10 ms·
Late Bloomers: Why do we equate genius with precocity? (2008)
- dominotw 12y agoolder ppl can be genius too. Is that the tldr?
- moultano 12y agoIf you find yourself wanting tldrs, maybe this isn't the site for you.
- jessriedel 12y agoThat's completely mistaken. Everyone has finite time, and we need a way to find out what's worth reading. HackerNews and the Internet in general is filled with unnecessarily bloated articles. Folks have been using tldr's in the academic sphere for centuries; they're called 'abstracts'.
- panzagl 12y agoRight, so you need a site that provides tldrs, whereas HN was built for discussion of the finer points of a topic. Neither desire is wrong, but you can't criticize the New Yorker for not being Reader's Digest.
- possibilistic 12y agoI have pretty extreme ADD, even on medication, and I could never hope to finish an article like this. I can never leisurely read; I have to skim. "tl;dr"s and commentary are what I thrive on, and ultimately how I derive a large percentage of my present context. I'm not saying that I can't get deep into technical specs or literature, but when it comes to a form that is largely prose... forget about it. Breadth-first search takes over.
- DennisP 12y agoMore that late bloomers are a different kind of genius, that takes time and experimentation to develop.
- Mz 12y agoExcerpt: Genius, in the popular conception, is inextricably tied up with precocity—doing something truly creative, we’re inclined to think, requires the freshness and exuberance and energy of youth. It is also tied up with the idea that "geniuses" are fast. It was nice to see profiles of Maryam Mirzakhani indicate that she was a deep thinker, not a fast thinker. Maybe we can start changing some of these popular mis-conceptions.
- wellpast 12y agoEinstein fit that bill, as well. Scientists that worked with him noted he was neither a fast thinker nor the best of mathematicians.
- dominotw 12y ago> Scientists that worked with him noted he was neither a fast thinker nor the best of mathematicians. I thought this was mostly a myth. Do you have source for that?
- Scuds 12y agoI definitely remember seeing that in one of Feynman's autobiographies like 'Surely You're Joking Mr. Feynman' Einstein to Feynman: "Please explain things slowly"
- baddox 12y agoFeynman seemed like a particularly quick thinker. I suspect a fair number of "geniuses" would need him to slow down.
- auxbuss 12y agoIt's interesting to compare the two approaches (and characters) of Feynman and his close colleague (with whom he shared the Nobel), Julian Schwinger. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julian_Schwinger#Schwinger_and_Feynman https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julian_Schwinger#Schwinger_and... You could call Schwinger "slow", but he "saw" very deeply. After all, he found and corrected problems with the Dirac equation.
- imjk 12y agoI read this years ago and thought he had a great premise for a book. I guess it kinda ties into Gladwell's Outliers and David and Goliath, but I still hope he writes more on this topic in the future.
- simulate 12y agoIn another New Yorker piece, Steven Milhauser explores aged genius in his short story, "In the Reign of Harad IV" Excert: he understood that he had travelled a long way from the early days, that he still had far to go, and that, from now on, his life would be difficult and without forgiveness. Link: http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2006/04/10/in-the-reign-of-harad-iv http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2006/04/10/in-the-reign-of...
- jgill 12y agoThis is a really good link to share. Thanks, I also ordered Thinking, Fast and Slow the book because of this posting and the comments. This thread has been pretty interesting to me even from an "at speed of thought" perspective. Certainly in lower levels of education, "fast" thinking against known problems and problemsets is the norm (at least in the United States). I worked with a few "fast" thinkers that fell into a strange, at the time to me, category of people that I could recognize as intelligent and could solve a certain class of issue or problem easily, but when it came to a more difficult problem space or perhaps one that requires delayed gratification (or no real external recognition/validation/praise) they would give up. The "deep" thinkers seemed to give equal or near equal weight to the validity of options in many cases. There's a time, place, and type of problem that can benefit from each mode of thinking.
- davidw 12y agoOffhand remark regarding the title: everyone can recognize the brilliance of a 5 year old doing calculus, because it's still sort of in the realm of something people may have encountered, and can compare to their own experience. Compare with someone who is, say, 30, and doing some topological quantum lattice tensor dilithium crystal quark extractor thing, it's just "blub" - it's so far beyond most of us we can't tell much more than that person is quite smart at something we know nothing about.
