9 ms·
This Man Has Nothing to Hide – Not Even His Email Password
- TheBiv 12y ago> "He is now a divorced professor at a technical college with no credit cards and extremely uninteresting finances, largely because the bulk of his paychecks are directly deposited, per his preference, in the account of his ex-wife." That just about sums up how he is able to be so flippant with his privacy, even if he has nothing to hide!
- notahacker 12y agoThe other reason he can be so flippant is that he's an ex-Mormon who walked out on his family and church because he'd taken up sleeping around and atheism, so from his point of view the worst damage to his social standing has already been inflicted.
- hawkice 12y agoI am intrigued by the "nothing to hide" = "nothing to lose" equivalence. "Nothing to lose" has always been a primarily mental phenomenon, but I think this clears away some of the potential dishonesty around claims like "if you have nothing to worry about, you shouldn't mind if the government reads your emails". Possible that they mean it, but I there are probably quite a few who do not understand what it means when they say it.
- prawn 12y agoDo you really "take up atheism" or do you just not go to church, etc? I don't feel like I've taken it up, it's just not something I worry about or act on. Rest of your point stands, obviously.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- frobozz 12y agoIt depends on the nature of your faith beforehand, and your lack of faith afterwards. If, as a child, you were just dragged along to church by your parents at Christmas and Easter, then when you grow up and realise you don't believe, so stop going, that's one thing, and there's nothing really "taken up" about it. If you were a regular adult churchgoer of your own volition, perhaps with a lay position within the church, or even part of the clergy, then apostasy, is a strong act that might be called "taking up" your later position, even if the later position is a lack of one. Similarly, if you become a normal atheist who simply doesn't believe in any gods, then there's nothing to take up. However, if you become an evangelical, proselytising atheist like Richard Dawkins, then you've certainly taken it up.
- gridspy 12y agoIf you simply don't believe in god, you're agnostic. If you actively believe that there is no god, you're atheist.
- collyw 12y agoActively believing there is no god, without proof of his/her/it's non existence is as evidence based as religion.
- Thimothy 12y agoNot arguing if this statement is right or wrong, but I think you should know that your phrase is highly controversial and the beginning of thousands flame wars through the internet. Maybe you should avoid it unless it is completely relevant to the topic at hand.
- nitrogen 12y agoNot believing in Santa Claus, Zeus, Imhotep, Peter Pan, or The Green Lantern without proof of their non-existence is etc. etc.? The burden of proof lies with the claim of existence. In the absence of any evidence, nonexistence is the default assumption. Yet disbelief in all of these things is based on evidence, since we have looked in the places people used to believe they lived and/or domains they were believed to control, andand they weren't there.
- mmalone 12y agoHow are you defining God? Have we looked for God in all of the places that people believe God lives / controls? The universe either came from somewhere or has always existed... If I define God as a "the thing that created the universe" how would you prove or disprove God's existence?
- nitrogen 12y agoIf I define God as a "the thing that created the universe"... ...then you would have to justify that definition before expecting anyone to accept, prove, or disprove it. FWIW I was once a believer and frequently associate with believers, so I have some experience in the matter and have given it considerable thought.
- CocaKoala 12y agoReading this reminded me of the adage, "Character is who you are when nobody is watching". Can you imagine being this guy's child and reading him talk about how "Yeah, maybe if people were watching me then I would have tried harder to spend time with my kids last summer". It's not that he wants to spend time with them, he's just worried about how it looks to other people. The truth hurts, but that doesn't mean that the truth is an excuse to be hurtful. This project seems pretty gross; he gets some respect for taking a position and committing to it, but it's not really kind or respectful or fair to anybody he interacts with to commit them to the same position indirectly.
- Mz 12y agoIt gets better: His "transparency" includes being open and honest with the world that he has had several affairs with married women where the husbands did not know. So, is that some kind of loophole? How does he justify that in his twisted logic? Everyone else knows, so it's okay?
- mleonhard 12y agoThis is how I feel when people give all of their email to LinkedIn. :(
- dinkumthinkum 12y agoWell it seems like he has done his children a great service. By logging into his email, his children's classmates can discover than rather than taking care of them, he was worried with sleeping around with other people's wives and those kids, that are generally cruel enough, and through that plus any pictures (because there is no privacy) in their faces as well. I mean, it really sounds like a win-win. :)
- kghose 12y agoSounds like the person is an exhibitionist. My best take away from the article is the insightful statement by the author: "Every one of us is entrusted with information that our family, friends, colleagues, and acquaintances would rather that we kept private."
