7 ms·
HTTP "Prefer:Safe" – Making Online Safety Simpler in Firefox
- walterbell 12y ago> designed to simplify and strengthen the online trust and safety model. Is this intended for the publisher to implement filtering, or for the publisher to declare semantic labels which can be filtered by 3rd-party sites with consistent editoral viewpoints?
- djent 12y ago"Strengthen the online trust and safety model" is a weird way to say "no porn."
- iancarroll 12y agoIt has many other uses, IMO. - Disable signup/require COPPA form to be mailed & signed - Filter out explicit content from user-generated content - Disable vulgar sections from a blog - Prohibit downloading software etc
- ossreality 12y agoMost of these are horrible suggestions for the same reason Do Not Track is useless - no enforcement or guarantees make it pointless. Especially that last one. LOL. The notion of a webpage blocking me from downloading because of a header that my platform's client browser sent? Pfft.
- comex 12y ago> - Disable signup/require COPPA form to be mailed & signed Somewhat off topic, but I think 13 is considerably above the age where kids have a reasonable interest in being able to actually use the web. When I was a few years younger than 13 (10 years ago...), I once accidentally put my true birthday into AIM, and was subsequently banned from the service I used to communicate with friends from school. Recently, the same happened with one of my sister's friends and Gmail. Does anyone actually think these forms are a good thing?
- iancarroll 12y agoI don't think forms are the answer. I think it should be around 9 or 10, honestly. I'm not too sure what would replace forms though.
- Karunamon 12y agoSounds like a great way for kids to learn how HTTP debugging proxies work.
- dimman 12y agoWas just gonna say that; "Users won’t find any UI in Firefox to enable or disable Prefer:Safe, which becomes one less thing for kids to try to circumvent to disable this control." That's good, make them hackers instead by making them implement their own HTTP-proxy :)
- 0x0 12y agoCan I start sending "Prefer: Unsafe" headers and expect to see a difference, too?
- chimeracoder 12y agoI have to say, I don't really care much for this, and I'm surprised to see it coming from Mozilla. "Prefer:Safe" is rather vague-sounding. I was expecting something about incorporating something like "HTTPS Everywhere" into Firefox. I understand the appeal of something to prevent kids from stumbling across porn or violence online, but let's not muddy words like "trust" (which mean something very different when talking about security and privacy) with the concept of age-appropriate content.
- chc 12y agoI think the idea isn't so much a porn filter as it is a "treat this user as a child" request. So, for example, social networking sites might work in restricted mode. I do agree "prefer safe" is a very poor way of expressing that desire, though. Maybe "child-safe", but not just "safe", which implies a related but different idea.
- bostik 12y agoIf this takes off at all, I can see the sites reacting by altering the advertising group selection based on the presence of the header. "Cool, an under-10 browsing. Let's push all the autoplay toy videos we have in rotation." I already get the creeps from the toy ads squeezed between and in the middle of children's TV shows.
- ClassicFarris 12y agoI agree… If this is only done when, Parental Controls, are enable from the OS level. Then a: "parental-control:enabled" header would make more sense, right?
- mperham 12y ago"Won't someone think of the children?" comes to the HTTP standard. Seriously though, this seems totally reasonable although "safe" does seem like an odd word choice. Maybe "modest" instead?
- theon144 12y agoI'm thinking it's in the same category as "Safe For Work" and "Not Safe For Work". But yeah, I expected a HTTP header that would, say, redirect to an encrypted version of the webpage, sort of like HTTPS Everywhere, but on the browser-server level.
- darklajid 12y agoNSFW is just another undefined concept. It depends on your work, on your culture/upbringing and the society you live in. If I stumble upon pictures of tits because someone posted a link to a yellow press newspaper site or a random celebrity scandal, I .. misclicked because that wouldn't interest me in the slightest. But it wouldn't be unsafe, not even for work. On the other hand, I wouldn't exactly want to end up on a nazi propaganda page (even if I'm merely looking at current splitter groups/facts around news reports about these sort of braindead idiots). I would feel very bad about leaving a trace like that - even if I don't think I'd have to face any sort of consequences. Point being: Safe™ is undefined, for minors or employers. You can try to find a GCD, a common global set - and you'll fail/end up with a balance act between false positives and misses.
- M2Ys4U 12y agoIsn't that HSTS? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTTP_Strict_Transport_Security https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTTP_Strict_Transport_Security
- iopq 12y agoI prefer to be safe. Can I be safe while browsing porn?