- VLM 12y agoI would agree with and extend your remarks that it takes a certain level of competence in a field to correctly evaluate someone at a higher level in the field, and as the level of the evaluated person increases, the required level of the evaluator increases. Someone with a BS in physics level of knowledge or maybe grad degree can possibly evaluate Feynman vs Einstein as per the debate in the comments today. However, I suspect most people can't do a useful evaluation of those two. There are obvious HN on topic analogies with coding, system design, database design, network design.
- anomie 12y agoWhen I read the title I assumed it was an article about the unfairness of the education system, and the whole-life impact of an assessment carried out at an arbitrary point in your 18th year. Perhaps that's an even more pernicious example of the problem.
- zb 12y agoEdward Tufte does a pretty entertaining takedown of Galenson's work in his book Beautiful Evidence. The excerpt in question is online: http://www.edwardtufte.com/bboard/q-and-a-fetch-msg?msg_id=0001Zl http://www.edwardtufte.com/bboard/q-and-a-fetch-msg?msg_id=0...
- VLM 12y agoIts interesting to analogize thinking with athleticism. There are some athletes who just outperform most people in all areas as a class. There are athletes who are experts in certain fields and useless in others (don't enter a football defensive lineman in an ultra-marathon, etc) Some athletes peak very young. Some train very slowly, some develop very fast. Some athletes start training late in life. It is mystifying if you're trapped in the dead/dying idea of mind-body dualism, but if the mind and brain are just another pile of nutrient consuming protein just like muscle, it makes sense that the observations are similar. I would imagine if it were easy to measure, we'd find similar performance trends WRT pancreas or kidney function.
- Xcelerate 12y agoThis may be a little off-topic, but as I was reading the article, I started wondering about something. The author uses examples of genius in art and literature, and noted how Cézanne's early works weren't "very good" and how his later one's were much better, whereas Picasso's early works were considered his best. So I googled paintings of both artists, and I'm perplexed. I have absolutely no clue what is considered "great". Obviously this is because my work is in science and I know next to nothing about art, but I'm still kind of curious what makes a work great in art and literature. For instance, there's thousands (hundreds of thousands?) of painters in the world right now. And if you select the top 100 and showed me their paintings, and then showed me a Picasso, I wouldn't be able to point out why Picasso's is "better". Robert Frost's "Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening" is also mentioned as one of the best poems of all time. I'll admit, it's very beautiful, but I just don't understand what makes it that much more amazing than a contemporary poet's work. Imagine if you took the world's population and wiped everyone's memories of great artists, and then asked them to reevaluate which which works are the "greatest". Would we arrive at the same conclusions? Without the bias of knowing "this is a famous artist, therefore his work must be good", would the rankings of art remain the same? Unlike my literature teachers in high school, I don't believe in "magical qualities", so there has to be some numeric metric one could use to separate the very best from the "just good". What is it? (Perhaps it's not an easily calculable number, but it still must exist; if it didn't, then the whole field of art and literature criticism would be nonsense.)
- dboard 12y agoIs there a numeric metric to separate the very best from the "just good" in any field?
- Xcelerate 12y agoYes. In athletics for instance it's very easy. Each sport has a built-in scoring system from the get-go. I would also say it's pretty easy to pick out the best scientists. Simply evaluate the improvement in predictive power that their contribution to the field elicits, and I think Einstein, Feynman, et al. would fall out pretty easily as the best.
- aaron695 12y agoI love the meta. It's pretty obvious as time goes on, unfortunately it's not better. For some who didn't maximise their earlier it looks like they did, but no, they didn't get better. But it's great art to think it does. So perhaps it's true after all. It's a nice artistic article.
- otakucode 12y agoI can think of 2 reasons very quickly - #1, the brain is far more capable and plastic and active in adolescence than it is in adulthood or later. #2, human beings have a finite lifespan. If you wish to get further than others, you have to surpass their development at all stages. Until we can change biology, no one is going to have a brain that works better than an adolescent, that's just how we evolved.
- squozzer 12y agoTo me, the question of precocity vs. late blooming can be summed up thusly: 1) The 70-year lifespan is a recent development. Producing great work in one's 20s and 30s was a necessity because one's 40s and 50s weren't guaranteed. Social inertia took over from there. 2) The young also have greater marketability (looks, energy) and can usually be controlled more easily. This makes them more attractive to backers. This matters a lot in many fields, but in the arts especially, where the artist receives as much attention as their art.