- seagreen 12y agoThis is a great point. Fundamentally, how well I uphold the trust of my friends is connected to the security of my computing environment. You damn well bet I want more secure software.
- snarfy 12y agoNew technologies like Google Glass are going to make this guy's dream a reality. I suspect people with glass will behave differently when wearing them than when not.
- rdrey 12y agoI think you're overestimating the effect of Glass, since taking pictures and recording video is still a conscious decision. (Except when someone publishes the inevitable life-blogging app that captures a shot every few minutes. Even then sharing with the public (via Google) is still a conscious decision - sharing with Google & the NSA isn't of course. Luckily batteries are still a limiting factor.)
- snarfy 12y agoTrue, but I can see the trend. Maybe 10 generations of glass later, when the glass/smartphone/tricorder device is ubiquitous, we'll see memes happen in society similar to the OPs feelings of 'share everything'. But maybe not. Maybe we'll get videos of people dumping water buckets on themselves.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Mz 12y agoExcerpt: "In most societies, we [recognize] the right of people to keep secrets. But really, there’s only one purpose for keeping secrets: secrets exist to prevent other people from acting as they would if they had complete information," Yeah, that's because most people cannot be completely trusted with your welfare. Der. They don't usually have your best interest at heart, even in cases where their intent is not specifically malicious. Also: He thinks most of us would live more ethically too. I doubt that. They would just get better at appearing to be ethical, which really isn't the same thing.
- kijin 12y ago> They would just get better at appearing to be ethical, which really isn't the same thing. There's a long and hard-to-kill tradition of thought, both in the West and in other cultures, that says something along the lines of "If you try hard enough to look like you care about X for a long time, you'll end up actually caring about X." It's the idea behind every educational system that requires students to wear uniforms: "Make them dress like ladies and gentlemen for several years, and they'll actually become ladies and gentlemen." It has also been the idea behind many state religions, both ancient and modern: "Make them participate in religious rituals from birth to death, and they'll actually come to have faith in our god(s)." What's scary is that this often works. It's an extremely powerful tool of social manipulation.
- Mz 12y agoI was sexually abused as a child. My healing process has been a long, strange journey. HN is not the right place to get into an in-depth discussion of my experiences. Suffice it to say that I have done a great deal of reading and thinking about sexual ethics and I have come to believe that there is a really huge difference between looking ethical and behaving in an ethical fashion. In fact, most "moral" people seem to be mostly concerned with social approval and doing things other people will agree is right. Actually ethical people seem to often be (or appear to be) amoral: They have standards they live by and public opinion be damned. That last stance gets harder if everything is in view. The first one easier. It isn't an outcome I long for.
- 12y ago
- lquist 12y agoIncidentally, this article is paid for by Metlife.
- Vhejdhchehd 12y agoThe "nothing to hide" argument is fundamentally wrong just like how shedding other rights because you don't personally need them is wrong. >I don't need a fair trial: I'm not a criminal! >I don't need free speech: I'm not a radical! >I don't need a free press: there's no corruption! Just like what Orwell discussed in 1984, words such as "liberty" and "freedom" are only propagandaspeak used to rally the population behind a vague sense of patriotism. The actual concepts behind these phrases have been systematically eliminated.
- miguelrochefort 12y agoI totally agree with that guy, and I've been looking for likeminded people for months. Beside social stigma, the most important barrier to living a transparent life is our reliance on secrets for identification. That includes Social Security numbers, Credit Card numbers, bank account passwords/nips, all details about physical keys and locks, etc. You might say that public access to the above information is only a problem in conjunction with private property rights. But even if nobody owns anything, secret/public keys are currently some of the best way to identify people and track trust/reputation/opinions. Without some kind of alternative, anybody could claim anything in my name. That's problematic. We need a way to accurately track and identify people, without the need to rely on secrets. Beside having billions of independent cameras/trackers everywhere and cross-validate their measurements, I don't know how we're going to achieve that.