- brimstedt 12y agoA header Id rather see is Cookies: I-know-what-they-are-for "don't show me information about cookie usage".. )
- 0x0 12y agoAgreed. Can't believe the alert has to be implemented on all the websites, instead of requiring browser vendors to provide an alert (that can be globally disabled.
- rmc 12y agoThat would be against the law. Talk to your MEP, not browser maker, if you want to change it.
- wlv 12y agoThis is what websites want you to think. Do it badly -> annoy users -> no more laws that protect users.
- itsadok 12y agoI was with them until they mentioned "one less thing for kids to try to circumvent to disable this control". If a kid is actively trying to circumvent the parental controls, this is no longer about "protection" but about control. In other news, the Feynman lectures on QED are blocked in "safe" mode. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yvl6TBGEoO0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yvl6TBGEoO0
- narsil 12y agoIt's up to content providers to honor the header. I can't expect that to happen very easily when explicit content is involved, although the avenues to find that content (such as Google) might be amenable.
- icebraining 12y agoI can't expect that to happen very easily when explicit content is involved Why not? Porn sites aren't interested in appearing to kids, which are unlikely to pay for their stay.
- mschuster91 12y agoJust wtf is this. Mozilla now jumping on the "omigod teh childr0n" bandwagon, too? Any reasonably educated child can easily disable all of these "safety features" (e.g. boot the machine at night from USB stick...). These "features" are nothing but placebos for parents too incompetent to educate their children.
- leni536 12y ago>(e.g. boot the machine at night from USB stick...) Well it does not work, if I use a transparent proxy at home which injects "Prefer: Safe" in every HTTP request header.
- darklajid 12y agoIn which case the browser support and whole article is useless and nothing new for that kind of weird setup. Although I'd recommend being a responsible admin/parent in that case instead and, with the _correct_ infrastructure for this scenario already in place, define filters for things you don't like or white lists for things that are okay for your network, instead of begging the internet to correctly guess your moral boundaries.
- indeyets 12y agoI think you misunderstand. This is a feature for 5-6yo, not for 11-12yo
- rurounijones 12y ago[Citation Needed] Spec makes no mention of age groups this is supposed to be used for aside from "children".
- indeyets 12y agoIt is a matter of common sense. You can't reasonably control internet usage of teenager (and probably shouldn't). While 5yo is an avid user YouTube and google and it is a good idea to filter things they can get to
- kijin 12y agoI wonder how they're going to implement the "no circumvention" part. Surely there's an option in about:config that affects the new behavior? Is about:config disabled too? There are also dozens of add-ons that lets you control every single header. Are add-ons disabled too, or is there going to be a blacklist of header-modifying add-ons? It will take less than a week for point-and-click circumvention tools to become available all over the place. Just download this little .EXE that makes a small change to your Firefox profile and might or might not also contain malware! Should Google block searches like "how to disable Prefer:Safe" if such searches come from a browser that already has "Prefer:Safe" enabled?
- icebraining 12y agoIt will take less than a week for point-and-click circumvention tools to become available all over the place. Just download this little .EXE that makes a small change to your Firefox profile and might or might not also contain malware! This is supposed be activated by Windows Parental Controls, which already allow you to block the user from running unknown .exe files.
- darklajid 12y agoSoooo.. This is sending "Hey, this is a kid on a restricted machine" to all servers now? I mean I fail to understand the original idea, obviously. It makes no sense to me. But I question the value of the above - basically now the server can _just as easily_ do crap with that information. You can now identify minors (using that feature). Beautiful. The server operators cannot decide what 'parental control' would mean for parents, they cannot decide what is ~okay~ or what isn't. Referencing a random US regulation/law (COPPA?) in a discussion about international traffic, international browser products seems crazy. If you want to prevent your kids from accessing 'stuff', make sure that 'stuff' is filtered on their machine or better on the edge of your network. Don't believe that random guys on the net will correctly guess what you find questionable content for kids and hide it, because .. your kid's browser sent a friendly "My parents didn't allow me to see unspecified things" header. Edit: I reread that thing over and over again. Something else that utterly blows my mind is this: Users won’t find any UI in Firefox to enable or disable Prefer:Safe, which becomes one less thing for kids to try to circumvent to disable this control. Newsflash: That includes the parents. Unless that is utterly misleading (or my English as a second language parser fails) this means that I, as a parent [1], can NOT - activate parental control features that are somehow detected by Fx - opt out of that idiotic header that announces decisions from my private household to each and every server, starting with Google for example 1: Hypothetical example. While I've got two kids, but both are too young to operate a computer yet and I probably won't buy into standard 'parental control' solutions anyway.
