4 ms·
Anarchy doesn't really exist. It's just that people want to go back to a state before the current contracts and laws were passed. What would happen? The same ki
by kzrdude 12y ago
Anarchy doesn't really exist. It's just that people want to go back to a state before the current contracts and laws were passed. What would happen? The same kinds of associations, rules, and laws would form again.
- coriny 12y agoAnarcho-collectivists, which as far as I understand, represents the dominant modern anarchistic philosophy, examine alternative methods to central government for generating laws. So they don't argue for an unregulated society - which is obviously a non-starter under the lens of reality - or a return to pre-government, but rather a complete replacement of the law-making mechanism. Basically, they're all over complexity theory and how to use strong local interactions to develop self-organising non-local societies. Which I personally think makes anarcho-collectivism possibly the most sophisticated and futuristic of current political models. They were two decades ahead of the "localism" and "direct democracy" ideologies, and with a far better understanding of the maths.
- voronoff 12y agoDo you have any links to writings on this (Anarcho-collectivism from a complexity perspective or vice-versa)? Did both a quick journal search and a Google search and didn't find much.
- coriny 12y agoSorry for the very late reply, I've been hoping I'd get some time to do this properly, but haven't succeeded. It's something I first read ~10 years ago, where it was mostly in the musings of a complexity theorist. Since then odd things have cropped up which have supported that narrative in my mind, but I haven't got a particularly convincing collection to work with. There's some leads in here though: http://www.anarchist-studies-network.org.uk/documents/Anarchism%20and%20World%20Politics/CudHob.pdf http://www.anarchist-studies-network.org.uk/documents/Anarch....
- jlangenauer 12y agoYes, as someone who's interested in this, I'd love to read any links or papers about this aspect of it.
- coriny 12y agoApologies for my poor stab at answering this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8273839 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8273839
- baddox 12y agoAll self-proclaimed anarchists I am aware of oppose the state, but do not oppose associations, rules, or laws.
- mikeash 12y agoThe point is that "the state" will just come back. You can't get rid of it permanently.