- shurcooL 12y agoI could not agree more; I feel the same way. It always makes me shudder when banks or other supposedly high security institutions ask me to provide the answer to "What city were you born in?" for extra security. I don't want to have to guard that secret, because it's not. Just an example. I feel that in a world with perfect transparency we wouldn't have to worry about things. If someone tried to impersonate you or steal your money, _they_ would get into trouble because it'd be public knowledge what they did. It's just much easier to rely on things being okay because everyone knows everything, rather than because everyone doesn't know certain things.
- dinkumthinkum 12y agoReally? I don't want to brow beat you but I really if you agree with this person, I can't help but think you need to wake up to reality. This is just utter nonsense. Privacy/secrecy as it relates to identification or ownership is just one facet of the world. You realize people are not actually robots or play-things in a Dystopian novel right? People have complex lives, desires, strategies for achieving their goals, feelings, etc.
- mkal_tsr 12y agoMost people here only see $ unfortunately.
- wamatt 12y agoFYI, he's doing a Kickstarter to raise awareness and funding: https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/noahdyer/a-year-without-privacy-noahdyertv https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/noahdyer/a-year-without... Philosophically speaking, the idea of a society where every actioned is monitored, recorded and made available, is a potentially interesting thought experiment. That said, I find it rather difficult to feel too excited, for this specific campaign.
- CocaKoala 12y ago>What about the privacy of your kids? >My kids don't have anything to hide. Did his kids say that, or is he saying that for them?
- lifeisstillgood 12y agoTl;dr guy thinks privacy is dead and so sets up a project to be completely transparent (public access to emails, video of daily life etc). He is a divorced Ex Mormon also, not relevant but a good story hook I like it btw - I agree that dealin with loss of privacy means asymmetry in knowledge unless we make things transparent.
- coldtea 12y agoWas thinking about this line in some comment: "if you have nothing to worry about, you shouldn't mind if the government reads your emails". Besides the obvious flaws, shouldn't it also go the other way? The government hides tons of things, from classified documents to internal memos. What about that?
- rabbyte 12y ago> "secrets exist to prevent other people from acting as they would if they had complete information" And? I don't understand why the reader must assume it would be good for people to act with complete information. Privacy is required where trust is absent because people in the abstract are not responsible or empathetic enough to warrant the risk. Ask any celebrity if privacy is a barrier to equality. This isn't pessimism either; I could see privacy not be needed but only if the protection from harm is replaced by other protections embedded in the culture or environment.
- mmalone 12y agoEh... I don't get it? Why is privacy required where there is no trust? I see how the two are related but I see it kind of differently... it's hard not to trust someone when you know they're not hiding anything. In a totally utopian sense I believe that privacy is bad. Practically it's probably impossible to implement society without privacy. I wouldn't share my email password because we're not living in a utopia and that information asymmetry would hurt me. However, if privacy went away social norms would have to change -- there would be a lot less hypocrisy -- and the things I'm keeping private right now wouldn't need to be private any longer. Really privacy just facilitates lying.
- Zancarius 12y agoIn a strange sense, in particular when reading the article, I'm reminded of a certain Orwellian utopia in which there was virtually no extant privacy. Maybe it "facilitates lying," although I think that's a rather extremist view, but if there's information I'm not willing to provide you, I may not necessarily be lying--I just don't feel that it's pertinent or necessary for you to know. Or in particularly pathological cases, I've simply forgotten, so neither of us will be privy to information that has been lost or destroyed. It's just unfortunate that it seems in this case, "lying" has been stretched to mean "lack of information or imperfect information" rather than "a statement which is not factual truth." That's not an argument I agree with. Likewise, I'm not so sure a privacy-less world would be, or bring about, utopia. At least, thusfar, I haven't read anything that has convinced me. Yes, I'm sure part of it is due to my own experiences in our world where privacy is a norm, but I'm not sure I completely buy into the belief that privacy facilitates all of these ills spoken about in TFA (or by yourself or other commenters). For one, there will always be actors with malevolent intentions--eliminating privacy for all individuals is unlikely to change that fact. Groupthink also comes to mind wherein opposing opinions are punished by way of mob justice. I could foresee a world where a lack of privacy encourages homogenous public opinion, either because those who might be inclined to disagree fear embarrassment or punishment.