- user24 12y agoAgreed; "The server operators cannot decide what 'parental control' would mean for parents" is the most important part, for me. There are as many definitions of "what is appropriate for kids to see" as there are parents. The decision belongs with the parents, not with the 3rd party sites who, let's not forget, are the ones supplying the content in the first place. This just seems like an utterly naive and vague idea.
- realusername 12y agoI exactly had the same idea... I would also add that this thing is going to be useless anyway because not all the websites are going to implement it. So you will have this header + the traditional blocker... It's totally unrelated but something I would really like to have right now would be a header with the average connection bandwidth (or just thresholds). This could be really useful to reduce the amount of data sent if the connection is really bad.
- Loic 12y agoMy feeling is that most of the people talking here do not have children yet. As a father, I would be really pleased to have such header accepted by many providers to just filter out content which is clearly not for kids. A small example, I am French living abroad, if I want my kids to read a bit the news, I cannot send them on one of the 3 "major" French newspaper to read a bit. Why? Because at the bottom of the first page, they put a lot of sexual content like fully naked women wresting. If this header could remove such content, together with videos where people are beheaded. I would be pleased. Really. If you start to think that this is censoring content, it is not, it is journalist work, that is, providing adapted content to the visitor.
- paublyrne 12y agoI would imagine the newspaper you refer to is not regarded as a serious newspaper, but I am not too familiar with the French publications. Surely there are other ones you could trust them to browse. Which one were you referring to again?
- darklajid 12y agoHow can the sites tell that this content isn't okay? I posted an example elsewhere in this thread: I might want to limit a 16yo with parental controls to avoid having them use the computer the whole night, but I wouldn't mind them seeing (naked) girls on a yellow press site, if that's what they stumble upon. I'm also reasonably sure that your particular problem could already be solved on the client site, today, and that would even make sure that your personal take on moral values is respected. Plus, as others have stated, 'parental' controls might be used for a "kiosk mode" in a hotel or elsewhere (for .. whatever reason). Would you really want these scenarios to result in the same thing ("Content filtered on a news site"), both for your personal kids and for random mature people elsewhere?
- dchest 12y agodo not have children yet "Yet"? You mean, everyone will eventually have children, and only people who have children can discuss such things?
- wlv 12y agoWhy isn't there a space before "Safe"? New compact http headers saving one character?
- Aissen 12y agoI used to think so. Then I read the spec: http://www.w3.org/Protocols/rfc2616/rfc2616-sec4.html#sec4.2 http://www.w3.org/Protocols/rfc2616/rfc2616-sec4.html#sec4.2 The field value MAY be preceded by any amount of LWS, though a single SP is preferred. For the definition of SP and LWS, see: http://www.w3.org/Protocols/rfc2616/rfc2616-sec2.html#sec2.2 http://www.w3.org/Protocols/rfc2616/rfc2616-sec2.html#sec2.2 For the definition of MAY, see: https://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc2119.txt https://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc2119.txt
- yry4345 12y agoThe Web is about statelessness and hyperlinking, so I'll note that: 1) Javascript breaks stateless linking. 2) Mobile versions and browser detection breaks stateless linking. 3) Censorship headers like Prefer:Safe, and censorship in general, breaks stateless linking. And the list goes on. Some state and inability to link is inevitable, but this is not. Mozilla: please get back on track for a strong/stateless and cite-able web. Headers are not the place to build a censorship "UX." Also, "safety"? That's not helping. Almost no one uses NetNanny, or similar software and, while I'd like to think we've grown as a species, even if we haven't, it doesn't make sense to force something most Web surfers have already rejected back down their throats. (And it is forcing them, even if it's optional. The social implications of even "optional" headers will be with us for a very long time.) A browser especially should strive to be neutral, unless you want to start getting requests from governments and industry to block sites directly in the browser. Google handles a million or more every day and they are just and index list... You can't expect a different fate without discarding neutrality as a core principal. Cite-ability requires availability, and censorship - the Web-equivalent of a frontal lobotomy - contradicts the very essence of your product. I'm starting to feel ashamed to be using a browser made by an organization that doesn't understand that.
- jasonlingx 12y agoLooks like they just enabled phishing / malware / etc sites that can target unsupervised kids and show innocuous content to everyone else.