These are hard questions, and and I can't answer all of them, but they do have answers. Moral questions aren't 'fuzzy,' they're subtle, and their applications are even subtler. This means that we have to work hard for answers, and sometimes we may have to settle with that we don't always know. But when people take the genuine difficulty of finding good answers as evidence that there are no answers, and present this as wisdom they are wasting everyone's time. I am not sayting that anyone here is guilty of this; I am just expressing a pet pieve of mine. edit: spelling & grammer
- hvs 17y ago"More right than the alternative" is much different than "this is the right answer." It gets to the crux of "ultimate truth." I am not a moral relativist by any stretch of the imagination, but even working within a moral and ethical framework, very few -- if any -- problems have a right answer. The reason we are even still discussing these issues thousands of years after they were first raised, is because there is no right answer. Only better answers than others.
- aaronsw 17y agoHow does having less cows being born hurt actual cows? It might "hurt" the cow species, but that's a metaphorical point -- surely you don't consider the cow species actually capable of pain. The evidence (look up "demographic transition") shows that the only reliable way to decrease birth rates is to decrease death rates. In practice, people seem to have more kids when they expect some of their kids to die. That's how societies keep from dying out. I don't say people are just deluded, I say they're often confused. I never said people are only allowed to get equal things, so I have no idea what you're talking about. Nobody disputes that things are sometimes complicated. But that just means you need to work a little harder to find out the truth -- not just spout random ideas you have.
- Tichy 17y agoHurting cows - I just wanted to point out that if you love having cows around, you might be in for a surprise. Without a judgment, just that it might be an unexpected consequence - just as a lot of other actions that seem ethical might actually backfire. "The evidence (look up "demographic transition") shows that the only reliable way to decrease birth rates is to decrease death rates." I don't know about that, but I know that in my country (which has a very good welfare system) there is a lot of discussion about the poor and uneducated having more kids than other parts or society. And their kids tend to go the same route, that is, they tend to end up on welfare. That might be sensationalist reporting of our newspapers, though. Also not saying that the solution would be to "curb" the birth rates - you might find a twist to make the kids fare better than their parents or whatever. I don't know - but it makes me wary about incentives and treating everybody equally. People are not equal - I wish for everybody to have a good live and a fair chance (and that includes if you are born dumb - which might mean you can't take advantage of chances, and it is not your fault - but then what if suddenly a lot of people are dumb - a ka idiocracy?). Also, about the demographic curve - how come human history is a history of war, struggle and genocide? So people had kids because they were afraid their kids might die, but then they didn't die so they had to exterminate their neighbors to get more room to live? From my experience, not everybody is friends with everybody. I trust your friends from MIT would feed me if I ended up under a bridge, even if in my previous life I had been a drug dealer? "I don't say people are just deluded, I say they're often confused." Sure, but how can you make sure that you are right? The cookies example seems like a no-brainer, but maybe it isn't. Maybe the world would be a worse place without cookies. "not just spout random ideas you have." That sounds as if you are entitled to an opinion and I am not. Why - because you read more books on the subject than I did? For what it's worth, I suspect trying to create value is probably the best way to make the world a better place. If there is enough food, people don't need to fight over it. Thanks to technology, normal people can live today as kings used to live in former times. So it seems to me advancing technology helps the most.
- cturner 17y agoFor example eating meat: if you don't eat meat because you love cows, becoming a vegetarian might actually hurt cows. If people weren't eating meat, there would certainly be a lot less cows around than are now. I like books covered in human skin. The best skin comes from babies. This is OK, because if I wasn't supporting the market for baby skin then there would be less babies around than there are now. Phew. Think of all the good work my passion for skin-covered books is doing. I like to start with the rotary mechanism for evaluating the ethics of an action: - Is it based on the truth? - Is it fair? - Will it build goodwill and better relationships? - Will it be beneficial to all concerned? It's not perfect. It tends to give priority to the people in your immediate vicinity over people who are remote. Also, people need to accept responsibility for their actions in some cases, and it's unrealistic to expect that the rest of the world will invest in mind games to overcome your folly. But I like to use that as my starting point.
- Tichy 17y ago"This is OK, because if I wasn't supporting the market for baby skin then there would be less babies around than there are now." Uhm - no it isn't OK. "Is it fair?" What is fair? "Will it be beneficial to all concerned?" How many actions have that property at all?
- cturner 17y agoWhat is fair? It's a good question. Two months ago I would have said it was completely aribtrary. However, a sense of fairness is wired into humans, so it's a factor we need to consider even though for rational purposes it appears ridiculous. This is the book I've been reading to give me perspectiev on this, _Animal Spirits_ (http://www.amazon.com/Animal-Spirits-Psychology-Economy-Capitalism/dp/0691142335 http://www.amazon.com/Animal-Spirits-Psychology-Economy-Capi...).
- Tichy 17y agoInteresting book, thanks.