- tolmasky 12y ago> "And having been transparent with his coreligionists about his loss of faith and with his ex-wife about his lost willingness to be monogamous, he gradually came to this life philosophy: Society would be better if no one had any secrets." Spoken like someone blessed to have been born a white heterosexual male in 21st century America. I wonder if he'd feel the same way if he was a homosexual in an incredibly homophobic town. He also seems to have reversed cause and effect here. Its not necessarily asymmetrical information that gives people power, but rather power that results in asymmetrical information. There's no magic switch to reveal all information in the universe, so its going to be government thats better at keeping secrets than you in a society that expects defacto transparency. Have fun trying to prosecute the government for keeping secrets when they have every detail on your life catalogued. You can't base a life philosophy around "if everyone magically did the right thing then..."
- ggreer 12y agoSimilar to how violence is acceptable in defense of self and others, I think the same holds for lying or withholding information. If telling the truth risks inviting harm, it's right to lie. Since societies judge some lifestyles harshly, being less open than Dyer is perfectly ethical. I agree that Dyer is fortunate to be able to take such an extreme position, but I do think society would be better off if we moved toward his ideal, rather than away from it.
- bad_user 12y agoI do think that society cannot evolve towards ideals that go against the human nature. Lets be honest here, we're humans, we have flaws - any ideals that do not work within the constraints of human nature are bound to fail. Lets do a thought exercise - at extremes, what would be like if every human would be connected to the thoughts of other humans? What would be like if your friends would hear every dirty thought you have about them in a moment of weakness? What would be like if your wife that's miles away would be able to feel you admiring a hot chick passing by? The outcome is simple to grasp - in order for us to survive, we'll stop being humans - feelings for one would not belong in this world, which would raise the question of why we'd want to live our miserable lives anymore? And if you think that we should at least have privacy of our own thoughts since the line has to be drawn somewhere, then you just acknowledged the need for privacy and yes, where should the line be drawn is a very good question and the answer should be that's up to the individual, because a heterosexual white male doesn't have the same problems as a gay afro-american.
- dskang 12y agoFor anyone who's curious what a world in which everyone is forced to throw away their privacy and embrace complete transparency might look like, Dave Eggers wrote a fantastic book called The Circle (http://www.amazon.com/The-Circle-Dave-Eggers/dp/0385351399 http://www.amazon.com/The-Circle-Dave-Eggers/dp/0385351399) that explores that very concept. Highly recommended.
- deskglass 12y agoThanks for the recommendation. I'll check that book out. Once, in thread similar to this one, I saw another recommendation for The Light of Other Days (http://smile.amazon.com/Light-Other-Days-Arthur-Clarke-ebook/dp/B003CTEFLG http://smile.amazon.com/Light-Other-Days-Arthur-Clarke-ebook.... It explores a world where everyone can see and hear everyone else at any (past and present) time. While I did not always find the plot compelling, I still enjoyed reading it because it explores some cool ideas.
- infectoid 12y agoWhat I found most interesting about the story was when a character was confronted by the factual truth of a past event that didn't agree with what she strongly believed to be true. There is no room for objection as you can view all past (and present) events as they really happened. But your comments are accurate. While, not always compelling, the concepts are pretty cool to indulge in.
- dskang 12y agoI should add that the story is especially appropriate for the HN crowd because the privacy-less world is realized by a Google-like tech company that decides that complete transparency via omnipresent recording devices would lead to a healthier society. The arguments made by Noah in the article are identical to those used by the tech company in the book.
- vacri 12y agoIt's an impressive story, but there is a notable difference between sending your details to a person you know the name of, who you can directly implore not to be a bastard, and just opening things up completely. This is noted in the article near the end: "In fairness, Dyer hardly shared his private communications with the whole world.". We already know from other experiences that public display of financial account numbers results in bad actors taking advantage of them (eg Jeremy Clarkson's stunt, or the disaster relief credit card pictured in a story on Hurricane Katrina). One chosen individual is unlikely to be a bad actor. The general public does however contain them - opening up to one individual is quite different to a wide demographic.
- aric 12y agoLack of privacy seems like a good way to encourage cultural genocide. Total transparency for individuals would make it easier for prevailing thought-leaders to suppress minority groups. Culture could be eliminated before it has a chance to coalesce to the point of daring to enter public acceptance. To think otherwise is to believe that cultural tyranny (thus legal tyranny) wouldn't exist in a world where no one may hide. That's foolish. Tyranny bred in complete openness is possibly more insidious. It's harder to escape. The author, perhaps, isn't bothered by the many reasons why other people unlike himself want privacy and have wanted privacy throughout history. Maybe the plight of others will never be good enough for him to change his advocacy. There's irony in his case. Not so long ago, and to this day in many parts of the world, revealing oneself as an atheist would have made one subject to extreme persecution, if not quicker death. It was through a long course of secrecy, over a gradual shift in public perception, which was rapidly accelerated by the soft veil of the internet, that more people began to feel safe enough to 'come out' as atheists. (Granted, that history didn't have a complete lack of privacy. Yet, if it had, I'd wager that the world today would have even fewer "heretics" upon whose shoulders others may rest their unpopular thoughts.) Transparency should be a growing expectation people have toward all governments and institutions that wage force over people. I agree with that part.
- bronbron 12y ago> Society would be better if no one had any secrets. Maybe, except that because information asymmetry provides an advantage, and sometimes a huge one, there will always be an incredibly strong incentive for each individual to keep secrets. An overwhelmingly strong incentive, I posit. Enforcing total transparency would basically require us to read everyone's thoughts.
- Renaud 12y agoI can't help to think that this man's views are very short sighted. They remind me of what happens when people decide not to lie any more. Works great in theory until you start hurting other people. I'm still fundamentally in favour of strong privacy laws. That some choose not to exercise their rights is their own decision to make. They are however, not entitled to make these decisions for others. A simple example of why strong protection is needed is when you have to travel to countries that, if privacy in your own country was weak, would gain access to more information than you'd want them to. So you're a gay atheist who likes to smoke pot from time to time? Please follow this nice man with the rifle.
- nsajko 12y agos/untitled/entitled/
- justinlloyd 12y agoThe people who declare "If you have nothing to hide, you have nothing to fear" never grew up in a parochial village that persecuted anything that was different. I was interested in books, SciFi, computers, electronics. Because I did not subscribe to the populist viewpoint of all that mattered was sports, sports, and more sports, getting blackout drunk on Friday and Saturday night, fishing and torturing small furry animals "just for fun" I suffered more than my fair share of persecution, beatings (lots and lots of beatings) and ostracism. The idiots that declare "nothing to hide, nothing to fear" are privileged minority, usually white, male and middle class.
- kazinator 12y agoThe premise of the article is a fallacy of equivocation over the word "nothing". "I have nothing to hide" is used as an argument meaning "I have nothing to hide for which I might be wanted by the authorities"; it does not literally mean "nothing at all". "I have nothing to hide" is an argument used against the advocacy of tools for anonymity and cryptography, and in particular tools that use strong cryptography and are free of back doors. The counter argument "you have your personal privacy to hide" to hide makes a strawman out of "I have nothing to hide" around the interpretation of the word "nothing". The nothing-to-hide argument, in its strongest form, is specifically limited as an argument against the advocacy of tools that make governments nervous, not against fig leaves and coconuts. That part of it is plausible, in fact: basic privacy arguably does not need strong anonymity and crypto tools that are free of back doors. You can be investigated by a government in ways that actually "respect" your privacy, so to speak. By this I mean that they get into into your accounts (using exploits or deliberately planted back doors), don't find what they're looking for, and then move on. Nothing private of yours has become public, and you don't even know. I'm not saying I agree with any of this, just that you have to take the "I have nothing to hide" argument more seriously: the taunt "so open your e-mail to everyone" is not really an effective response. Those who use the "I have nothing to hide" argument are statists and conformists; they really mean "I am willing to open all aspects of my life to the authorities in cooperation with any investigation", not "I'm willing to open my life to the public". (The tacit implication is "those who are not willing to unconditionally cooperate with the authorities to the extent that I am are not merely advocates of liberty: they likely have something to hide, whether it be links to terrorist organizations, child porn, or evidence of crime. Unlike me, the advocates of those tools and systems are not so confident that nothing will be found.")
- kazinator 12y agoThe argument against "nothing to hide" is this: 1. So you agree with every single law there is, and every single prohibition against any activity or posession of anything? 2. Even if you don't violate any law or prohibition yourself, but your best friend or a family member is investigated for such a thing, you're willing to open up everything to help provide evidence to throw that friend under the proverbial bus, in the name of conformity to the state? 3. Are you okay with doing away with wiretap laws and search warrants? 4. Are you okay with any citizen being arrested and given "truth serum" drugs so they truthfully divulge everything they believe to be true on any topic? If they have nothing to hide, why should anyone object?
- dinkumthinkum 12y agoThis is about the silliest thing I've read in awhile. All right so he wants to do this dumb PR stunt where he films his life and he wants to raise money on Kickstarters. OK, I will just wait for him to raise the money, log in to his Kickstarter or his bank account, take all his money and voila I have won the game. I mean this is extraordinarily ridiculous and I don't know how this is making any intelligible point about society or how we shouldn't care about privacy. So without privacy politicians would work to build a Utopia or something? This is not worth the time of The Atlantic, or what I thought that institution was about. The idea that people will act more ethically because of privacy is something out of a Dystopian novel, but he actually sees this as Utopian; this makes me wonder if this is a prank. Let us wonder, if we give up all privacy, I imagine this applies to institutions. So, when Google gives me their Secret key, or wait, no one will ever use encryption because there will be no secrets, what stops someone from firing a nuclear weapon because of course we will not have secrets like the "launch codes." I realize in such a Utopia we won't need nuclear weapons but let's Utopia will start tomorrow, before we get rid of these weapons ... What's to stop some mentally ill person from using the free knowledge to destroy the world of all new-found anti-privacy advocates? Oh, you may say "we won't share those secrets." OK, where does this end because I don't know see how you get Utopia without everyone following this silly idea. I mean, it may come as a surprise, but humans are (relatively) intelligent self-interested agents and will not always follow such noble ideals as no-privacy, particularly if they will have grey area sorts of cases, such as keep launch codes secret. It's just such a farce. I never thought anyone could make Zuckerberg seem like someone that has intelligent thoughts about privacy but here we are.
- mmalone 12y agoIn a hypothetical world with no privacy and perfect information I'd just make my nuclear launch system (which also has perfect information) only launch when the right people ask them too. You can't pretend to be those people because you can't lie because the launch system would know because there's no privacy. I don't know of any way to actually implement this in practice -- there probably isn't one -- but it's an interesting thought experiment. It's possible that privacy isn't a moral right and perhaps isn't necessary at all. The argument for privacy seems to be predicated on other people being immoral. If you could identify immoral people 100% accurately then perhaps the need for privacy goes away. In fact, if that were the status quo you might claim that keeping something private is immoral.
- headgasket 12y ago1.Accept no privacy in exchange for access to all feeds 2.implement and roll out fail proof reporting tech 3.Restrict access to feeds 4.8.9.1 is what you'll see in the oblong mirror (bonus if you get to call the tech telescreen)
- elwell 12y agoI don't have to hide my email password either: I use 2-factor auth.
- Double_Cast 12y ago> All the world's a stage, > And all the men and women merely players. I think one benefit of privacy is the ability to maintain multiple identities. Not just "secret" identities, but also the ability to play different roles depending on the context. I'm not sure how to explain it exactly, but I feel like a loss of privacy would bestow upon me a pretty heavy cognitive burden. Even if my behavior isn't embarrassing or self-sabotaging, I have better things to do than justify my every waking moment and tailor a consistent & comprehensive identity. It would be the equivalent of spaghetti code. And in keeping with the information asymmetry theme, I can't see how this could be feasibly implemented. If everyone agreed to an entirely transparent society, it only takes a single agent to exploit the system by keeping secrets anyway. There would have to be absurdly harsh disincentives for defecting in order to keep the system pareto optimal.
- panzi 12y agoI'm sure the mafia would love the end of the witness protection program. And fundamentalists of any religion would like to know who exactly is breaking which one of their arbitrary rules and where they live, when their kids go to school etc. Pedophile offenders would like to know when which child is home alone etc. Privacy has a purpose, damn it! These are extreme cases, but they still are about the privacy of people. The article mentioned good less extreme examples. Just who you are voting for is already something you have to hide (in general). If you wouldn't have a right for secret elections you could be forced to vote for a certain candidate or your vote could be bought. Yes, the governments keep things secret that shouldn't be secret (e.g. contracts/agreements with other countries, i.e. how the big countries fuck the little ones). There is a saying: use public data, protect private data. In German: Öffentliche Daten nützen, private Daten schützen. (it rhymes)
- munin 12y ago> I'm sure the mafia would love the end of the witness protection program. if there was truly no privacy, then the Mafia would cease to exist. think this through.
- panzi 12y agoThe mafia wouldn't care about laws. So the mafia would keep secrets but law abiding citizens wouldn't. So there is a fundamental asymmetry.
- collyw 12y agoGood to see the pedophile argument in here on HN. I thought this was a bit more intelligent than the Daily Mail. Assuming that pedophile offenders didn't have any privacy either, would your problem still exist?
- panzi 12y agoThe one time when this argument actually works and I use it I'm accused of being as intelligent as the Daily Mail! A criminal only has to investigate one arbitrary innocent. But the innocent (or the police) would have to sieve through the data of all other people. And someone only becomes an offender when it's to late. There is no guarantee that he/she could be recognized as a potential thread in advance. Therefore certain information should be only provided to people you have reason to trust.
- conradfr 12y ago1/ I don't trust extremists like him. It seems to me they are usually the ones who moves from cause to cause way too easily leaving everyone behind, or fight their "daemons" by putting the blame and the burden on the whole society. 2/ "Zero is still the amount of times I've killed someone, robbed someone, raped someone, taken illicit drugs, or even had alcohol or other substances," So that what being virtuous is for him, not society as a whole. 3/ "He thinks most of us would live more ethically too." That paragraph is scary. He needs people to watch him to behave better ? While telling us that becoming a non-believer felt liberating regarding his sexuality ? 4/ Reducing privacy to a power tool for the elite is ludicrous. He confuses transparency with no privacy. He also ignores lots of things about human psychology and sociology. 5/ I was disappointed that the reporter didn't checked his Google search history. 6/ You don't need $300,000 and a crew. You only need webcams, Gopro and Google Glasses.
- Xcelerate 12y ago"... he then married, had four children [...] that a polyamorous lifestyle was, in fact, for him [...] "I really wanted to have sex with other people" [...] now a divorced professor" How convenient for him. I'm supposed to take life lessons from some guy that put his own selfish needs above his wife's and children's just because he got bored of having sex with one person? That's sickening.
- DarqWebster 12y agoHang on, as much as I disagree with the man, this is not why. The man realised, during the course of his relationship, that he was unhappy with his life. So he made a change that made him happier. At the same time he deposits the bulk of his paycheck into his wife's account and considers it his ethical duty to see his kids three to four times a week. All things considered, the man made the change in a rather respectable manner. The alternative is to remain in the relationship, discontent, for the rest of his life. Is that what is expected of people? In the best case, one person is miserable. In the worst case, his unhappiness manifests in the relationships with his wife and kids. It seems reasonable that he steps aside before that can happen, leaving him and his family to pursue happiness elsewhere. I disagree with him because of his premise that complete information creates a level playing field between people. Rather, the people who fall closer to the perceived "normal" gain power over those who are closer to the tails of the bell-curve.
- Xcelerate 12y ago> The alternative is to remain in the relationship, discontent, for the rest of his life. Is that what is expected of people? Yes, absolutely. I would expect no less of myself.
- yuhong 12y agoPersonally I tend to focus on reducing the need for anonymity on the Internet, though I know eliminating the need completely will probably never be possible. I still remember this for example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7809766 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7809766 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7816839 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7816839
- mikehall314 12y agoI'm reminded of the Ricky Gervais movie The Invention of Lying, and how easily his character is able to manipulate the society he is part of because he lies and no-one else does. In Dyer's privacy-less utopia, it just takes one person to break the rules, to keep things to themselves, to create a power disparity.
- corobo 12y agoThe problem with no privacy is context. I have no idea the context of this Facebook status, just grabbed it as the first thing that caught my eye. http://i.imgur.com/zUh8qfn.png http://i.imgur.com/zUh8qfn.png > Suppose, hypothetically, I wanted to meet a beautiful "little person." Where, in your opinion, would one go to most reliably be acquainted with such a treasure? — feeling determined. Is he making a joke, is he someone that treats people as objects? There's no context, his ideals don't work.